SouthEast - I loathed, "Fingersmith." I thought it was laboured and trite, and that she was so busy grinding the lesbian axe that it got in the way of the story. Nearly everybody I've spoken to, including my dp, loved it, except one dear colleague whose comment was, "If I want to read Victorian fiction, I'll read the proper bloody stuff instead of this nonsense!" It's nice to see another person who doesn't feel the love.
Having said all that, even, "Fingersmith" was better than the crap that is, "Nightwatch" which I couldn't even finish. I forced myself through about 75% of it, hating every word, and then decided life was far too short - I wish I'd listened to myself after 15 pages!