Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I cooking shit or being stingy??

474 replies

Hydranga · 06/08/2026 13:44

Currently on holiday with my sister, her husband, their 8 year old DS Amanda 14 year old daughter

i had originally booked it for just me, DH and Ds (8) but I invited them last minute at no cost to them as sister was stressed about money and not being able to take the kids out.

They have complained non stop about the food. First evening we got a takeaway but first morning they asked what was for breakfast so I said I had porridge or Greek yogurt and fruit and nuts. BIL burst out laughing saying “so it’s either prison food or bird food?”. Sister said “don’t you have anything in for the kids?” So I said I’d got the porridge for the kids and I have honey, jam or Nutella to stir into it. Teen rolled her eyes and sister said “I’ll go to shop later and get something in”. Was it really so bad???

that evening I made spaghetti bolognese. 75g dry pasta each and a 600g pack of mince shared between us all with mushrooms, bacon and various veggies. When I served it BIL pulled a face and said where’s the rest of it? They all started laughing - teen dramatically pulled a bit up from her plate and let it fall back down slowly whilst pulling a face. Sister said “what’s up with you?” And teen said “it tastes funny”. They all laughed.

I was getting pissed off at this point and told them they’re welcome to buy and cook their own food if they’d prefer. BIL said “oh here we go, here’s the catch” so I said no I’m more than happy to carry on buying and cooking but not to be insulted and laughed at. DH then decided to tell everyone I’m always on weird diets which isn’t true, I have ibs so I do try and restrict certain things but he made it out to be about weight loss which it isn’t. DS said he likes the food and DN said “yeah but you’re used to eating crap”

So yesterday I refused to cook. They’d bought their own cereals but when it came to evening meal I told them I was cooking a curry for us 3 so they might want to pop to shop and get something in which they did and came back with dohnuts and loads of sweet food. Fair enough.

tonight sister had told me she can’t afford to go back to shop as they hadn’t budgeted for repeated shopping trips. I’ve told her I’m cooking paella and they’re welcome to join us without insults. She said she’d talk to them.

as of 10 minutes ago teen was still asking what was for dinner so she clearly daren’t tell her.

Am I really cooking shit or being stingy?? I’m starting to wonder if it’s me

OP posts:
faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 06/08/2026 17:05

@gayestgal is projecting a lot of her insecurities here and it's derailing the thread.
It is obviously not 'nasty' to offer 2 choices of breakfast and homecooked meals on a free holiday? But I have been called names by SIL who is very overweight, I think it is called "skinny shaming" on here sometimes.
What you have offered is fine OP and they are rude and ungrateful. It is a shame because when I experienced very similar it caused a long term cooling of the relationship which was a shame. Yes, I gave a free holiday, DH and I cooked all week and then then slagged us off to all and sundry who told us what had been said. This is how people are, and I am sorry your kindness has been taken for weakness and you have been treated so shabbily.
I hope you enjoy your Paella :)

Happyhettie · 06/08/2026 17:05

They are incredibly rude. I’m not surprised you’re fed up. It’s your holiday too and if they don’t like the food, they can do their own thing. Do they honestly think you’ll be cooking every meal for them to turn their noses up at? That’s just daft if they do!

member08713 · 06/08/2026 17:09

There’s nothing wrong with your food or your use of recommended portion sizes. You eat well and sensibly.
There’s everything wrong with the attitude of your sister, her husband and child. They have no right to expect you to skivvy and provide food to their sole satisfaction. To add insult to injury your sister’s now making you feel guilty that she can’t afford to shop locally. They’re ungrateful, rude, appalling and grabby CFs.
Your husband let you down badly and compounded the insults. I’d reproach him for this. Don’t let him take you for granted or humiliate you.
Apart from your DC they have all disrespected you.
Just cook for yourself and your DC from now on. Then perhaps they might appreciate you.
Resolve never to be so generous with a free holiday for them in future.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:09

faithfultoGeorgeMichael · 06/08/2026 17:05

@gayestgal is projecting a lot of her insecurities here and it's derailing the thread.
It is obviously not 'nasty' to offer 2 choices of breakfast and homecooked meals on a free holiday? But I have been called names by SIL who is very overweight, I think it is called "skinny shaming" on here sometimes.
What you have offered is fine OP and they are rude and ungrateful. It is a shame because when I experienced very similar it caused a long term cooling of the relationship which was a shame. Yes, I gave a free holiday, DH and I cooked all week and then then slagged us off to all and sundry who told us what had been said. This is how people are, and I am sorry your kindness has been taken for weakness and you have been treated so shabbily.
I hope you enjoy your Paella :)

Who said its nasty to offer the food choices the op has?

What insecurities, who said I am insecure?!

Youre making stuff up really. And, I answered the op's question. The thread hasnt been derailed at all, i am responding to those who feel the op is not being unreasonable, where as I think she is being unreasonable.

Sounds like youre projecting because of your reference to your sil's body type.

Catsandbikes · 06/08/2026 17:11

Justaquestionplease · 06/08/2026 13:56

They are being rude but 75g pasta each is a bit stingy imo

Nope, this is a standard serving

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:11

TunnocksOrDeath · 06/08/2026 17:04

You're pretty obsessed with the idea that bolognaise with veg in is watery. Sorry if that's the case in your house, but at the hands of someone who can cook, it just isn't. "Animal Fat" is not a synonym for "flavour" or "quality" in the kitchen of anyone who's cooking level gone past the level of a uni student in their first-year in halls.
Not everyone wants to live on grease and stodge - fine for those who do, but if they're invited on a free holiday and given free food, they should either raise the issue politely away from the dining table, or keep their traps shut and buy snacks during the day.

No but

Bologneise for 6, with 600g mince padded out with loads of veg and mushrooms, is going to be watery.

Providing a good, properly done bolognese with enough pasta and garlic bread availsble to feed a small nation, is good hosting for your guests. A few good meals on holiday doesnt a stodgy diet make.

The op was unreasonable in her meal offering, the family could've done things differently also.

Stompythedinosaur · 06/08/2026 17:13

They are incredibly rude and I wouldn't cook for them either.

The portion sizes might be a bit on the small side, especially if they're used to eating more. But there and many more polite ways they could have discussed that with you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/08/2026 17:13

Bloody hell! No good deed goes unpunished, as Elphaba says! 😂

YANBU at all.

They are extremely cheeky fuckers. If I’d got a free holiday I’d be expecting to contribute more than half of the food, to share the cooking 50:50 and certainly not complain.

And your DH joining in with them is something else!

The only thing is I’d do 100g pasta per person (excluding small children) but that’s a minor detail

IronEverything · 06/08/2026 17:13

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:09

Who said its nasty to offer the food choices the op has?

What insecurities, who said I am insecure?!

Youre making stuff up really. And, I answered the op's question. The thread hasnt been derailed at all, i am responding to those who feel the op is not being unreasonable, where as I think she is being unreasonable.

Sounds like youre projecting because of your reference to your sil's body type.

We get the picture that you want a big load of fatty, sugary crap. You'd be the perfect host for the SIL and her family.

Perhaps even a beige buffet?

ginasevern · 06/08/2026 17:15

@gayestgal "Honestly - if you have to break down the calorie contents of PORRIDGE offered to your guests - you are not being a good host.
Next time op, head to waitrose (or aldi) and pick up a load of breakfast stuff
Pastries
Pancakes
Bread
Bacon
Eggs
Sausages
Tomatoes
Black puddding if thats your thing
good butter
Fruit
Jam and marmalade
Lots of juice
Tea
Coffee (if youve got a machine/cafetière) - if not, offer to uber eats in a Starbucks"

I can't work out if you're being tongue in cheek or not. I seriously hope you are. Because otherwise it seems you actually think that the OP should not only pay for her sister's holiday but also feed her sister's husband and two kids for the entire week without a single contribution from them (which wasn't the deal). Not only that but she should also have the decency to head to Waitrose and buy quality ingredients to offer them a full English breakfast every day, including fruit juice, and naturally round it off by ordering Starbucks coffee for everyone. I mean, what the actual fuck.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:16

IronEverything · 06/08/2026 17:13

We get the picture that you want a big load of fatty, sugary crap. You'd be the perfect host for the SIL and her family.

Perhaps even a beige buffet?

All my food is well cooked, diverse and flavoursome. I like hosting so have a good time sourcing good ingredients etc

No beige crap in my home. You do know that eating food other than granola and mushrooms does not make you 'beige'

Greenandyellowday · 06/08/2026 17:16

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 14:53

I dont really know what to say, i am genuine 😕

Ive seen watery bolognese- which is what you get when you pad it out with mushrooms and veg

For your guests, who you know like a bit of food!

But quick (or fake) Bolognese is supposed to be made with vegetables. You start off by making a sofrito of sautéed onion, celery and carrot.

Bollihobs · 06/08/2026 17:16

Pinkflamingo10 · 06/08/2026 13:59

They’re so rude. And ungrateful.
however would serve way more than 75g pasta per person though and I use 750g mince for 5 people, so I think 500g mince for 7 people is a stretch especially when cooking for guests, there certainly wouldn’t be any seconds for anyone or enough for hungry children!

Edited

It was 600g plus mushrooms, bacon and vegetables with garlic bread as a side. Hardly stingy. Standard guide on dried pasta for an adult would be 75g per serving. And no point making enough for "seconds" if they were being rude about the "firsts".

OP your food sounds amazing, tasty and more than enough - dare I say it's a bit "above them"? Are they more takeaways, ready meals and trays of doughnuts types? Sod them, you do you and let them see to themselves food wise. And as for how they are speaking to you, I cut that off too - be nice or go home.

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:18

You’re very kind and doing them a generous favour. They are rude, entitled and poor parents.
I wouldn’t book them another bite.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:18

ginasevern · 06/08/2026 17:15

@gayestgal "Honestly - if you have to break down the calorie contents of PORRIDGE offered to your guests - you are not being a good host.
Next time op, head to waitrose (or aldi) and pick up a load of breakfast stuff
Pastries
Pancakes
Bread
Bacon
Eggs
Sausages
Tomatoes
Black puddding if thats your thing
good butter
Fruit
Jam and marmalade
Lots of juice
Tea
Coffee (if youve got a machine/cafetière) - if not, offer to uber eats in a Starbucks"

I can't work out if you're being tongue in cheek or not. I seriously hope you are. Because otherwise it seems you actually think that the OP should not only pay for her sister's holiday but also feed her sister's husband and two kids for the entire week without a single contribution from them (which wasn't the deal). Not only that but she should also have the decency to head to Waitrose and buy quality ingredients to offer them a full English breakfast every day, including fruit juice, and naturally round it off by ordering Starbucks coffee for everyone. I mean, what the actual fuck.

Thats not what I said - i have repeatedly said that the guests should have insisted on buying the food, should offer to cook half the time.

But yes, you'd be a good host and offer this, imo, as youve invited someone to your rented holiday home.

Had she invited them to a hotel, I would be saying something different.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/08/2026 17:18

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:11

No but

Bologneise for 6, with 600g mince padded out with loads of veg and mushrooms, is going to be watery.

Providing a good, properly done bolognese with enough pasta and garlic bread availsble to feed a small nation, is good hosting for your guests. A few good meals on holiday doesnt a stodgy diet make.

The op was unreasonable in her meal offering, the family could've done things differently also.

I don’t understand how vegetables (including mushrooms) make something watery!

I’m a vegetarian and my food isn’t watery - I always have to watch my bolognese to make sure it doesn’t go too thick. And when I used to make pasta sauces with a mix of meat and some veggies it still wasn’t watery! It’s only watery if you put loads of stock and then don’t take the time to reduce it, surely?

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:19

Bollihobs · 06/08/2026 17:16

It was 600g plus mushrooms, bacon and vegetables with garlic bread as a side. Hardly stingy. Standard guide on dried pasta for an adult would be 75g per serving. And no point making enough for "seconds" if they were being rude about the "firsts".

OP your food sounds amazing, tasty and more than enough - dare I say it's a bit "above them"? Are they more takeaways, ready meals and trays of doughnuts types? Sod them, you do you and let them see to themselves food wise. And as for how they are speaking to you, I cut that off too - be nice or go home.

Edited

Porridge and mushrooms make you 'above' someone?!

No need to look down your nose at people

BobbysDazzler · 06/08/2026 17:19

I think its the family who are the problem and are being ungrateful and rude. If they don't like it then buy and cook their own, you have given them a free holiday, you can't be expected to supply everything else as well surely?!

theneighboureatmysalad · 06/08/2026 17:23

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:19

Porridge and mushrooms make you 'above' someone?!

No need to look down your nose at people

Edited

we get it, YOU are the sister.

It's more than acceptable to look down at people as rude as sister and her family are.

Badgerstmary · 06/08/2026 17:24

Op your food sounds delicious & just the sort of food we cook. It was incredibly rude of them to complain about what you are paying for & cooking for them.
You say they had already bought their weeks shopping & it was mostly frozen. What do they normally eat in a typical day? Was there no meat, fish, fruit, veg, carbs they could have brought with them? If this is the case then your delicious , healthy food must have been a shock for them.
En joy your paella.

Dragonflyspeeding · 06/08/2026 17:26

They are being rude BUT the spag Bol portions seem very small tbh.

I don’t understand why they can’t shop and cook alternative evenings. It really isn’t fair for one person to do it every day.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:26

theneighboureatmysalad · 06/08/2026 17:23

we get it, YOU are the sister.

It's more than acceptable to look down at people as rude as sister and her family are.

I am not 🤣

I have hosted people and so offer advice on that basis

And it really isnt okay to imply that someone isnt as good as you because they want feeding on their holidays

Babyboomtastic · 06/08/2026 17:27

Greenandyellowday · 06/08/2026 17:16

But quick (or fake) Bolognese is supposed to be made with vegetables. You start off by making a sofrito of sautéed onion, celery and carrot.

Absolutely. But not mushrooms and 'various veggies'. Mushrooms in Bolognese are more contentious than pineapple on pizza, and the sort of ingredient that many people (especially kids) went like. Bolognese shouldn't just be used as coffee for beefy pasta sauce with random other ingredients thrown in.

Personally, I think mushrooms in Bolognese are an abomination! And not even having a loaf of bread for toast at breakfast is IMO odd.

If I was catering for another family as well as my own, I'd discuss the meal plan and dietary stuff in advance personally.

This doesn't excuse the rudeness of the SIL and family though.

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:28

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 14:28

How?!

Mushroom and veggies in a bolognese for guests!

I understand if its a quick weeknight dinner for the kids

Whats yours then?

I learned from an Italian chef how to make proper ragu (bolognaise). For depth of flavour it has mushrooms, celery, carrots, herbs and pancetta as well as meat tomatoes and onions. That’s the correct way to make it. What’s often offered up in the UK bears NO resemblance.

gayestgal · 06/08/2026 17:29

ThisOneLife · 06/08/2026 17:28

I learned from an Italian chef how to make proper ragu (bolognaise). For depth of flavour it has mushrooms, celery, carrots, herbs and pancetta as well as meat tomatoes and onions. That’s the correct way to make it. What’s often offered up in the UK bears NO resemblance.

The proper italian chef i knew would be disgusted, and states that only a soffrito is the veg needed.