Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Books Challenge Part Three

1000 replies

Southeastdweller · 24/02/2024 13:46

Welcome to the third thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2024, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read.

If possible, please can you embolden your titles and maybe authors as well of books you've read or going to read? It makes it much easier to keep track, especially when the threads move quickly at this time of the year.

The first thread is here and the second one here.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
25
FortunaMajor · 31/03/2024 13:38

My personal pick for winner is Enter Ghost but I have a funny feeling that And Then She Fell will pip it at the post.

I have yet to read Restless Dolly Maunder, but I trust the review given by a previous reader and I doubt it will make the cut.

My personal shortlist

Enter Ghost
And Then She Fell
Soldier Sailor
Ordinary Human Failings
River East, River West
Nightbloom

I also liked Brotherless Night, but not quite enough.

I think the actual shortlist will be different and likely to include Hangman and I don't think Ordinary Human Failings will make it. I wouldn't rule out In Defence of the Act making it either, more from a variety quota than anything else. There's always one batshit entry on the shortlist that makes me wonder how much money changed hands.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 31/03/2024 13:40

Happy Easter!

Thanks for the heads up on the deals

Palegreenstars · 31/03/2024 14:26

@splothersdog glad you liked it to. The dinner party scene will stay with me, I think a good dinner party chapter is a genre all its own

@FortunaMajor great list. I’m looking forward to the others on your short list

cassandre · 31/03/2024 14:59

Ooh, lots of great reviews! Fuzzy, you've made me want to read Romain Gary.

HenryTilney, I just finished 8 Lives and while my assessment isn't as quite as scathing as yours, I completely agree with most of what you say. Here's my review (quite dry in comparison to yours, ha):

  1. 8 Lives of a Century-Old Trickster, Mirinae Lee 3/5 Women’s Prize longlist. Contains a lot of interesting detail about North and South Korea across the whole of the 20th century (including WW2 and the Korean War). However, to a large extent the stories are a litany of horrifically brutal acts, which doesn’t fit well with the book’s framing device of playful trickster. (And the stories aren’t ordered chronologically, which gives the book a jigsaw-puzzle kind of feel as you try to work out which pieces go where.) The overall effect is of a narrative that is a bit too easy or superficial in its treatment of traumatic events.

What you say about the trickster motif and how that replaces a meaningful exploration of why we really do tell stories - that's very perceptive. I didn't even notice the lack of typographical consistency though! And I can't believe that the stories were ordered in the way the author actually published them before she transformed them into a novel - oh dear. The ordering certainly seemed rather random to me.

Great shortlist, Fortuna. I've only read half the longlist so far, but I concur with your top pick of Enter Ghost. And Ordinary Human Failings and Soldier Sailor would definitely also make my shortlist. In general, our assessments seem to be quite similar (or maybe I'm just being unduly influenced by your fabulous reviews, ha! 😜) I'm really looking forward now to reading And Then She Fell.

Happy Easter/spring/chocolate day to everyone who celebrates!

cassandre · 31/03/2024 15:09

Of the 8 entries on the Women's Prize longlist that I've read so far (the fiction list), I'd put them into these three tiers:

Tier 1: Enter Ghost; Ordinary Human Failings; Soldier Sailor
Tier 2: Western Lane; River East, River West
Tier 3: The Maiden; 8 Lives of a Century-Old Trickster; The Wren, The Wren

ÚlldemoShúl · 31/03/2024 15:24

I’m loving reading the emerging personal shortlists.
I’m going to emulate cassandre and go with tiers.

For the fiction so far
Tier 1- complete agreement- Enter Ghost, Soldier Sailor, Ordinary Human Failings
Tier 2- Western Lane, In Defence of the Act
Tier 3- The Maidens, The Wren The Wren, The Blue Beautiful World (though to be fair I DNFed the last one)

I’m currently reading Brotherless Night which will be either tier 1 or 2 I reckon.

For the non-fiction
Tier 1- Intervals, Doppelganger, Young Queens
Tier 2- A Flat Place,
Tier 3- Eve

I’m now focussing on the shortlist and current read is Thunderclap which I’m pretty sure will be tier one

Piggywaspushed · 31/03/2024 15:41

Copperhead update! Am now 150 pages from the end. It is moving at a better pace but God it's unrelenting in its grimness. I guess that's where BS departs from Dickens who does comedy so well.

I'm not feeling too well but will hopefully finish by Tuesday.

Reminder to Dickensalongers we convene tomorrow!

MorriganManor · 31/03/2024 17:41

Oh no @Piggywaspushed , I’m 44% of the way through Copperhead and I’m finding it so lovely, mostly. His indomitable little spirit. Fully expect that to be crushed before much longer, though. Otherwise, why would it have won awards #cynical

StColumbofNavron · 31/03/2024 18:34

I follow the prizes through commentary on here only, so have no opinions here.

I don’t mind a spa, but prefer puttering around in the pool/sauna/steam room and reading the without distraction rather than actual treatments. Happy birthday @Palegreenstars

Keen to read The Scapegoat @TimeforaGandT but it’s just sitting with about 400 other books on my Kindle.

@EineReiseDurchDieZeit Respect for giving Moshfegh another go. Absolutely not for me ever again.

FortunaMajor · 31/03/2024 18:36

I completely agree with the tier systems listed above.

Just a shame there are so many tier 3 books on the list in total.

A very short one

Clear - Cary's Davies
1840s Scotland at the end stages of the clearances. A pastor takes on the job of evicting an elderly man from a remote island who has lived alone for 10 years. He has a serious accident shortly after arriving on the island and the man rescues him and nurses him back to health. Despite not sharing a common language they come to understanding one another which makes it even more difficult for the pastor to complete his task.

This is beautiful and devastating. It looks at the early founding of the Free Church as well as the personal connections that develop between people. It's very atmospheric. The ending is a bit rushed and implausible, but overall it's a great bit of writing.

StColumbofNavron · 31/03/2024 18:36

Whoops, I have actually read something.

Romancing Mr Bridgerton Julia Quinn
I wanted to read this before the new series airs. More of the same Regency swooning, this one has a bit more oomph as Lady Whistledown is unmasked and I do like Penelope and Colin. Book two still the best in the silly regency romance saga.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 31/03/2024 18:44

@StColumbofNavron

I wouldn't be trying again but for the fact I bought Lapvona before I'd read any and now I'm stuck with it.

BlueFairyBugsBooks · 31/03/2024 20:42
  1. Specular. Calix Leigh-Reign Thit's is the third and final book in the series (which I've forgotten the name of) and its lost its way a little for me. There's a whole load of new characters, some who are in it so little you're never really sure who they are. And, it turns out, more universes. I got a bit confused

  2. Maybe It's About Time. Neil Boss
    This is a bold for me. First of all, all proceeds go to Gingerbread.
    Set from January-April 2020, so the start of Covid. Marcus is a very wealthy business man, married, 2 children, 2 houses etc etc. On the face he has it all. But he's becoming disillusioned with life.
    Claire is a single, unemployed mum of 2.
    They meet via Claires social Worker. Totally unprofessional imo. At one point I thought we were in lockdown again and couldn't work out why my SM was full of posts of people who were out and about

Anyway, I was broken by then end. So broken.

  1. The Godfather of Dance. Andrea Barton Another bold. Set in the glamorous world of competition ballroom dancing, it's a murder mystery, whodunnit, Mafia type book.
HenryTilneyBestBoy · 31/03/2024 22:15

Due to ravages of Fake Time, feel unable to do proper justice to 39 Thunderclap - Laura Cumming so will just heartily echo @Terpsichore 's previous praises. It's the only WPNF book I've finished so far, so obviously my pick 😀 But aside from that, it's likely to be my non-fic book of the year - genuinely revelatory, enabling me to see paintings in a completely different way (several, actually).

Glad you found things to appreciate in 8 Lives @cassandre ! To be fair, I’m of Korean heritage so already familiar with the background, and had just finished two Korean books, with non-fiction about WWII to boot, namely:

40 Greek Lessons - Han Kang (tr. Deborah Smith and Emily Yae Won)
A Korean writer and lecturer suddenly becomes mute, a condition she'd once experienced in adolescence. Attempting to regain a connection to language, she begins to attend evening classes in Classical Greek, taught by a man who's hiding the fact that his progressive loss of sight is now nearly complete. The woman's third-person narrative alternates with the man's first-person one (mostly addressed to various people he's lost); neither protagonist is named, b/c Literary Fiction.
The Lit game was strong in this, with lovely passages on language, from the shapes of Korean diphthongs to the Greek middle voice, to the fundamental embodied processes of shaping and receiving sounds, seeing and making and feeling marks, all exquisitely translated. However, I found the Fic bits much weaker - arguably unnecessary (though admittedly linguistics essay collections tend not to sell as well as elegant novellas). Certain characters and plot points in the male teacher's story in particular were so mawkish and melodramatic they became unintentionally funny - not in the gleefully batshit way of The Vegetarian, to make a point, but seemingly just due to genre conventions of psychologically nonsensical but 'symbolic' behaviour.

41 Miss Kim Knows and other stories - Cho Nam-Joo (tr. Jamie Chang)
Eight short stories, mercifully unlinked, but sharing a contemporary South Korean setting and interest in women's lives. Precise, unfussy prose with a particularly good ear for dialogue (Chang did an excellent job rendering various levels of Korean formality and slanginess in Br. Eng). The most 'on brand' entries for readers of Miss Kim Ji-Young, Born 1982 are probably the Dear John letter to a controlling fiancé, the slyly funny mundane-weird office slice-of-life, and and the very meta one in which the writer of a hit feminist novel is accused of appropriating another woman’s lived experience. The other stories cover a surprising range, and even the slightest (puppy love derailed by Covid and running out of free texts) was enjoyable. I continue to be baffled and dispirited that so moderate and centrist a writer as Cho has become a lightning rod for the toxic anti-feminist movement in SK.

42 Coffee with Hitler - Charles Spicer
Previously reviewed by Terpsichore. Narrative history of the English amateurs associated with the Anglo-German Fellowship (1935-39) who sought to ‘civilise’ rather than 'appease' the Nazi regime, and through this, re-examining some more famous figures associated with Appeasement. Seeks to reclaim the nuance and contingency of Anglo-German relations and complicate popular narratives of stupid/weak/evil ‘guilty men’ and pure 'war heroes' and very much succeeds. However, as with any revisionist history (and books that used to be PhD theses) the piling up of Evidence in exhaustive detail did make my eyes glaze over at times and lose sight of the bigger picture/argument. Still full of fascinating facts and insights, sensibly organised and well written - accessible but still scholarly.

Currently appreciating the elegance of Enter Ghost and glad to have the other top tier WP novels yet to come.

cassandre · 31/03/2024 22:30

Ah, those two Korean books sound interesting, HenryTilney, especially Miss Kim Knows. 😂at Eight short stories, mercifully unlinked! I don't think I've ever read any Korean literature at all. And I didn't know about the anti-feminist movement there; I'll google.

highlandcoo · 31/03/2024 23:01

A very belated happy birthday @Palegreenstars. A pile of books is a brilliant present!

@splothersdog I really enjoyed Gillespie and I too. Have you read The Observations, also by Jane Harris? I recommend it to everyone. It's an intriguing mystery and Bessy's narrative voice is very engaging.

I was a little disappointed in her third novel Sugar Money, however all credit to JH for tackling a totally different sort of novel. Looking forward to what she writes next.

I've just finished This is Where I Am by Karen Campbell. I loved Paper Cup and in TIWIA Karen Campbell again gives dignity and a voice to someone experiencing prejudice. Abdi is a Somalian refugee struggling to cope with past horrors and to build a new life for himself and his young daughter in Glasgow. Debs is the middle-aged volunteer, recently widowed, who becomes his mentor. It's a realistic, nuanced account of two decent people, sensitive and vulnerable in different ways, stumbling awkwardly towards friendship and understanding.

I have a slight problem with one aspect of the plot but that doesn't detract from all that's excellent about this book. The cast of Glasgow characters is well done, ranging from appallingly racist to warm-hearted and humorous. It's thought-provoking - the scenes in Dadaab refugee camp in Kenya are tough to read. It's a page-turning, compassionate piece of writing. If you enjoyed Paper Cup I think you would like this too.

MorriganManor · 01/04/2024 06:48

I have This Is Where I Am on my physical TBR pile @highlandcoo . I wanted to leave a bit of space between it and Paper Cup, good to know it is of the same standard.

Picked up The Maiden (I know it divides opinion on here), The Mess We’re In by Annie MacManus and Relight My Fire:Stranger Times 4 for 99p on Kindle this morning. And Then She Fell is £2.99 but I’m sticking to my 99p only pledge 😇

ChessieFL · 01/04/2024 06:57

74 I Am Missing by Tim Weaver

Missing person investigator David Raker is hired by a man who has lost his memory, to try and find out who he really is. ‘Richard’ was found in a harbour with head injuries and can’t remember anything except a vague memory of a beach and a TV programme intro. This is another really good story, and I really liked the later setting of the book.

75 You Were Gone by Tim Weaver

Raker’s wife died 8 years ago, but now a woman who looks very similar has walked into a police station claiming she’s his wife and she has been living with David for the last 8 years. She knows things about David’s relationship with his wife that nobody could possibly know. Why is she pretending to be his wife and how does she know all this stuff? Another brilliant book by Weaver with a great premise.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 01/04/2024 09:57

In Memoriam is 99p. I’m really hoping it will be the one to get me out of my slump.

Piggywaspushed · 01/04/2024 10:41

I'll definitely be really interested to hear your opinion remus because I feel like I'm the only person thus far wo thought it was a bit meh.

TattiePants · 01/04/2024 11:22

The only book I’ve bought is The Black Angels by Maria Smilios based on the true story of the black nurses that helped treat - and cure - men with TB after white nurses refused to treat them.

I also spotted Frenchman’s Creek which a few of us loved.

satelliteheart · 01/04/2024 12:17

Have been in a rut of stupid romance novels which I won't bother to list or review as have had no ability to concentrate on anything real. But finally managed to read an "real" book

  1. The Guesthouse by Abbie Frost One of those dark blue house silhouette with yellow writing covers. I have loads of these and I honestly don't know why as I rarely rate them, probably just because they're cheap. In this one 7 people go to stay at an Irish manor house for its opening week as a guesthouse. We're following Hannah who is trying to recover from a recent failed relationship but also present are a father and son, another single woman and a family with a teenage daughter. We slowly learn that everyone present seems to have some sort of link to the house's past and strange things start happening in the house. The guests are trapped by the fact that the house has no road access, just a treacherous walk through the woods and they're hemmed in by a storm and blinding fog. It was fine although really very implausible
GrannieMainland · 01/04/2024 13:30

I thought there were quite a few good things in the daily/monthly deals today, a nice surprise.

  1. Green Dot by Madeleine Gray. Australian novel following a disaffected young woman, Hera, as she starts an affair with an older married man at work. It carries on for some years as he repeatedly fails to leave his wife. I'm not sure what to make of this - she can definitely write and it is witty, albeit in a Very Online kind of way, but I'm not sure it's saying anything different from the masses of other novels on the same theme.

  2. Good Material by Dolly Alderton. Mid-30s comedian Andy is left by his long term girlfriend and sets out to work out why things went wrong. A touch of Fleischman as we eventually get the girlfriend's perspective at the end. Some interesting and nuanced things to say about the different directions people's lives take at this age.

  3. A Season for Scandal by Laura Wood. The second in a YA series about a secret female crime fighting agency in the 1890s. This book is about Marigold, a florist, who is recruited and then put on an operation involving a long lost sister and an inheritance, where she has to pretend to be the fiancée of the handsome young Lord Lockwood. A real romp.

I'm off on holiday tomorrow so will be reading books exclusively set in New York (if you can guess where I'm going)

highlandcoo · 01/04/2024 13:55

Have a great time @GrannieMainland - which NY books are you reading?

I'll be reading In Memoriam for my book group soon (need to finish Birnam Wood for my other book group first however, and so far I'm not grabbed) so looking forward to hearing what you think remus and others

StColumbofNavron · 01/04/2024 15:33

Ohhhh, will grab In Memoriam.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread