I’m glad people think it gets to the heart of it. It did upset me this morning, and I wanted to work out why in a way that would address any unthinking Be kind! defence (or attack!) On the surface, it may seem very reasonable to many readers, and my own feelings quite churlish. But not in the current context - a context the Guardian systematically obscures and denies to prevent and demonise precisely this kind of critical engagement with the issue.
The difference in biology - strength & reproductive role - lies at the very heart of the issue; for us, it is the issue. It shapes and limits our decisions and movements; colours our thoughts and feelings every day; every hour, even. And it’s the one thing that men can never fully understand because of their own, different physical reality - they can only ever imagine and empathise, at the very most. But they don’t, on balance. The bear in the woods went viral, this went viral, in part because women are desperate - desperate - for a way to bring this home in terms men can understand. So here was another chance… exquisitely skewered in the most damagingly effective way by the very newspaper that claims to support us.
How better to undermine another effort to communicate this fundamental truth and legitimise its denial than reframing our daily fear to include a male-bodied person? It’s perfect. And it’s devastating.
And it reenacts exactly what the clip is fighting to expose.