Very interesting and heartening to see judges being corrected and changing their language. Tired are turning? Quoted text from article. My bold.
'The full appeals court disagreed with Chatigny's original finding that the case was moot after transgender champions Andraya Yearwood and Terry Miller graduated and that failure to correct "past athletic records," to remove male winners in girls' sports, was not a legal injury.
It said the girls "adequately pled a concrete, particularized, and actual injury in fact … denial of equal athletic opportunity and concomitant loss of publicly recognized titles and placements" – the plaintiffs want dozens of records corrected – by finishing behind Yearwood and Miller.
It's an embarrassing reversal for Chatigny, whose removal the girls unsuccessfully sought for "unfair bias" when they appealed his ruling. They cited his order to stop "bullying" Yearwood and Miller by calling them "male" and for allegedly making up his own science on biological sex.
Unlike in 2021, Chatigny's ruling last week is replete with references to biological sex. He even twice used the phrase "biological males," which three years earlier he had deemed "needlessly provocative" when applied to Yearwood and Miller.'