Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2021 Part Five

1000 replies

southeastdweller · 13/04/2021 22:56

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2021, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read. Could everyone embolden their titles and/or authors as well, please, as it makes the books talked about easier to track?

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

How're you getting on so far?

OP posts:
RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 02/06/2021 23:09

I seem to remember absolutely loathing Howard's End is on the Landing. I get the impression that a minute in Susan Hill's company would be 59 seconds too long. Very annoying woman.

Just read The Survivors by Jane Harper so.you don't have to. Utter dross.

PermanentTemporary · 02/06/2021 23:14
  1. She shall have music by Kitty Barnes A children's book I loved and still do despite it being almost unreadably snobbish now. The story of Karen's unexpected musical talent in an unmusical family.

32 Fridays Child by Georgette Heyer
Lord Sheringham has been rejected by Miss Milborne, the Incomparable, despite his adoration- and his desperate need to marry. Goaded by the events of the day, he strides out declaring he will marry the first woman he sees. Altogether, a delicious bit of cream puff to enjoy when life feels challenging. One of Heyer's funnier stories.

33 The day that went missing by Richard Beard
A memoir of a terrible event in the author's childhood and how it felt when he went back to explore it as an adult and a parent. Close to unbearable and perhaps a little determined on the endpoint from the start, but simply and effectively written.

elkiedee · 02/06/2021 23:39

@Remus I think Susan Hill is the only person who I know has blocked me on Twitter and I'm not sure why. It may be because of our very different political views but in that case I also don't know why she briefly followed me back before blocking me. I didn't try to comment on anything she posted, life's too short for that.

elkiedee · 02/06/2021 23:40

But I don't think Susan Hill and I would get on in person, either.

Stokey · 03/06/2021 08:11

Remus I just read The Survivors too. I didn't mind it. Not one of her best but still a bit better than the average "you never saw me" type thriller. I liked her description of small beach town Australia, but it lacked the landscapes of The Dry or The Lost Man.

Terpsichore · 03/06/2021 08:28

51: A View of the Harbour - Elizabeth Taylor

Just after the war, life proceeds quietly in the shabby, obscure seaside town of Newby. Novelist Beth Cazabon is preoccupied with her latest book and doesn't notice that her husband, local doctor Robert, is secretly involved with her best friend, divorcee Tory Foyle, who lives next door. But Beth's 20-year-old daughter Prudence has picked up the signals, and tensions mount. Meanwhile, a visitor to the town, self-regarding retired seaman and aspiring painter Bertram, inveigles his way into various households. One of his haunts becomes the harbouside house where Mrs Bracey - feared local gossip and matriarch - now lies felled by illness and confined to bed, still dominating her two daughters nevertheless. At the town's down-at-heel waxwork museum, Lily Wilson has been left widowed by the war and must somehow face her ever-mounting loneliness and despair.

This is quite an early novel by Taylor and a miracle of subtlety and sadness. She's so good at drawing you in to a complete, sharply-evoked world - I felt I could envisage the setting perfectly. There are some other excellent characters too; Beth and Robert's 5-year old daughter, Stevie, is wonderful and adds humour to the delicacy of Taylor's writing and the out-of-season melancholy that hovers over the book.

BestIsWest · 03/06/2021 08:52

I had to unfollow Susan Hill on Twitter.

Dear Life: A Doctor’s story of Love and Loss - Rachel Clarke

Another medical memoir - this one about terminal illness from a hospice doctor I found very moving and touchingly written. She writes about the illness and death of her own father which leaves her heartbroken. I seem to be drawn to such books at the moment, alternating them with frothy stuff.

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 03/06/2021 09:59

Yes, this Harper definitely suffered for the lack of landscape.

Susan Hill doesn't strike me as a very nice person. Self absorbed, rather batshit religious type. We would definitely hate each other.

homemadefries · 03/06/2021 10:07

@homemadefries

10. (New here!!) The Split

A year ago Felicity Lloyd fled England to South Georgia, one of the most remote islands in the world, escaping her past and the man she once loved. Can she keep running her whole life?

Freddie Lloyd has served time for murder - and now he wants her back. Wherever she is, he won't stop until he finds her. Will he be able to track her to the ends of the earth?

  • Not sure about this. I'm a third in and it's not grabbing me. I don't feel anything for any of the characters. Will continue on!
Utter shite.
StitchesInTime · 03/06/2021 10:55

52. Clear My Name by Paula Daly

Tess works for Innocence UK, a charity which takes on alleged miscarriages of justice.
Her charity decides to take on the case of Carrie, a woman convicted of murdering her husband’s lover.
Alongside the plot line about investigating the potential miscarriage of justice, there’s Tess’s secrets. She’s spent all her adult life running from her past, but now that she’s back in her hometown investigating Carrie’s case, she’s forced to face up to things.
This was quite a quick read, the plot moved along well.

53. New Model Army by Adam Roberts

This is set in a near future where war is being revolutionised by the introduction of New Model Armies (NMA). Instead of a traditional army, with traditional lines of command and so on, the NMA’s operate in a more democratic way. All members are connected by wireless connections, rapidly coordinating their attacks, courses of action are voted on by members of the NMAs, which results in efficient guerilla style warfare.

The narrator is a member of Pantegral, a NMA that’s been hired by the Scottish government as part of their bid for independence from the U.K.

This was very interesting and absorbing for the most part, although unsurprisingly violent. I struggled to understand the ending though. The last chapter was utterly baffling.

54. Playing Nice by J P Delaney

Pete Riley opens the door one morning to find Miles Lambert and a private investigator on his doorstep. They break the news that Pete’s 2 year old, Theo, isn’t Pete’s real son - Pete and Miles’s premature babies were mixed up at birth when in NICU.

At first, things seem to be going ok. Pete, his partner Maddie, Miles and his wife Lucy, agree that they’ll find a way to share access, and Miles invites Pete to join in with his plan to sue the hospital.
But things soon start going wrong. Miles turns out to be a nasty manipulative piece of work who’s not good at sharing, and the situation gets increasingly nightmarish for Pete and Maddie.

It’s a chilling scenario, and compellingly told. I’m glad I didn’t read it when I was pregnant with my premature DC though.

YolandiFuckinVisser · 03/06/2021 12:50

32 - Hamnet - Maggie O'Farrell
I've seen mixed reviews for this one but I liked it very much

  1. Merivel - Rose Tremain A sequel to Restoration which is definitely in my top 10. Merivel takes up his story 17 years on from where he left off. He is living in his country estate, paid for by the King, with his daughter Margaret, who is now a self-possessed 17-year old and his only comfort and joy. When Margaret is invited to join their neighbours and friends on a sojourn in Cornwall for Christmas, Merivel decides to take himself off to Versailles with an introductory letter from the King to pave his way once there. At Versailles there are various Merivellian adventures involving womanising and experiments with fashion prompted by vanity and insecurity. Having failed to acheive an audience with King Louis, Merivel moves to Paris with the wife of a homosexual Swiss Guard and remains in her house until he is ejected by the husband and makes his way home, where he finds Margaret has been desperately ill with typhus since the day after he left.

I really enjoyed this. Merivel is a fabulous creation, his observations on his own character failings are humerous and poignant. I reviewed another book by Rose Tremain earlier this year (Trespass) and I find it hard to comprehend this is the same author. Trespass was badly-written drivel but Merivel is excellent.

RoseHarper · 03/06/2021 18:32

Reading and enjoying The Survivors! Nothing startling but I've had a run of duds and this is holding my attention. My general guide is that it's a winner if I want to read it through the day and I ve been finding 10 mins here and there to read a chapter.

elkiedee · 04/06/2021 14:53

@Yolandi, I also didn't like Trespass much but have liked several other books by Rose Tremain, esepcially Music and Silence - I think I need to reread Restoration before reading Merivel though, as I probably read it a very long time ago.

YolandiFuckinVisser · 04/06/2021 19:24

@elkiedee - is Music and Silence about a Danish court lutenist? I've read it if so, really liked that one. Maybe she's just better at the historical stuff.

elkiedee · 04/06/2021 19:41

I don't remember those details, but it does sound as though we're talking about the same book - I don't think she's written others about a historical musician at a Scandinavian court.

Tanaqui · 04/06/2021 20:07
  1. The Mirror Crack'd From Side to Side by Agatha Christie. One if the few where I always remember not only whodunit but why, because of the film with Elizabeth Taylor (I suspect it was on TV a lot in the 80s). It's a good Miss Marple, although one of the red herrings is wildly unbelievable. (If you haven't seen the film this is the one where Angela Lansbury plays Miss Marple, but once you come to terms with that the film is quite a good reflection of the book!).

  2. After the Funeral by Agatha Christie. Poirot solves a double murder in an English country house setting.

StitchesInTime · 04/06/2021 20:34

@Tanaqui I watched the film version of The Mirror Crack’d on TV a few weeks ago.

They’d cut out a part of dialogue that turned out to be crucial to explaining the murderer’s motive. Hmm Confused
They’d not cut it out very well either. They’d cut it partway through a sentence, which is how I noticed (and rewound to check it wasn’t me missing things).

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 05/06/2021 00:30
  1. What's Left Of Me Is Yours by Stephanie Scott

Not the sort of thing I would choose but was this months subscription box.

Sumiko grows up believing her mother died in a car crash, but the truth is very far from this.

Inspired by the Japanese profession of 'wakaresaseya' paying someone to entrap a spouse into adultery, I thought it got off to a good start

Unfortunately I did not believe any aspect whatsoever of Rina and Kaitaro's doomed romance, it was all very melodramatic.

I was going to post that I wont remember this book by next year but I had to search the lead characters name to review so it's already fading.

Stokey · 05/06/2021 07:48
  1. The Last House on Needless Street - Catriona Ward. This seems to have a lot of hype surrounding it, comparisons to Gone Girl, Stephen King and Shirley Jackson. It's about Ted, a reclusive, possibly autistic, man who lives on the edge of a forest with his cat Olivia (who also tells the story), and occasional visits from his difficult daughter Lauren. Ted talks about a lost girl with the popsicle who went missing from a nearby lake a few years ago. The girl's sister Dee is another narrator, along with Ted and Olivia, and thinks Ted is involved in the disappearance of her sister. As others have said, it's hard to review without spoiling. The first half of the book meanders along with the horror gradually building, while the second half throws events at you very quickly so you're left a bit disorientated. The reveal is interesting but for me there were a few bits that weren't tied up well or were conviently dismissed. It has left me wanting to chat to someone about it, but don't think it's a classic.
Tarahumara · 05/06/2021 08:35
  1. No One Is Talking About This by Patricia Lockwood. The unnamed narrator is a woman with a job in social media. Her life is all about clicks and likes and shares, until her sister gives birth to a very ill baby and suddenly her priorities change completely. This is an original and powerful book, and is deeply affecting at times. However, the format of small chunks of text jumping from one thing to another, mirroring the bite-size nature of social media posts, made it difficult for me to get fully emotionally immersed in it, despite the desperately sad theme. This was one I respected and admired, rather than loved.
RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/06/2021 08:48

Just started this.

ChessieFL · 05/06/2021 10:17

That just takes me to the Guardian headlines Remus!

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/06/2021 10:36

Sorry. Not sure what went wrong there. The book is called 'Seashaken Houses' and there's a nice review in the Grauniad.

BestIsWest · 05/06/2021 11:32

Interesting row broken out on Twitter on burning books and ‘Wimmins Fiction’. Started by Jeanette Winterson burning some of her own books because she didn’t like the cosy domestic cover design. Lots of writers up in arms.

cassandre · 05/06/2021 11:53

Jumping back into the thread after an absence that was much longer than I meant it to be. @Terpsichore, I’m so impressed that you’re reading the whole of Proust. In fact Proust is to blame for a lot of my exhaustion this term. I had to teach him for the first time ever because a colleague is on leave, and it was so much more labour-intensive than I expected. It’s not my period of expertise at all, and it took hours and hours for me just to get through the assigned text, which was Combray (the first third of the first novel) before I even got started on the secondary criticism. It was like reading a very long prose poem. It’s the kind of book that you need to read at a patient and leisurely pace, and wasn’t at all conducive to the breakneck rhythm of term time. (Yes, I know! I should have started it earlier! And read Proust instead of slacking off with the Women’s Prize longlist!) At least I was only teaching the text to first years (so we were doing a kind of focused analysis of the language rather than a broader exploration of the cultural/historical period), and the students had lectures by a proper Proust scholar, which I most emphatically am not. Blush I complained so much at home that at one point I had DH and the DC asking me every day, ‘Are you done teaching Proust yet?’ Grin And the irony is that my uni is taking Proust off the first-year syllabus after this, so I may well never teach him again. Not even sure I can count my hours and hours of reading as a finished book for the purposes of this thread, because it wasn’t even a whole book. Grin

Anyway, there were moments when Combray did amaze and delight me, but I won’t be rushing out to read the whole of La Recherche any day soon. Terpsichore said in her review, the eponymous narrator, having cherished a love from afar for the aristocratic Duchesse de Guermantes, without ever having actually met her (an unfortunate and now very recognisable character trait of his), finally does meet her and becomes part of her circle, just as his adoration fades. I did laugh at this, because OMG yes, this character trait is already hugely present in Combray. Whether it’s the Duchesse de Guermantes or Swann’s daughter, the narrator spends so long creating fantasies about them in his head that when he actually meets them, it’s a bit of an annoying distraction for him really. Not that that seems to deter him. The students and I talked about how, when these women turn out not to conform to the mental images he’s constructed of them, he doesn’t move from imagination to reality – instead he just reconfigures his fantasy, so that they are playing a new and different role in his imagination. (Sample essay title: ‘In Combray, imagination is not an escape from the world, it is the world.’ Discuss.)

@Tarahumara, I LOVE Deborah Levy’s The Cost of Living. Have been trying to get my book group to read it for ages (no success yet). I like her novels too, but like you I enjoyed the memoirs even more. The third volume Real Estate has just come out, I think, and I’ve put in a request for it at the library. I really like the way she mingles literary references with lots of concrete everyday detail and humour about her own experiences – she has a very distinctive voice. She seems like the kind of woman who would be great to have as a friend in real life.

Very interesting conversation between Cote and LadybirdDaphne about gender and women acting compliant so as not to frighten men (I know I’m paraphrasing here!). It reminded me of a famous article by the early woman psychoanalysis Joan Riviere, called ‘Womanliness as a Masquerade’ (1929). She argues that especially when women enter male-dominated professions, they often exaggerate ‘feminine’ behaviours in order to reassure the men around them. However, she goes a step further as well, and argues that there is no essential difference between ‘being’ a woman and ‘masquerading’ as a woman – ultimately they are the same thing. I think part of the idea here is that women behave in ‘feminine’ ways unconsciously to a degree, because they know it will put the people around them at ease. Looking back at my own career, I can see that I did a lot of that myself, especially early on. I’m more aware of it now and try to be less people-pleasing in general (not just around male academics!). I’m not sure whether it’s nature or nurture, I suspect it’s more the latter, but women are certainly conditioned to do it.

@elkidee, I vaguely remember one MNer, who was a teacher, telling a story about how her students had written a letter to Susan Hill to tell her they felt dissatisfied with the ending of The Woman in Black, and she sent a very grumpy reply, essentially saying they were too thick to understand her genius. Grin I’m not a big fan of her myself.

EineReise, I’m actually reading What’s Left of Me Is Yours right now and struggling to finish it. The Japanese setting is interesting, but like you, the romance is leaving me cold.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.