Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Job market is awful

356 replies

Flowerpowerz · 03/08/2026 19:34

I work in pharma (general field) and the job market is horrendous. I’m seeing a huge trend towards AI which is not surprising. Perhaps more concerning is the massive uptick of offshore partners aka shipping work out to India because they are cheaper than people in the uk and USA. I have several friends in several related companies (technology, IT, coding) that have lost jobs due to this. They are being expected to share knowledge with their Indian colleagues before their redundancy kicks in.

I have honestly never known it so bad. My linked in is a sea of “open to work”

is it just me or has anyone else noticed these trends? It’s worse than ever

OP posts:
user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 19:05

People are too fussy and don't do shift work. DH works in the rail industry doing shifts and there are always vacancies. Does night shift, back shift and early shift on rotation. You just get on with it. It does interfere with family life but working 9 til 5 type jobs are problematic in their own way too. He is often around to help with bed time routine, can go to school assemblies during the day etc if on a rest day.

Also there are loads of manufacturing jobs. DS aged 19 is currently doing 10 hrs shifts 4 days a week at a bakery. Often standing for long periods of time on the production line. But he earns okay for his age. Often clearing £350 each week. He got this work through an agency. Anyone can do this. He has worked various shift patterns such as 7am til 5.15, 10 til 6pm, and 10 til 8pm.

Too many fussy people out there.

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:12

user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 19:05

People are too fussy and don't do shift work. DH works in the rail industry doing shifts and there are always vacancies. Does night shift, back shift and early shift on rotation. You just get on with it. It does interfere with family life but working 9 til 5 type jobs are problematic in their own way too. He is often around to help with bed time routine, can go to school assemblies during the day etc if on a rest day.

Also there are loads of manufacturing jobs. DS aged 19 is currently doing 10 hrs shifts 4 days a week at a bakery. Often standing for long periods of time on the production line. But he earns okay for his age. Often clearing £350 each week. He got this work through an agency. Anyone can do this. He has worked various shift patterns such as 7am til 5.15, 10 til 6pm, and 10 til 8pm.

Too many fussy people out there.

What does your DH do? It is all well and good saying there are always vacancies, but if you need multiple qualifications and years of experience to do the job then it is not going to be something that everyone is applying for.
I don't think a rail industry job is going to be some entry level role somehow.

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:15

user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 19:05

People are too fussy and don't do shift work. DH works in the rail industry doing shifts and there are always vacancies. Does night shift, back shift and early shift on rotation. You just get on with it. It does interfere with family life but working 9 til 5 type jobs are problematic in their own way too. He is often around to help with bed time routine, can go to school assemblies during the day etc if on a rest day.

Also there are loads of manufacturing jobs. DS aged 19 is currently doing 10 hrs shifts 4 days a week at a bakery. Often standing for long periods of time on the production line. But he earns okay for his age. Often clearing £350 each week. He got this work through an agency. Anyone can do this. He has worked various shift patterns such as 7am til 5.15, 10 til 6pm, and 10 til 8pm.

Too many fussy people out there.

£350 for 40 hours.... That is £8.75ph. That is not legal.

ThePeppyOpalScroller · 04/08/2026 19:20

Nutmuncher · 04/08/2026 17:27

Plenty of people work as volunteers today, doing charity work for free. Plenty of people love their jobs and relish having a purpose through work. There will still be a cohort of society who would do anything over not working at all. There will still be highly paid human roles, controlling the AI, robots and the systems. I think before UBI or UHI we will see the shift towards shorter working weeks for many sectors, 3 day weeks will be common in the next 18-24 months.

It’s also going to be a good 4/5 years before people are comfortable having a robot carer or nurse so many jobs will stay human centric out of necessity for the human touch initially. Let’s not forget that the new world we’re entering is going to be filled with an abundance of new opportunities just as the internet brought with it influencers, online retailers and service providers, new careers will blossom.

I disagree.

SpaceRaccoon · 04/08/2026 19:25

amala18 · 04/08/2026 14:20

Earth is hard isn't it.

I grew up in poverty of money, and total poverty of love, which I think is the real poverty. No one cared about me

However I think I can't really complain as at least I didn't grow up in a war torn country. So many people have it so hard.

I do sometimes wonder: is the child in a really poor but loving family in Africa, more unhappy than a child in a family that is less poor in Europe but who's parents don't love them. We all go through so much. Just being alive is hard

I can answer this. I grew up in Africa, there was and still is widespread absolute poverty and most of the children seem happier than here in the UK.

Boudy · 04/08/2026 19:26

@user1476613140 my 2 sons aren't fussy. They have applied for these sort of roles. Ds1 worked a rolling rota in one of his temp jobs,starting at 5am. Please don't make sweeping statements

Shatenoeuf · 04/08/2026 19:33

As Elon said "it turns out you dont need that many people".

Ah..but Elon is wrong.

Without people there is no end customer. All that "productivity" he wants to generate, its all worthless without an end customer who needs/wants (and has the money) to buy good and services. Even if a business's direct customer is AI/robot, that robot is in a supply chain that ultimately ends with people buying stuff.

No people... no demand.

And the people need to have money to buy.

Shatenoeuf · 04/08/2026 19:35

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:15

£350 for 40 hours.... That is £8.75ph. That is not legal.

Could be if he is on an apprentice wage.

amala18 · 04/08/2026 19:45

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:15

£350 for 40 hours.... That is £8.75ph. That is not legal.

It is legal if you are an apprentice.

x2boys · 04/08/2026 19:53

user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 19:05

People are too fussy and don't do shift work. DH works in the rail industry doing shifts and there are always vacancies. Does night shift, back shift and early shift on rotation. You just get on with it. It does interfere with family life but working 9 til 5 type jobs are problematic in their own way too. He is often around to help with bed time routine, can go to school assemblies during the day etc if on a rest day.

Also there are loads of manufacturing jobs. DS aged 19 is currently doing 10 hrs shifts 4 days a week at a bakery. Often standing for long periods of time on the production line. But he earns okay for his age. Often clearing £350 each week. He got this work through an agency. Anyone can do this. He has worked various shift patterns such as 7am til 5.15, 10 til 6pm, and 10 til 8pm.

Too many fussy people out there.

Theres not enough jobs our there ny 19 year old is willing to work any hours and hss sent off loads of applications but heard nothing back.

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:54

amala18 · 04/08/2026 19:45

It is legal if you are an apprentice.

I thought apprenticeships had to pay at least NMW.
I remember seeing one for £3.54ph (was a few years ago though), and I got shit on here for not applying for it (it was a year long one for learning to make tea!).

Dorisbonson · 04/08/2026 19:57

Cars4Gov · 04/08/2026 07:46

UBI will be a necessity for the millions unable to find work

Don't we have this already with the benefits system? The country is struggling to pay for existing claimants at the current level let alone enhanced payments for more people.

Generally, people have ignored the news when it's announced that UK productivity is very poor, this leads to less companies wanted to invest in the UK, which leads to the GDP growth at currently is almost zero. Without growth there are no jobs.

The recent increase in NI without a doubt impacted employers, mine reversed hiring as they felt the decisions by Labour, especially rushing through the changes without a period of notice meant the UK was not a safe place to invest.

The lack of stability in UK finances due to government spending is a major factor as borrowing costs rise so impacts employers.

Labour can't make the UK finances stable as the voter base won't allow it...which is why most people are pessimistic

Construction is a UK sector that has less risk of AI but rarely considered by UK people. Someone else mentioned that machine drivers are highly in demand. Also military roles, not everything is combat as many areas which could appeal to active young people.

I think the volume of Uni students does have to reverse. I've hired many students with degrees that didn't provide enough (or any skills) for the job market.

You should see the robots China are making. They can lay bricks, plaster walls, paint, fold clothes - all kinds of tasks requiring hand eye coordination and manual dexterity. They used to struggle with uneven surfaces but can run marathons now. When they can climb ladders they will be roofing. These machines are less than $50k USD today and work without breaks.

China is developing dark factories (no lights because no humans) to produce cars.

Robots are mining and automation is reducing humans involved in port operations.

The European/Japanese/ Chinese demographic trend towards lower population levels and higher levels of education seems beneficial in this context.

During the industrial revolution high wages in the UK were a driver towards factory adoption. It was a disaster for workers living standards in the short term - shorter heights, life expectancy etc - hogarths gin lane. Then factories led to the eventual creation of the middle class - it took decades though. Blake's phrase in Jerusalem: Dark Satanic Mills is due to the impact of mills on employment.

Understanding AI and how to use it is the best defense against losing your job to it.

amala18 · 04/08/2026 20:15

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:54

I thought apprenticeships had to pay at least NMW.
I remember seeing one for £3.54ph (was a few years ago though), and I got shit on here for not applying for it (it was a year long one for learning to make tea!).

it is the minimum wage for apprenticeships. the minimum wage changes for age aswell.

I believe the poster said that her son is 19 so for his age/an apprenticeship it is correct

Backedoffhackedoff · 04/08/2026 20:29

curiositykilledthiscat · 04/08/2026 18:46

Not all of unemployed people are paying mortgages.

Also repossessions are the highest they’ve been for a while according to the most recent figures:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cj0e0jjz88ro

Well obviously not all unemployed people have mortgages, but we know how renters pay their rent when unemployed, so it wasn’t a question.

Repossession are at their highest for 5 years but it’s a very slow increase and they are still low.

user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 20:59

XenoBitch · 04/08/2026 19:15

£350 for 40 hours.... That is £8.75ph. That is not legal.

It's after tax and the agency take a cut.

user1476613140 · 04/08/2026 21:03

x2boys · 04/08/2026 19:53

Theres not enough jobs our there ny 19 year old is willing to work any hours and hss sent off loads of applications but heard nothing back.

Try an employment agency. DS honestly just kept applying and just last month was phoned back by an agency who wanted him to come into the office and sort out his paperwork and the following week he had a job helping move furniture for his first shift. Then the next one he did not like so contacted the agency to let them know this (12 hr shift packing boxes). Since then he's been offered shifts in a local bakery and he isn't ecstatic about the work but it is helping pay his first insurance policy for his car. And has helped him pay for repairs on his car so it could pass its M.O.T. last month. Hopefully your DS gets something soon 🤞

LooneyLiberalSpaceWaster · 04/08/2026 23:56

Shatenoeuf · 04/08/2026 19:33

As Elon said "it turns out you dont need that many people".

Ah..but Elon is wrong.

Without people there is no end customer. All that "productivity" he wants to generate, its all worthless without an end customer who needs/wants (and has the money) to buy good and services. Even if a business's direct customer is AI/robot, that robot is in a supply chain that ultimately ends with people buying stuff.

No people... no demand.

And the people need to have money to buy.

Yep.

But Elon also mentioned UBI.

He said UBI doesn't necessarily cause inflation. Governments and banks leverage money into being all the time. When money is created it can lead to inflation-but does so because this money is not equal to the commodities produced. I don't subscribe to mainstream economics or believe in supply and demand models, however on this point I agree with Musk.

This is why I think the owners of the means of production will be instrumental in demanding that governments step in to ensure that demand exists. One demand could well be UBI.

Capitalism collapses just as soon as human labour is no longer exploited to create surplus value.

I think there is an inevitability that AI and automation used in search of greater surplus value driven by the inner logic of competition pushes capitalism towards a point of collapse.

Marx wrote

'As soon as labour in its immediate form has ceased to be the great source of wealth, labour time ceases and must cease to be its measure, and therefore exchange value [must cease to be the measure] of use value. The surplus labour of the masses has ceased to be the condition for the development of general wealth, just as the non-labour of a few has ceased to be the condition for the development of the general powers of the human mind. As a result, production based upon exchange value collapses' This was written in 1870! So we certainly are not in this mess because of Covid, or labour.

If capitalism is defined as exploitation of labour in pursuit of profit, then AI and automation undermines capital and as you say creates crisis. The ultimate crisis is of course a huge heap of 'use values' that would meet human need sitting alongside the fact that there is no demand. But then Marx also wrote about this....

Basically I think when we try to think about a post work society we are thinking that work is only work when we are employed and paid, and secondly thinking within the paradigm of mainstream economics.

I am not a great fan of UBI, but I think it will become necessary. But I don't think that is the end point. Because once human labour is not exploited for surplus value, then commodities are reduced from having both use and exchange value. At that point you have transitioned to communism. (not state socialism ie Soviet Russia, or China, since that is not communism).

Palomiino · 05/08/2026 05:19

Shatenoeuf · 04/08/2026 19:33

As Elon said "it turns out you dont need that many people".

Ah..but Elon is wrong.

Without people there is no end customer. All that "productivity" he wants to generate, its all worthless without an end customer who needs/wants (and has the money) to buy good and services. Even if a business's direct customer is AI/robot, that robot is in a supply chain that ultimately ends with people buying stuff.

No people... no demand.

And the people need to have money to buy.

Well said. Elon Musk is a drug-addled fool.

DidVeryWell · 05/08/2026 08:31

Bigfatsquirrel · 04/08/2026 15:57

The government has a lot to answer for. Huge increase in regulation (employment rights act) and cost to hire people (min wage, national insurance). Then they wonder why youth unemployment has sky rocketed and the grad market is in the doldrums plus huge reduction in vacancies generally. Until this gets fixed expect things to keep getting worse - more tax rises coming in the October budget. But it’s ok cos Andy has cut bus fares to £2 (where they were when they took office) and given us all £45 off electricity (even though the price cap is increasing by around £150). They take us for fools - and now the proposal is an extra 1.8% levy (tax) on earnings above £6500 to pay for social care. There’s never any discussion about cutting spending is there from this lot. Just looking to tax people more. And then they wonder why businesses don’t want to hire people - the economy is not growing and Labour have no plan to get it growing (hopefully the fake solicitor now in charge of the Business Dept will have a think about that!)

They take us for fools - and now the proposal is an extra 1.8% levy (tax) on earnings above £6500 to pay for social care. There’s never any discussion about cutting spending is there from this lot.

How do you suggest social care is funded?
Which areas should have spending cuts?

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 08:44

I have encouraged DS aged 19 to not save up for a mortgage and put his name down on council housing list. Yes, it will take time but he will have a house for life. You get all your repairs done for you.

There's just no incentive now for young ones to buy up property and have a mortgage to their name.

And it's getting more and more out of reach for them. How on earth can they save up when many can't even get a decent job?

Seymour5 · 05/08/2026 09:15

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 08:44

I have encouraged DS aged 19 to not save up for a mortgage and put his name down on council housing list. Yes, it will take time but he will have a house for life. You get all your repairs done for you.

There's just no incentive now for young ones to buy up property and have a mortgage to their name.

And it's getting more and more out of reach for them. How on earth can they save up when many can't even get a decent job?

Edited

Trillions of £ are going to be inherited over the next 20+ years as my generation dies off. My friends are all 70+ and we own our homes. Not expensive London properties, but at least £150k+. For those of us that don’t end up in expensive care homes, our middle aged children (who really don’t need it) will probably use it to help our grandchildren with housing.

Most of us started with nothing, council house upbringing in many cases, and got no or little inheritance. We encouraged our children to take opportunities that weren’t there for us. Perhaps those who like to have a go at boomers for ‘having it all’ will be glad we took the then unknown risk of buying houses when they get a nice windfall.

DidVeryWell · 05/08/2026 09:41

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 08:44

I have encouraged DS aged 19 to not save up for a mortgage and put his name down on council housing list. Yes, it will take time but he will have a house for life. You get all your repairs done for you.

There's just no incentive now for young ones to buy up property and have a mortgage to their name.

And it's getting more and more out of reach for them. How on earth can they save up when many can't even get a decent job?

Edited

I’m not sure it is as easy as that!

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 09:42

Seymour5 · 05/08/2026 09:15

Trillions of £ are going to be inherited over the next 20+ years as my generation dies off. My friends are all 70+ and we own our homes. Not expensive London properties, but at least £150k+. For those of us that don’t end up in expensive care homes, our middle aged children (who really don’t need it) will probably use it to help our grandchildren with housing.

Most of us started with nothing, council house upbringing in many cases, and got no or little inheritance. We encouraged our children to take opportunities that weren’t there for us. Perhaps those who like to have a go at boomers for ‘having it all’ will be glad we took the then unknown risk of buying houses when they get a nice windfall.

Edited

I can assure you although we're not destitute ourselves, we will have little to leave all 4 DC. They'll have to make their own way in the world. As for their grandparents, well, they may leave each of them something. I don't know. But we're not counting on that. Best to assume you get nothing then there's no disappointment.

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 09:45

DidVeryWell · 05/08/2026 09:41

I’m not sure it is as easy as that!

It's a damn sight easier if you have additional needs which my eldest does have. I am sure it's a points based system.

Owning property just means you have your assets seized to pay for your care later on. That cannot happen if you're a council tenant.

x2boys · 05/08/2026 09:49

user1476613140 · 05/08/2026 09:45

It's a damn sight easier if you have additional needs which my eldest does have. I am sure it's a points based system.

Owning property just means you have your assets seized to pay for your care later on. That cannot happen if you're a council tenant.

Its not really it depends on what properties are available
Even with priorty you can be waiting years.