Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

The Times article on surrogacy and concerns about single fathers

91 replies

Sixorhalfdozen · 23/04/2026 19:52

Hi all, I haven’t seen a post yet about the article in today’s Times on surrogacy with the title, ‘What it is like to be a single dad (with a child via surrogacy)’. It is an entirely uncritical puff piece on single men who purchase babies and there is no attempt in the article to highlight the risks and harms caused by this barbaric practice. I have written to complain and encourage others to do the same.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Glowingup · 27/04/2026 17:04

AncientBallerina · 24/04/2026 14:38

Is there any research yet on the outcomes for these children born of surrogacy when they become teenagers/young adults and how their beginning in life has affected them in terms of their relationships with the people who brought them up, their mental health etc?

I work in academia and basically the official line is that surrogacy is good and nobody would entertain or fund any research that was seeking to argue otherwise. Concern about surrogacy is equated to being a bigot or a homophobe. My discipline is law and I appreciate that maybe it is different in other disciplines such as psychology.

Arran2024 · 27/04/2026 17:26

There is some ongoing research in the UK. I will dig out the link later

Arran2024 · 27/04/2026 19:01

I found this handy resource - links to various research studies. They are all really small. https://brilliantbeginnings.co.uk/research-about-surrogacy/

Research about surrogacy - Brilliant Beginnings

https://brilliantbeginnings.co.uk/research-about-surrogacy/

JellySaurus · 27/04/2026 22:05

Glowingup · 27/04/2026 17:04

I work in academia and basically the official line is that surrogacy is good and nobody would entertain or fund any research that was seeking to argue otherwise. Concern about surrogacy is equated to being a bigot or a homophobe. My discipline is law and I appreciate that maybe it is different in other disciplines such as psychology.

Sounds familiar for academia…basically the official line is that TWAW is good and nobody would entertain or fund any research that was seeking to argue otherwise. Concern about Transgenderism is equated to being a bigot or a homophobe. Remember James Caspian in 2017?

TheSandgroper · 28/04/2026 09:04

UtopiaPlanitia · 27/04/2026 15:39

I'm glad I read that article but the information in it is going to haunt me for a while - it's sickening how human beings are being commissioned/bought/sold to satisfy the whims of wealthy people.

Why does the human race have to learn over and over that just because we can do something doesn't mean we should do it.

Yeah, sorry about that. It’s horror on a number of different fronts.

Compunction. That’s what is missing from the world today. Compunction.

ZoeCM · 28/04/2026 23:09

Shortshriftandlethal · 24/04/2026 12:32

Agreed! Not to even have a 'mother' story for the child is verging on abuse. In fact potentially very damaging to instil in the child that it has no mother at all.

I know a lesbian couple who got annoyed when an aunt wondered aloud if their son got X characteristic from his father. One of them pulled the aunt aside and snapped at her that they've told their son he doesn't have a father, he has a donor. It's so damaging. When that poor boy learns where babies come from, he'll realise that everyone has a father and that he's been lied to.

I really hate how socially acceptable it's become to insist people use double-speak so that others can remain in denial about biological reality. "He's not the father, he's the donor." "She's not a woman, she's a uterus-haver." "She's not the birth mother, she's the gestational carrier."

viques · 29/04/2026 13:57

ZoeCM · 28/04/2026 23:09

I know a lesbian couple who got annoyed when an aunt wondered aloud if their son got X characteristic from his father. One of them pulled the aunt aside and snapped at her that they've told their son he doesn't have a father, he has a donor. It's so damaging. When that poor boy learns where babies come from, he'll realise that everyone has a father and that he's been lied to.

I really hate how socially acceptable it's become to insist people use double-speak so that others can remain in denial about biological reality. "He's not the father, he's the donor." "She's not a woman, she's a uterus-haver." "She's not the birth mother, she's the gestational carrier."

See above for “situational infertility” which is the phrase used to describe the totally unforseeable biological reason why two men can’t make a baby together, but which apparently needs to be regarded as sympathetically as any medical reason for infertility.

ZoeCM · 29/04/2026 14:06

viques · 29/04/2026 13:57

See above for “situational infertility” which is the phrase used to describe the totally unforseeable biological reason why two men can’t make a baby together, but which apparently needs to be regarded as sympathetically as any medical reason for infertility.

Yes, "situational infertility" is an astonishing phrase. It reminds me of TIMs who describe themselves as infertile because they can't pregnant, some of whom have already fathered children. By that definition, isn't everyone on Earth infertile? No one is able to both get pregnant and impregnate someone else.

Beowulfa · 29/04/2026 14:10

I have heard the phrase "fertility equality" start to be used. No doubt it will help with the constant need for young women to donate their eggs.

SapphireSeptember · 29/04/2026 14:25

logiccalls · 24/04/2026 19:05

The popular preacher, gay- turned- even- more- trendy 'trans', in one USA State, who, with his gay partner, was allowed to take possession of the baby they bought, because that is contract law. He tokenistically changed his address to that of his mother, nearby.

That was enough to satisfy the court, despite the difficulty that the still-pregnant mother had asked the court to cancel the contract, in order to keep the baby. She no longer wanted to hand it over, after there was publicity about a tweet he had posted to the local gay group.

He had said how excited he was at the prospect of getting the newborn baby home and being the "very first person to enter that brand new little body". He mused he might invite a group of friends to "take part in the celebration" .

That's utterly chilling. That poor child.

Namingbaba · 29/04/2026 14:36

Llamasarellovely · 24/04/2026 08:52

A former (50 something, gay, single) colleague of mine has just had a child by surrogate in the States (with a separate egg donor for precisely the reason stated in the article) and brought back here at 6 weeks. I asked him if he would stay in touch with the mother and he physically recoiled. He said "we" dont use that word, that's not what she is.
His child has a father, an egg donor and a gestational surrogate, apparently.

What person would want to come into the world with this set up? It's just horrible. Also having your one parent at 50 is troubling too.

The ages as well is troubling. I'm not against people having children later in life but with surrogacy you get cases of 65 year old men having a baby. Even if they turn out to be brilliant parents they're going to die when the child is around 20 or earlier most likely!

logiccalls · 29/04/2026 17:40

aberamagold · 24/04/2026 12:57

If we made it illegal to buy babies abroad the father wouldn't be able to look after the baby, as he would be in prison, so the baby could be adopted.
There is no shortage of potentially excellent mothers wanting to adopt babies.
A few cases of this and people would stop buying babies.

Yes and no: Social services apparently do their best to avoid best outcome for anyone: It seems they make couples jump through hoops to be approved as adopters, but then, even if a new baby is available, force the baby to go to a temporary foster carer for a couple of years, during which time the future adopters are kept in ignorance that the baby exists. Hats off to the temporary foster carers. But why on earth can't the babies go straight to their permanent parents?

aberamagold · 01/05/2026 11:17

I agree with you, placement with permanent parents from birth is the best way to limit trauma to the baby.
Though I think it's right there are many 'hoops to jump through', as these babies deserve the best possible parents.

logiccalls · 02/05/2026 17:49

aberamagold · 01/05/2026 11:17

I agree with you, placement with permanent parents from birth is the best way to limit trauma to the baby.
Though I think it's right there are many 'hoops to jump through', as these babies deserve the best possible parents.

But the jumping of hoops has been made so exhausting and taken years: Then, AFTER the prospective adopters pass every test, a baby is due to be taken into care at birth. So, is it put straight into the arms of the approved couple? No. It goes to a foster family for two years, while, nearby, the adopters wait another two years.

Jane3212 · Today 03:35

logiccalls · 24/04/2026 19:05

The popular preacher, gay- turned- even- more- trendy 'trans', in one USA State, who, with his gay partner, was allowed to take possession of the baby they bought, because that is contract law. He tokenistically changed his address to that of his mother, nearby.

That was enough to satisfy the court, despite the difficulty that the still-pregnant mother had asked the court to cancel the contract, in order to keep the baby. She no longer wanted to hand it over, after there was publicity about a tweet he had posted to the local gay group.

He had said how excited he was at the prospect of getting the newborn baby home and being the "very first person to enter that brand new little body". He mused he might invite a group of friends to "take part in the celebration" .

That was an unbelievable awful case. I think a couple of details seem not quite correct though, I think- where did you read about the case? :

Adam Stafford King never took possession of the baby, nor was there any public record of the surrogate fighting to cancel the contract to keep the child.
King was arrested on March 22, 2024—a week before the baby's March 29 due date—and was ordered held in federal jail without bond. He was never released and never had custody of or contact with the newborn. [1] (https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/adam-stafford-king-veterinarian-dog-show-judge-arrested-child-pornography/

https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/68371108/united-states-v-king/

(https://chronicleillinois.com/news/cook-county-news/government-defense-spar-as-child-porn-trial-looms/

•King's parents did offer to house him under strict supervision if he were granted bail, which the judge denied. Separately, King's husband, Lucas King—who was not charged and whom prosecutors stated had no knowledge of the crimes—moved out of their shared home and arranged to raise the newborn at his own parents' house with extended family support
• "...The still-pregnant mother had asked the court to cancel the contract, in order to keep the baby." — No news reports or federal court records I could find mention the mother filing a lawsuit tp keep the child.

The vile message wasn't 'a tweet to a local gay group'. On the gay dating app Scruff, King tested other users' boundaries and if they reacted positively to hints of his criminal interests, he shared more. That's how the police caught him, as he ended up talking to an undercover officer
It seems unlikely to me he would have posted such a message to a mainstream gay chat group.

King was also a vet, not a pastor, and doesn't seem to have been trans (the partner was a pastor though)

Chicago veterinarian, dog show judge charged with child porn; FBI says he boasted of drugging and abusing multiple kids

The FBI says Adam Stafford King also chatted online about planning to sexually assault his newborn son.

https://www.cbsnews.com/chicago/news/adam-stafford-king-veterinarian-dog-show-judge-arrested-child-pornography/

Jane3212 · Today 04:28

logiccalls · 24/04/2026 08:43

Surrogacy and prostitution both depend on an assumption that using human bodies for commercial reasons is fine:
Using the same assumption, why not herd humans of all ages into intensive farms, to harvest human organs and blood, on demand, to the highest bidders?

Apparently to some extent this is already practiced, with living donors being imported, or rich recipients flying to obtain the purchased body parts.

The planet is overwhelmed with multiple billions too many humans, the majority of whom can make no contribution, just be life-long parasites, now that A.I. is increasingly able to our-perform humans. What is plentiful is cheap. A century of mass population explosion has made human lives cheap.

It would have been better to have had an international one-or-no child policy for a century. It rescued the population of China, and rescued the Chinese economy. It probably would have been an international policy, if women had been in positions of power and policy making, internationally:

Melinda Gates said that rich and poor, all over the world, what women want, above all, is control of fertility.

(Bill however, openly boasts that uncountable millions, or billions, of extra people are now alive on the overcrowded, poisoned, biodiversity-stripped, once perfect but now dying-by-humans planet, all "thanks" to him. Yet another example of how males, and male-run organisations, find it impossible to regard females as equal human beings, not merely as reproductive systems to be used.)

There is a huge amount of evidence that women were forced into abortions by that, that baby girls were abandoned or adopted abroad due to state pressure (often girls whose parents wanted to keep them). How is forcing women to abort and ending up with a colossal and problematic gender imbalance (with far more men) a pro-woman policy?

Why do you think Chinese women in general would have freely chosen this policy? Or women in other countries?

And re population, populations across the developed world are falling, not rising. The population explosion happened in places like Africa and India but as contraception, education etc spread, those will fall too. The crisis countries like us face is not overpopulation but not having enough people to work and pay taxes, especially with increasing numbers of elderly people who need to be protected.

China solved their overpopulation problem but they have replaced it with a huge sex imbalance and a falling fertility rate. 1 child families mean 1 child has to support 2 parents and 4 grandparents.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page