Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2021 Part Five

1000 replies

southeastdweller · 13/04/2021 22:56

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2021, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read. Could everyone embolden their titles and/or authors as well, please, as it makes the books talked about easier to track?

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

How're you getting on so far?

OP posts:
TheTurn0fTheScrew · 05/05/2021 13:34

Pepe I loved Slaves of Solitude and Hangover SQuare so will give The Midnight Bell a go.

I did manage to get The Girl With The Louding Voice for a quid yesterday - thank you Desdemona

VikingNorthUtsire · 05/05/2021 13:50

Really interesting review of Prairie Fires, Sadik, and while we ended up with different overall verdicts, I can certainly recognise the faults that you describe. I am guessing maybe this is partly because I was just blown away by the story (not just the stories of the Ingalls and Wilder families, much of which was new information to me, but the absolutely mind-blowing story of the American West and the truth of what it was like to be a pioneer farmer) - perhaps being more familiar with this material gave you more space to notice the what, how and why of what Fraser chose to include (while I was just going "OMG THE GRASSHOPPERS")

I did notice that she takes Laura's side - not just (very noticeably) in comparing her to Rose but also, for example, when it comes to Almanzo's sister EJ. There were a few snide comments from Fraser about her which didn't seem to be based on any research other than Laura's account nd the fact that Laura disliked her. I hadn't noticed the comments that you highlight about the writing process (and you make a really good point) but did certainly pick up other times where Fraser oversteps to suggest what someone must have though about a certain event or issue. I had given her the benefit of the doubt as I can see that she's spent months if not years enmired in these people's writings, correspondence, memoirs and opinion pieces, and I trusted her to have a decent stab at interpreting their attitudes - something which I imagine most biographers have to do to a certain extent.

I totally recognise myself as a naïve reader here though - I know there have been a number of other accounts of these people's lives, not least the ones they wrote themselves, and not having read those, I am probably more susceptible to taking Fraser's account at face value than I would if I had other, conflicting versions to compare it to.

Still though - those grasshoppers. Man.

Boiledeggandtoast · 05/05/2021 14:11

Fortuna Many thanks for the personal recollections of Lemn Sissay. I found his book very poignant and affecting when I read it; I can only imagine how painful it must be to learn what happened to him if, like your mother, you had known him as a child.

mackerella · 05/05/2021 18:32

Thank you all for some really interesting reviews recently (and for reminding me about Rupert C-B's May Day ditty Grin). It's an unpopular opinion but I've got a soft spot for Appassionata among Jilly Cooper's novels (as well as the first three Rutshire chronicles, of course).

Viking and Sadik thank you for your wonderful reviews of Prairie Fires! I'm not a LHOTP fan (although I read a couple of the books as a child), but I was really interested to read your reviews because I read Ducks, Newburyport recently and Laura and Almanzo feature heavily in that.

@Hushabyelullaby I'm so sorry that you didn't enjoy Ghost Wall, especially if you read it because of my review. It's always a bit nerve-wracking when other people on this thread read something you've reviewed because then you feel responsible for wasting their time if they don't like it! My review was meant to be ambivalent because I thought that it was quite an odd book, but looking back I can see that it came across as more enthusiastic than I meant it to. (Not helped by the fact that I wrote it several weeks after I'd read the actual book.) The more I'm on these threads, the more I realise that there are some people whose tastes correspond with mine more closely - and so I tend to follow up their recommendations in particular. I'm glad your next book was more enjoyable, anyway! Smile.

SapatSea · 05/05/2021 18:40

Great to see all the praise for Patrick Hamilton. One of my favourite author's too. Hangover Square is my least liked of his books but I know it's the one that sells as his "masterpiece".
I love The Slaves of Solitude too. If you like Slaves then Craven House from 20 years before has a lot of "seed ideas" for Slaves. It's set in a hotel in Brighton in the early 1920's, when many genteel families have been ruined by WWI and had to give up their houses and move into hotel rooms. It's not as good or as polished as Slaves but worth a read.

Twenty Thousand Streets Under the Sky which is the trilogy that starts with The Midnight Bell is superb. If the final volume, The Plains of Cement doesn't make you shed a tear then you must have a heart of stone.

ChessieFL · 05/05/2021 19:49

Appassionata is one of my favourites too mackerella

RemusLupinsBiggestGroupie · 05/05/2021 20:14

Burning Down the Haus by Tim Mohr
A bit niche, as it's about punks in East Germany, but for anybody vaguely interested in the topic, I heartily recommend this. It's not great writing: the writer has a couple of annoying tics, the most irritating of which was the use of 'punchy' five word sentences every couple of paragraphs:
A bit like this one.

However, I found the individual stories fascinating. So many people, all across East Germany, coming together to make music, and routinely getting arrested, beaten and chucked into prison for it.

I found the section post-wall particularly moving, as the squatters moved in and tried to make something new and hopeful in the ashes of the regime. And I adored the old photographs at the end.

Hushabyelullaby · 05/05/2021 20:59

@mackerella

Thank you all for some really interesting reviews recently (and for reminding me about Rupert C-B's May Day ditty Grin). It's an unpopular opinion but I've got a soft spot for Appassionata among Jilly Cooper's novels (as well as the first three Rutshire chronicles, of course).

Viking and Sadik thank you for your wonderful reviews of Prairie Fires! I'm not a LHOTP fan (although I read a couple of the books as a child), but I was really interested to read your reviews because I read Ducks, Newburyport recently and Laura and Almanzo feature heavily in that.

@Hushabyelullaby I'm so sorry that you didn't enjoy Ghost Wall, especially if you read it because of my review. It's always a bit nerve-wracking when other people on this thread read something you've reviewed because then you feel responsible for wasting their time if they don't like it! My review was meant to be ambivalent because I thought that it was quite an odd book, but looking back I can see that it came across as more enthusiastic than I meant it to. (Not helped by the fact that I wrote it several weeks after I'd read the actual book.) The more I'm on these threads, the more I realise that there are some people whose tastes correspond with mine more closely - and so I tend to follow up their recommendations in particular. I'm glad your next book was more enjoyable, anyway! Smile.

@mackerella don't feel sorry, everyone has different tastes, and as I said I really liked the idea of the book. I think it was mostly my problem in that I had expectations which is never a good way to approach a new read.

Palegreenstars · 05/05/2021 21:43

@FortunaMajor thanks for your review of Lemn Sissay’s book. That must be so hard for your mother to learn what had happened since.

I’m listening to the audio which I am finding really accessible with different voices for different reports. God it’s cruel though - Lemn just said that even now sometimes he forgets in his dreams that he now has a loving family.

It’s interesting how authentic case reports seem and then the reality Lemn describes is so different. So few people fought his corner.

Sadik · 05/05/2021 22:24

Burning Down the Haus sounds really interesting Remus - I love this thread so much for the books I would never, ever have come across otherwise.

Viking good point about EJ, and one I hadn't picked up on. I've been pondering the book more, and it's interesting, she talks a fair bit about how Laura and Rose cast the story in the books to fit with their political views around small government and self-sufficiency. But equally, it seems like she's writing from a unstated viewpoint around appropriate behaviour. Rose's messy & chaotic life, and the way it remained enmeshed with her parents' was perhaps just a bit too trailer-park-trash for the daughter of an American icon. That and the fact that both women were, when it came down to it, writing to make money. Which is pretty common for authors (!) but perhaps doesn't fit with the role that the Little House books have taken on.

elkiedee · 05/05/2021 22:30

I read Lemn Sisay's memoir last year - I was so sad for him and his mother that they were kept apart for so long when this clearly wasn't her intention, and I was shocked that the social worker just assumed being part of a white British family would be the best thing for him and ignored the mother's wishes and her letters and lied to her.

He's also a broadcaster (Radio 4) and I'm probably more familiar with his work in that capacity. I think I did try to vote for him as chancellor of Manchester University but couldn't find the details I would have needed to log in to cast my vote a few years ago.

elkiedee · 05/05/2021 22:45

I have a Vintage edition of Twenty Thousand Streets Under the Sky, which is all 3 of the novels in a trilogy starting with The Midnight Bell. I thought it was very good but very bleak. There is also a TV dramatisation made a few years ago which I think first introduced me to it. I have copies of Hangover Square, The Slaves of Solitude and Craven House but need to get to them all.

I collect Virago Modern Classics and Persephone books and have read I'm Not Complaining (which I liked very much) and A Woman's Place from Persephone, a 20th century social history of women up to 1975 (when I think it was originally published). Will have to look at what Furrowed Middlebrow have reprinted by her. I'm shocked by the Amazon Marketplace price being asked for I'm Not Complaining. I've had my copy for a long time and can't remember when I bought or otherwise acquired it.

It's the sort of book which traveled around my family in the late 1980s and early 1990s, as my mum, her sisters, my grandmother and I would regularly give or lend each other books and swap them around (and probably my cousin and my sister too). But I think I first read it that way then and then reread about 10 years ago.

A book listed on Amazon re adoption by Ruth Adam sounds as if it might be by another author of the same name.

Terpsichore · 06/05/2021 07:22

elkiedee good to hear that someone else has read and enjoyed I'm Not Complaining ! Yes, Ruth Adam's novel about adoption is called So Sweet a Changeling. I'm hoping my copy will arrive today, I've had notification that it's been posted.

FortunaMajor · 06/05/2021 09:10

On My Name Is Why My mum is so upset regarding Lemn. She has very strong opinions about fostering and there have been many rants over the years about local families she knows who fostered/adopted and were not kind to the children. She's really annoyed about those she knows from the book, the school head and one of the social workers as she always had them pegged as decent people and this has opened her eyes. Such a sad story and all the worse that his experience is not a one off.

SOLINVICTUS · 06/05/2021 10:16

Have added both Prairie Fires and Burning Down the House to my wishlist!

I am racing through The Holiday by T.M Logan as, as I said the other day, it's a heavy week and I need some crap thriller. And boy this doesn't disappoint.
Utterly unpleasant middle class 40 somethings on holiday in a villa in the south of France (obviously!)
Children that are all so hideous I just hope one of them (or all of them) is going to be the victim. The author has clearly never met or spoken to anyone other than 40 something middle class people as the 5 year old is like a cross between Violet Elizabeth Bott and Hermione and speaks like an 18 year old, the 10 year old speaks like a 3 year old (and gets the lolz by pronouncing "couscous" as "cowcous", which irritated me more than it probably should, as a) it wasn't funny b) a 10 year old, even if a poor reader (he's managing Harry Potter though!) wouldn't have mispronounced only the first syllable and not the second.
There are two teenage boys who started off normal but have gone a bit Lord of the Flies, and a 16 year old girl who leaves her pregnancy test in the communal bin. FFS.
The men are all ineffectual twats, and the glaring plot-hole thus far is that one of the women has been picked up from the airport flying in from Bangkok where she's been living, and yet one of the first things our drippy heroine says to her is how is she finding living back in Europe- when she's been back in Europe about an hour.

It's great! In a really bad way obviously.

In other news, there have been fisticuffs and flounces in the Radio 2 bookclub group on Facebook Grin I've been a member for a couple of months, it's pretty much based on Richard and Judy recommendations and WHS top 20 but sometimes it fits the bill.
Except it went all schoolmarmy over the weekend with people being twatty over other people's spelling and saying "if you want to talk about Crawdads scroll and look for a thread already about it instead of starting your own". Things came to a very middle of the road head when a woman posted something not to do with books Shock and was put on the naughty chair.
700 of us flounced. Grin

SOLINVICTUS · 06/05/2021 11:33

FFS!
Head twat, on seeing a forest fire about to engulf luxury villa has actually said "we need to call the POMPIERS"
Course he did. Because your kids are about to be fried and you decide to show off your wanky middle-class GCSE French skills.

You'll be pleased to hear I'm nearly at the end and will stop ranting soon. Before sending it back for my 99p.

Terpsichore · 06/05/2021 11:35

Sorry, @elkiedee, think I misread your post....I'm not sure whether the novel you saw on Amazon is the same one I mean but So Sweet a Changeling is by the same Ruth Adam. It centres on a couple who lose a baby but have an informal adoption when a single girl decides she doesn't want her baby, but later changes her mind several times. It's from later in Ruth Adam's writing life and from the couple of reviews I've read is a bit more emotive than her earlier work, but sounds interesting - if quite challenging to read, given the subject matter.

I'm keen to read it now, so rather annoyed that it hasn't yet arrived!

Palegreenstars · 06/05/2021 12:29

@FortunaMajor my friend is a social worker and was super impressed that Lemn came to speak about his experiences and focused on the need to change from within.

mackerella · 06/05/2021 12:32

I'm very much enjoying your reviews of The Holiday (and also the mass-flounce from the R2 book club group), SOL Grin.

I'm continuing with my backlog of reviews:

13. Djinn Patrol on the Purple Line by Deepa Anappara

Gosh, this broke my heart Sad. It’s set in a basti (slum village) where children have been mysteriously disappearing. 9-year old Jai and his friends Pari and Faiz decide to investigate, inspired by the cheesy cop shows that Jai loves to watch on TV. The story is narrated from Jai’s point of view, and we have to read between the lines of his naïve discoveries to work out what is really going on.

The author used to be a journalist in India, and she based this book on some of the real-life cases that she had reported on. This research and real-life experience is reflected in the setting, which really brings to life the bustling but precarious life in the basti: the huge network of honorary aunts and uncles who surround the children, the threats from corrupt policemen and neglect by lazy, self-serving politicians, drunken fathers, domestic violence, mothers working their fingers to the bone to clean the swanky flats owned by “hifi” ladies, girls forced to live constrained and stifling lives, primary-aged children working on tea stalls to get money for their families, the overcrowded school where underpaid teachers struggle to manage 50 children per class, sectarian tensions, the way in which the children’s lives are both unimaginably free (they roam the city at will) but also horribly limited… there’s a lot of noise and confusion and smells and colours and dozens of Hindi and Indian English words thrown in as well! Above all, I got the sense of a country in tension – a city where there are huge extremes of wealth and poverty, and where cutting-edge technology sits uncomfortably side-by-side with superstition and a belief in djinns and magic.

The novel did drag a bit in the middle as it settled into a pattern of child-goes-missing-the-children-investigate-but-the-police-don’t-believe-them. I also found the chirpy and faux-naive narrative a bit unsettling, as it made the book sound more like a children's book than the subject matter would suggest. However, it took a much darker turn near the end, and all of a sudden Jai’s make-believe investigations stopped being fun (I don’t want to say too much about the ending because of spoilers, but it managed to be both harrowing and yet also potentially hopeful). It’s quite an upsetting read as a novel, but Deepa Anappara has done a great job of giving a voice to the invisible people who live in these basti slums (apparently nearly 200 children go missing each day in India Sad).

14. Mortimer & Whitehouse: Gone Fishing by Bob Mortimer

I picked this up on Borrowbox – goodness why, as I have never watched the TV programme that it’s based on, nor do I have any interest in fishing. Anyway, it’s a delightful book! The audiobook is narrated by the authors, and their affection for each other is palpable. It starts with their medical stories – Bob Mortimer needed an emergency quadruple heart bypass in 2015 and Paul Whitehouse had a near-fatal colon abscess about 5 years before that – and the two of them compete over who had the biggest health scare, while also managing to discuss more serious topics (what it’s like to be forced to confront your own mortality, the reluctance of middle-aged men to take their health seriously, the feelings of depression and vulnerability that follow a major operation) by stealth. They are both touchingly candid about their experiences, especially Bob, who had sunk very low after his heart op: he cut himself off from friends and colleagues for a year afterwards, and was only persuaded to start “living” again when Paul dragged him on fishing expeditions.

The second part of the book is about these expeditions (which they managed to pitch to BBC2 as a series), and there’s a lot of stuff (some of it surprisingly interesting) about different fish and rivers and tackle, as well as more meditative parts about why fishing is good for the soul (if not the sole Wink). I was particularly gripped by the chapter about fly fishing, and about the Victorian craze for making ever more elaborate artificial flies (often from endangered exotic birds) – this culminated with a frankly mad-sounding story about an American flautist who carried out a heist on a Natural History Museum outpost in Tring, stealing $1 million of rare bird specimens to sell to fly-tying obsessives on the “feather underground” because he wanted to buy himself a golden flute, and escaping a custodial sentence because he'd been diagnosed with Asperger's by Borat's cousin. (Everything about that sentence sounds unbelievable but is true!). During their rambling chats, Paul and Bob fall easily into their roles: Paul is the grumpy and more acerbic one, Bob is the loveable fool, Paul (who is clearly an extremely experienced and accomplished angler) is the grizzled elder guiding the neophyte Bob in the ways of fish and fishing.

The book ends with some of Bob’s riverside recipes (which are designed to be both heart-healthy and also achievable on a camping stove); obviously, these didn’t work very well on audio (or appeal to me personally), but it seemed to keep him happy. Anyway, I thought this was a lovely book, which managed to keep me entertained and amused for 5 hours while also smuggling in some more serious points about men’s health, companionship, mortality (and angling).

StitchesInTime · 06/05/2021 13:48

36. Behind Her Eyes by Sarah Pinborough

This starts with Louise hooking up in a bar with an attractive stranger, David. A few days later, Louise discovers that David is her new, married, boss.
Awkward. But they decide to pretend that it never happened.
Then, Louise accidentally bumps into David’s wife, Adele, one thing leads to another, and soon Louise and Adele are best friends. And then Louise and David start having an affair. It’s all one great big mess that Louise has got herself into here. So far, so psychological thriller territory.
Which is when things start getting really weird, because it’s getting increasingly obvious that Adele knows about all this, and wants it to happen for some reason, despite desperately adoring David.
The final bit that explains the why of it all is the sort of thing that feels like it belongs in a different genre altogether. Readable, but sort of odd.

37. A Sudden Wild Magic by Diana Wynne Jones

Mages from an alternate universe have been looting our universe for ideas for centuries, something that’s causing problems. Now, a secret society of witches and warlocks have noticed that something’s going on, and they’re sending a small task force to the mage’s headquarters to try and stop it.
An enjoyable light read. I think this one’s aimed at adults or young adults.

38. One By One by Ruth Ware

A company ski trip turns into a nightmare trip that ends up with 4 dead, thanks to a murderer in the party and an avalanche. I managed to guess the killer’s identity before the first victim dies, although the motive was unclear at that point.
But when the killer is finally revealed, they give one of those “and now I will explain everything” sort of speeches, where after spending most of the book ruthlessly bumping off anyone who might expose them as a murderer, they then take the time to fully confess their actions and motives to a surviving witness rather than trying to kill them too.

This was a reasonably entertaining bank holiday read, although it’s the sort of book I suspect I’ll have forgotten in a couple of months.

JaninaDuszejko · 06/05/2021 14:54

escaping a custodial sentence because he'd been diagnosed with Asperger's by Borat's cousin. (Everything about that sentence sounds unbelievable but is true!)

I knew about Sir Simon Baron Cohen and his autism-spectrum quotient, scientists (including me) come out as more systeming than average (surprise) but not as much as those on the autistic spectrum although it's easy enough to game the questions.

FortunaMajor · 06/05/2021 15:06

Sol I also flounced! Grin

Palegreen I'm glad Lemn is speaking out. I did wonder whether his file would have materialised if he wasn't who he was. I can imagine someone with no platform being fobbed off. It was fascinating to read his side vs the notes and I'm glad there were a handful of people along the way who helped him and stood up for him.

mackerella · 06/05/2021 15:21

@JaninaDuszejko

escaping a custodial sentence because he'd been diagnosed with Asperger's by Borat's cousin. (Everything about that sentence sounds unbelievable but is true!)

I knew about Sir Simon Baron Cohen and his autism-spectrum quotient, scientists (including me) come out as more systeming than average (surprise) but not as much as those on the autistic spectrum although it's easy enough to game the questions.

Sorry, I didn't mean it to sound as if I thought the feather-stealing flautist had gamed the questions (although this is clearly implied by many people who have reported on this story). FWIW, one of my DCs has been diagnosed with HF autism, so I know that the usual diagnostic process is a lot more rigorous than just going "hmmm, seems a bit weird - check"! (I also work - indirectly - with SB-C and know that he is a controversial figure in autism research circles, as well as not the kind of person who would usually be involved in diagnosis.)

There's a lot that could be said here about how individuals with ASD are more likely to be victims of crime (because of their naivety and willingness to trust people), and also about some of the high-profile cases where autism has been discussed as possible mitigation for criminal behaviour. I'm certainly not suggesting that people with ASD are criminals or that people who have used it as a defence are all faking it - just that some people have smelled a rat in this particular case. (I'm a bit sensitive about this because I can see how easily my own DC could get carried away and end up either being taken advantage of or in legal hot water, and also how people might think ASD was being used as an "excuse" Sad.)

mackerella · 06/05/2021 15:23

Aargh, that was all well OTT. Basically, the flautist in this story sounds like a bit of an arsehole, whether or not he has ASD Grin.

StitchesInTime · 06/05/2021 16:15

In other news, there have been fisticuffs and flounces in the Radio 2 bookclub group on Facebook

Well, that explains a lot!
I was completely off social media for the bank holiday weekend.

There were some odd posts from that Radio 2 bookclub popping up on my news feed when I did go back on Facebook. I was wondering what I’d missed!
It seems to be getting back to normal now though.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.