Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People commenting on my 6 YO DD weight?

341 replies

mumspiration1997 · 29/05/2024 20:09

I've had 3 different family members commenting on my daughters weight this week. "She's really filled out" "you should watch what she's eating" etc etc . Possibly from a place of concern as they wouldn't be people to be obviously nasty. For context she's 4 stone and average height. Is this a problem? She's a great appetite and an active girl who definitely loves a wee treat but big deal. I'm 9 stone and very active myself so it's not like I'm purposely just laying around setting bad examples. Perhaps maybe I should be making her eat healthier but I mean she eats fruit and ham sandwiches and chicken nuggets and mash and veg and the takeout with the whole family om a sat McDonald's etc. Big deal??!!! She's 6 I was just grateful she has a good appetite. Aibu???? Or r they???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Mummyoflittledragon · 30/05/2024 07:42

Scottishshortbread11877 · 30/05/2024 07:29

Carbs should be reduced if she is eating pancakes, croissants , waffles and mashed potato daily. It just converts to sugar. Complex carbs are good but yes, refunded carbs should be cut back

This is true, yes. This is what I meant in my post rather than reducing overall carbs. Dd’s evening meals were things like spaghetti bolognese with plenty of veg (onions, garlic, courgette, carrot) or eggs and marmite toast. So I wasn’t reducing complex carbs. She had fruit or yoghurt for pudding.

Otherstories2002 · 30/05/2024 07:50

mumspiration1997 · 29/05/2024 20:09

I've had 3 different family members commenting on my daughters weight this week. "She's really filled out" "you should watch what she's eating" etc etc . Possibly from a place of concern as they wouldn't be people to be obviously nasty. For context she's 4 stone and average height. Is this a problem? She's a great appetite and an active girl who definitely loves a wee treat but big deal. I'm 9 stone and very active myself so it's not like I'm purposely just laying around setting bad examples. Perhaps maybe I should be making her eat healthier but I mean she eats fruit and ham sandwiches and chicken nuggets and mash and veg and the takeout with the whole family om a sat McDonald's etc. Big deal??!!! She's 6 I was just grateful she has a good appetite. Aibu???? Or r they???

You are. That’s hugely overweight. If people are commenting about it that says it all!

she weighs more than my 7 year old who’s a bit of a chunk.

NotDonna · 30/05/2024 07:51

whilst fruit is a great snack or ‘pudding’ some are very high sugar, esp the tropical ones like banana, mango etc. Best to stick to apples, pears and berries. Better still would be veggies such as carrot sticks, cucumber, celery, and peppers. I’d really try to up her veg intake and reduce the sugar.

JanefromLondon1 · 30/05/2024 07:52

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

PollyPut · 30/05/2024 07:56

@mumspiration1997 you've not mentioned what she's drinking?

bakewellbride · 30/05/2024 08:02

I'm 34 years old and your 6 year old is nearly half my weight. It's not ideal imo.

rainbowunicorn · 30/05/2024 08:09

tamade · 30/05/2024 04:17

@mumspiration1997 I just did a bit of googling, seems like DD is about a stone heavier than what the WHO calls average, whatever that means. Also whilst reading up discovered that my DS is in the same boat. But since he is healthy, happy and active I find myself unable to GAF.

I also imagine that the standard deviation on something like global weights of 6yos is massive and confidence intervals will be large. So even significantly heavier than average may still be quite unremarkable, statistically.

Edited

The thing is a stone when you are talking about an adult being a stone overweight is very different to a 6 year-old child being a stone overweight. OPs daughter is in the obese category at a stone overweight. This wouldn't be the case with an adult.
An attitude like you don't GAF is awful. You should GAF it is literally your job as a parent to GAF about your child's health.
Also you imagine incorrectly about your final point. When you are dealing with small numbers the range isn't very large. A child being a stone overweight at that age and size is 25% heavier than they should be. That is a massive amount. If they continue as they are within 5 years they could easily be 50% heavier than tbey should be.

Didimum · 30/05/2024 08:13

bakewellbride · 30/05/2024 08:02

I'm 34 years old and your 6 year old is nearly half my weight. It's not ideal imo.

That’s not a meaningful comparison and your weight at 34yrs old is irrelevant. A female will reach their full adult height in their teens.

SoTiredNeedHoliday · 30/05/2024 08:32

@mumspiration1997 I think cutting out treats until the weekend will be difficult and all children have things they see as treats more than that. It's changing what they view as the treats that is the key.

For instance, a croissant should be viewed as a treat breakfast or snack. Normal would be Weetabix or some other low-sugar cereal. You can make massive changes by reading the cereal ingredients/stats, they all look like they are relatively healthy but it's misleading. The image are two granolas from the same brand, both of which look health from the front of the package.

Desserts can also be natural greek yoghurt with some no added sugar jam (I use St. Dalfour) and maybe some cereal added for little crunch. At least this way she's getting the natural fruit sugars rather than a bunch of additives

Small adjustments like these will make a big difference to her intake, its so important to get good diet started early

People commenting on my 6 YO DD weight?
pontipinemum · 30/05/2024 08:34

mumspiration1997 · 29/05/2024 21:59

It's sooo easily done and honestly I hadn't even noticed. But not the end of the world and we can start some healthier habits!!!!

You sound like you have a good attitude and you were open to receiving what others who loved you said about DD's weight.

DH was a very overweight child/ teen. Pretty much down to his mum. Maybe if someone had, had a quiet word with her it'd have helped.

Mchill79 · 30/05/2024 08:39

bakewellbride · 30/05/2024 08:02

I'm 34 years old and your 6 year old is nearly half my weight. It's not ideal imo.

This is a very bizarre comment! My son is 7 and at 5 stone is well over half of your weight! That has no relevance at all.
No idea how tall are you but he is 100% more than half your height unless you are over 9 ft tall. That is about as relevant as your comment!

SoTiredNeedHoliday · 30/05/2024 08:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn due to privacy concerns.

@bleughgreen

100% agree McDonalds 1 times a week is far too much, even 1 times a month in my opinion. Its pretty much all completely ultra-processed food which is so bad for us all.

@mumspiration1997 have you looked at alternatives for a easy night like cook they deliver frozen meals that have all been freshly prepared etc and you can get a meal for 4 for around £20. They also do things like thai and Chinese style food. Maybe then you can save the McDonalds restaurant trips for a real treat?

COOK | Frozen Ready Meals, Delivered Meals, Prepared Meal Delivery | COOK

Remarkable frozen ready meals, prepared by our own chefs and delivered to your door via our nationwide delivery service. Or discover your local COOK shop!

https://www.cookfood.net/

yumyumyumy · 30/05/2024 08:47

Have you checked her on the bmi calculator? My just turned 4 year old is tall (110cm) and 3 stone and that puts him on 51st.

Greengrapeofhome · 30/05/2024 08:55

Happyhappyday · 30/05/2024 04:30

My DD is 5.5 and 4 stone. She’s about 115cm tall too. I don’t think she’s overweight but definitely feel like she has some preschool chub, so a full stone more on her would feel pretty heavy I think. I’d maybe offer food less often, let her ask if she’s hungry. More fresh, less processed. Example for what DC ate today: oatmeal for breakfast, some fruit, snack at school which is usually some crackers or seaweed snacks and fruit. Homemade bean burrito, fruit and spinach for lunch. Snack afterschool peanut puffs, fruit. Dinner tonight was out at a nice restaurant, pasta and she had a scoop of ice cream. Last night was pork tacos with avocado, corn etc and similar rest of day.

If you input your child’s height, weight and age into the nhs app, she comes up as overweight and almost in the obese category being 4stone and 115cm

Rycbar · 30/05/2024 08:56

TomatoSandwiches · 29/05/2024 20:22

Don't they do checks at school around this age? Has the school nurse said anything?

Reception age so it would have been last year for OPs daughter!

TribeofFfive · 30/05/2024 09:06

Cut out the ham, the nuggets and the takeaways.

edited as posted too soon!

Now is a good age to introduce healthy food habits. My 6yo has covered healthy food choices recently in school and is always reminding me what’s healthy and what isn’t. He’s just under 3 stone.

notacooldad · 30/05/2024 09:07

I absolutely won't and im going to use the dentist as an excuse
Dont blame the dentist and use that as an excuse.
Just reduce your intake and if any questions are asked you can talk about health then. Don't blame someone else.

user1492757084 · 30/05/2024 09:18

Your daughter sounds happy.
It's great that she has a good appetite.
The change I would make would be limiting take-aways to once per week and lollies to once a week.
The SOMETIMES FOOD should be limited to sometimes and the fresh, cook from scratch food is best to be indulged.
Fruit bowl, popcorn, wholemeal breads and low sugar/salt spreads available rather than chocolate bars.
Vegies with mince meat patties, tuna bake and sausages rather than chicken nuggets for most nights.
Water and milk rather than solf drinks and juice.
Lower sugar/salt breakfast cereals in the trolley rather than those saturated in sugar.
People have commented to you so take the time to be alerted to what she does seem to eat most weeks.

All kids eat treats and enjoy them sometimes.

Otherstories2002 · 30/05/2024 09:19

Mchill79 · 30/05/2024 08:39

This is a very bizarre comment! My son is 7 and at 5 stone is well over half of your weight! That has no relevance at all.
No idea how tall are you but he is 100% more than half your height unless you are over 9 ft tall. That is about as relevant as your comment!

Your 7 year old is also overweight.

You can say it’s not relevant but young children should not weight half that of a fully grown adult.

Otherstories2002 · 30/05/2024 09:19

notacooldad · 30/05/2024 09:07

I absolutely won't and im going to use the dentist as an excuse
Dont blame the dentist and use that as an excuse.
Just reduce your intake and if any questions are asked you can talk about health then. Don't blame someone else.

This!

Mchill79 · 30/05/2024 09:22

Otherstories2002 · 30/05/2024 09:19

Your 7 year old is also overweight.

You can say it’s not relevant but young children should not weight half that of a fully grown adult.

He isn’t overweight at all. He is very tall and well within the healthy weight range. This post is meant to help educate so saying rubbish like this isn’t helping.

People commenting on my 6 YO DD weight?
Lingfield01 · 30/05/2024 09:26

Talk to your GP if you are genuinely concerned, there are an awful lot of ‘superior’ mums here.

Hemakesmesmile2 · 30/05/2024 09:26

My 11 year old son is 5 stone.

Mchill79 · 30/05/2024 09:27

Hemakesmesmile2 · 30/05/2024 09:26

My 11 year old son is 5 stone.

Yes but how tall is he. Height is always relevant. Just throwing out numbers is helping anyone!

ilovesushi · 30/05/2024 09:28

Good you are planning to take action already. An girl in DD's class was a little bit plump at that age and just steadily put on more and more weight through childhood. She is now an obese teenager. I don't think it i easy to shift weight if you have been carrying it all your life.