Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be deeply concerned about the recent influx of 30k+ undocumented arrivals in Spain?

736 replies

ChirpyUmberBiscuit · 31/07/2026 13:17

AIBU to feel really unsettled by the recent news coming out of Spain and Ceuta? Reports are showing that tens of thousands of undocumented migrants have crossed over in such a short window, completely overwhelming local infrastructure, reception centers, and security forces.

I know migration is always a sensitive and compassionate topic, but looking at these numbers practically, I don't see how any European border region can absorb 30,000 to 50,000 arrivals almost overnight without severe strain on public resources, local housing, and emergency services.

What worries me even more is the precedent it sets for the rest of Europe and the UK down the line. Surely there has to be a firm balance between humanitarian support and actual, enforceable border control?

Am I being completely unreasonable to view this as a serious policy and security crisis, or are others feeling equally concerned about where this leads?

Would love to hear honest thoughts on how this should actually be handled!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
38thparallel · 02/08/2026 18:21

Who provided the thousands of rubber rings? It must have been a plan organised some time in advance.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 02/08/2026 18:13

People also dont have to say they like the UK to seek asylum, asylum is sought on the basis of the person being at risk in their home country, so no one has to say the 'right things' as its implied here that they love the UK and all our ways

I don't think many here are thinking of a professed love of the UK being one of the "right things to say", likelysuspect, and certainly it's not been included on the coaching notes I've seen handed out by migrant supporters

The suggested claims on those were more along the lines of "my father's been shot, my sister raped and my brother chucked down a well", though I'm told that insisting they've been persecuted for being gay has fallen out of favour since many don't even want to pretend that

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 17:23

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:58

Common Nationalities: According to data from advocacy groups like Refugee Action, nearly two-thirds of the most common nationalities applying for asylum in the UK come from countries with colonial links or a history of British resource extraction and conflict.

I'm done.

They dont come because of that reason though?

Given the vast majority of asylum seekers in the world do not come to the UK, how is this relevant.

Our empire and colonies were wide spread, so it stands to reason that many countries throughout the world had some sort of British link (even if tenuous), it doesnt mean people choose the UK simply because of the empire.

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 17:20

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 17:16

Im not here to give 'excuses' for people being here. There are strict categories of asylum application, but you can choose to seek asylum in any country you choose, that is the law, you dont have to claim asylum in the first country you come to

Most asylum seekers world wide dont come here, dont even want to come here.

Im just giving feedback on my knowledge from working with asylum seekers for those particular people

People being interviewed are as much of a representation as any group or gaggle of people being interviewed with simple soundbites

Well thank you. I appreciate your level headed responses throughout this thread and your ability to see both sides of the argument. But from what you’ve said, it pretty much has confirmed what many of us on this thread have been saying. That they don’t care about our culture or integrating and that they come here because we are “tolerant” and the likes of the woke left, the greens, along with the Antifa and Stand Up to Racism mob bleating “say it loud, say it clear, refugees are welcome here” will always defend them no matter what horrific crimes they commit. You have further confirmed that by saying they can claim asylum in any country they choose, that’s very true… but there are thousands queuing up to come here over the channel and paying high sums of money to do so. Many may not come to the the UK but there is a reason why a huge majority of them who choose to come to the UK go to such lengths to do so.

As you can see, Ceuta didn’t welcome them with open arms. A lot of them have gone back now, even though they went to great lengths to get there, some even dying in the process…. But they didn’t get the welcome they wanted.

IfNot · 02/08/2026 17:17

Firetreev · 02/08/2026 17:02

You definitely need a duvet day to go and inform yourself properly. Ceuta is in Africa and not in the European continent. The OP is blowing this out of proportion. These immigrants haven't left Africa ffs.

Again. Ceuta is part of Spain. Geographically it it on the continent of Africa. Just like geographically the Canaries are FAR from mainland Spain, and closer to Africa.
Both Spain.
Ceuta has never been part of Morroco. The population is Spanish, and wish to be Spanish.
The 50k men breached the border of Spain.
It’s bog all to do with “colonisation” unless we are going back to the Romans..?
I wish people would not turn everything into a game of Opressed and Oppressor. The world actually is more nuanced than that.

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 17:16

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 17:06

“I think some of that has some validity by a bit of a stretch, the reality is that people that really have no time for UK values, dont come here, they stay in the ME or other African countries, they have no interest in living in this society”

Yet they want to come here… with little to no interest in integrating into our culture because they have no interest in it. But they want to come here because we are “tolerant”.

”People also dont have to say they like the UK to seek asylum, asylum is sought on the basis of the person being at risk in their home country, so no one has to say the 'right things' as its implied here that they love the UK and all our ways.”

No they don’t have to say they like England but a lot of the reasons you’re giving aren’t much of an excuse for them being here. They have passed through multiple safe countries to get here and risked their lives crossing the channel.
I’ve watched various people interviewing them asking why they came to England and it’s almost always the same generic answer “We like England”, “We love England”, “England good” and you can just tell they’re being false, it’s not coming from their heart for a lot of them.

Im not here to give 'excuses' for people being here. There are strict categories of asylum application, but you can choose to seek asylum in any country you choose, that is the law, you dont have to claim asylum in the first country you come to

Most asylum seekers world wide dont come here, dont even want to come here.

Im just giving feedback on my knowledge from working with asylum seekers for those particular people

People being interviewed are as much of a representation as any group or gaggle of people being interviewed with simple soundbites

ShautyMels · 02/08/2026 17:13

Properjob · 02/08/2026 14:29

Well its been like that since the 80s when I lived there but of course the Tories slashed all the low cost English courses that helped particularly the women to learn.

Perhaps they should have already known the language of they are full time residents. There's also plenty of free classes and material online.

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 17:06

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 17:00

I think some of that has some validity by a bit of a stretch, the reality is that people that really have no time for UK values, dont come here, they stay in the ME or other African countries, they have no interest in living in this society

People also dont have to say they like the UK to seek asylum, asylum is sought on the basis of the person being at risk in their home country, so no one has to say the 'right things' as its implied here that they love the UK and all our ways.

I think many do have a genuine shock about what is expected of men in particular, culture about equality in terms of sex, not ethnicity. When there is a view given about tolerance from an incomer, what they mean is tolerance for them to thrive, progress, get jobs etc, its not about sex equality or sexuality tolerance and that can come as a bit of a surprise to them.

“I think some of that has some validity by a bit of a stretch, the reality is that people that really have no time for UK values, dont come here, they stay in the ME or other African countries, they have no interest in living in this society”

Yet they want to come here… with little to no interest in integrating into our culture because they have no interest in it. But they want to come here because we are “tolerant”.

”People also dont have to say they like the UK to seek asylum, asylum is sought on the basis of the person being at risk in their home country, so no one has to say the 'right things' as its implied here that they love the UK and all our ways.”

No they don’t have to say they like England but a lot of the reasons you’re giving aren’t much of an excuse for them being here. They have passed through multiple safe countries to get here and risked their lives crossing the channel.
I’ve watched various people interviewing them asking why they came to England and it’s almost always the same generic answer “We like England”, “We love England”, “England good” and you can just tell they’re being false, it’s not coming from their heart for a lot of them.

Firetreev · 02/08/2026 17:02

Duvetdayneeded · 31/07/2026 13:27

It’s now documented to be about 49,000 and it is absolute fuck up for the UK as they are in the majority going to come to our country because we give them such a free ride. I Stress I don’t mind genuine asylum seekers, but these are economic immigrants and we are fucked. We need to cease almost all foreign aid because our country is going to the toilet.

You definitely need a duvet day to go and inform yourself properly. Ceuta is in Africa and not in the European continent. The OP is blowing this out of proportion. These immigrants haven't left Africa ffs.

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 17:00

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:58

Common Nationalities: According to data from advocacy groups like Refugee Action, nearly two-thirds of the most common nationalities applying for asylum in the UK come from countries with colonial links or a history of British resource extraction and conflict.

I'm done.

As the pp above has said, they come here because we are more “tolerant”. That’s basically it. They know they will be welcomed with open arms

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 17:00

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 16:46

And this is the issue - a lot of them are not “tolerant” of our culture or values yet they like that we are tolerant of them.
And while ever the lefty woke are calling concerned British citizens “racist”, they know they will have the likes of certain people on this thread, Antifa and stand up to racism who welcome them with open arms because they are “tolerant”.
It seems more of a manipulation tactic used by many boat migrants more than anything. You can’t claim to want to live in England and love England, then go raping and murdering its citizens. Obviously not all of them are doing this but it does seem a lot are saying the “right things” in order to get to stay here.

Edited

I think some of that has some validity by a bit of a stretch, the reality is that people that really have no time for UK values, dont come here, they stay in the ME or other African countries, they have no interest in living in this society

People also dont have to say they like the UK to seek asylum, asylum is sought on the basis of the person being at risk in their home country, so no one has to say the 'right things' as its implied here that they love the UK and all our ways.

I think many do have a genuine shock about what is expected of men in particular, culture about equality in terms of sex, not ethnicity. When there is a view given about tolerance from an incomer, what they mean is tolerance for them to thrive, progress, get jobs etc, its not about sex equality or sexuality tolerance and that can come as a bit of a surprise to them.

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 16:59

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:58

Common Nationalities: According to data from advocacy groups like Refugee Action, nearly two-thirds of the most common nationalities applying for asylum in the UK come from countries with colonial links or a history of British resource extraction and conflict.

I'm done.

And again, absolutely NOT AN EXCUSE TO CLAIM ASYLUM HERE! So defend it all you like. It’s not going to change my mind.

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:58

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 16:26

Still doesn’t answer why you think colonisation is relevant. Maybe the English should start crossing the channel over to France because of the battle of Hastings in 1066. Absolutely no logic whatsoever and anyone spouting this daft ideology as an excuse for boat migrants to come to England needs to give their head a wobble!

Common Nationalities: According to data from advocacy groups like Refugee Action, nearly two-thirds of the most common nationalities applying for asylum in the UK come from countries with colonial links or a history of British resource extraction and conflict.

I'm done.

Facts about refugees and asylum seekers

What's the difference between a refugee and an asylum seeker? Should people claim asylum in the first safe country they reach? We answer some of the most frequently asked questions about refugees.

https://www.refugee-action.org.uk/about/facts-about-refugees/

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 16:46

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 16:28

Oh Cuenta, yes, different demographic to assylum seekers in the UK

Many are coming to the UK though because the UK is more tolerant, that is a fact for many African and ME people. No country is paved with gold, its not so much about that, but there is more equality here for peole who come here from abroad to the usual other European countries (Im talking generally obviously and from my experience of what asylum seekers have experienced)

And this is the issue - a lot of them are not “tolerant” of our culture or values yet they like that we are tolerant of them.
And while ever the lefty woke are calling concerned British citizens “racist”, they know they will have the likes of certain people on this thread, Antifa and stand up to racism who welcome them with open arms because they are “tolerant”.
It seems more of a manipulation tactic used by many boat migrants more than anything. You can’t claim to want to live in England and love England, then go raping and murdering its citizens. Obviously not all of them are doing this but it does seem a lot are saying the “right things” in order to get to stay here.

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 16:28

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:05

I don't have the energy for an argument. The whole topic is extremely complex and emotionally charged. I surmise that some young people who were in Cuenta were risk takers.

I have talked to people seeking asylum who held England in high regard, misguided at best.
Its a worrying situation. Vulnerability and the sort of rage we see expressed in many places.

Oh Cuenta, yes, different demographic to assylum seekers in the UK

Many are coming to the UK though because the UK is more tolerant, that is a fact for many African and ME people. No country is paved with gold, its not so much about that, but there is more equality here for peole who come here from abroad to the usual other European countries (Im talking generally obviously and from my experience of what asylum seekers have experienced)

Flyingintotheunknown · 02/08/2026 16:26

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:05

I don't have the energy for an argument. The whole topic is extremely complex and emotionally charged. I surmise that some young people who were in Cuenta were risk takers.

I have talked to people seeking asylum who held England in high regard, misguided at best.
Its a worrying situation. Vulnerability and the sort of rage we see expressed in many places.

Still doesn’t answer why you think colonisation is relevant. Maybe the English should start crossing the channel over to France because of the battle of Hastings in 1066. Absolutely no logic whatsoever and anyone spouting this daft ideology as an excuse for boat migrants to come to England needs to give their head a wobble!

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 16:25

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2026 15:45

I don’t know - obviously there was no information available, only that he was a recent arrival and had no parents with him. As I said, he was a pleasant young man but most certainly not school age by a long way. This wasn’t just my opinion!

It made for a strange situation since we had to treat him like a 17 year old. He moved on, or was moved on, after a few weeks.

Yes very likely age disputed and therefore moved on to NAAS

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 16:05

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 15:38

In what context?

Im baffled quite honestly by some of the reasoning about earlier colonisation, young people being risk takers, reinvention of oneself etc

Many of the young people are utterly traumatised by the journey and the pressure they're under having come here, they havent come here to take some sort of life adventure like a middle class gap year traveller.

What relevance do you think colonisation has to decision making for families? Most are not au fait with their own country's history and current politics believe it or not, let alone ours.

I don't have the energy for an argument. The whole topic is extremely complex and emotionally charged. I surmise that some young people who were in Cuenta were risk takers.

I have talked to people seeking asylum who held England in high regard, misguided at best.
Its a worrying situation. Vulnerability and the sort of rage we see expressed in many places.

CoffeeCantata · 02/08/2026 15:45

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 14:38

Im not sure if you mean he pretended to be a child so he could join family here? Children who apply outside of the country to come to join family here are subject to huge scrutiny, they need proper documentation, they come via immigration and the Home Office, subject to various assessments so its not likely that someone saying they're the child of Mr and Mrs X aged 17 is really their grown up son aged 30

But some people come to the UK and arrive at ports via sea crossings and say they're 17 when they might be older, usually young people come into the care system with age disputed already by the Home Office and then age assessments have to be completed. They're not terriby reliable, easy to 'prove' and 'disprove'. Its not really easy to say 'he's not 17, he's 19'. Think about how many teens you could interview and say that about?

I don’t know - obviously there was no information available, only that he was a recent arrival and had no parents with him. As I said, he was a pleasant young man but most certainly not school age by a long way. This wasn’t just my opinion!

It made for a strange situation since we had to treat him like a 17 year old. He moved on, or was moved on, after a few weeks.

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 15:38

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 15:35

I have.

In what context?

Im baffled quite honestly by some of the reasoning about earlier colonisation, young people being risk takers, reinvention of oneself etc

Many of the young people are utterly traumatised by the journey and the pressure they're under having come here, they havent come here to take some sort of life adventure like a middle class gap year traveller.

What relevance do you think colonisation has to decision making for families? Most are not au fait with their own country's history and current politics believe it or not, let alone ours.

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 15:35

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 14:44

Do you work with asylum seekers?

I have.

Violetdeparma · 02/08/2026 15:30

Properjob · 02/08/2026 14:29

Well its been like that since the 80s when I lived there but of course the Tories slashed all the low cost English courses that helped particularly the women to learn.

That's sad but why do they need low cost courses do learn ? I assume they are on spousal working visas and they can afford their own English class ?

If they have succesfully claimed assluym then yes they should get help with classes.

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 14:47

Fredabasset · 02/08/2026 12:42

Well they certainly aren't slashing them or impounding them are they? {Despite what we (UK) are paying them.}

The French are working flat out trying to control that situation and providing intelligence to the UK, there is a lot of joint working but not every crossing can be prevented. Huge numbers of crossings are thwarted.

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 14:44

bafta16 · 02/08/2026 12:21

Its complex. Many threads to this. English is becoming a world wide language, the colonial past, misinformation, relatives already established here, escaping hideous trauma/ poverty, trying to get out of a hell hole and yes trying to reinvent yourself.
I think young people are risk takers.

Do you work with asylum seekers?

likelysuspect · 02/08/2026 14:42

DoraSpenlow · 02/08/2026 12:02

https://www.thejc.com/news/uk/gazan-family-refugee-status-asylum-rejection-gwsq2c8b

Not for much longer once more people hear about this route.

Edited

Yes we read about this at work.

We have had similar (not exactly the same) which are then easily overturned at appeal. Im expecting this to be the same. However, who knows, the courts are often surprising.