- When Nights Were Cold by Susanna Jones.
Definitely my last complete read for 2014 :o
The novel is told in flashback by Grace Faringdon, the surviving member of the mountain climbing and Antarctic exploration society she formed at University.
There were originally four members of the group, the fate of the other three is gradually revealed to the reader through the narrative.
The flashback accounts date back to the years immediately preceding WW1, but are told from many years later (around 1940). Grace is, by then, living alone - a recluse - in her old family home. She is an extremely unreliable narrator, and the story twists and turns all over the place; we are never sure quite what to believe.
The focus of the story is the build up to, and aftermath of, the Society's preparation for an ascent of the Matterhorn. We learn about their preparations for this in Snowdonia and later climbs in the Alps.
There is a terrible accident on one of their climbs, of the Breithorn, and one of the group is killed in a fall. The remainder of the novel examines the accountability of the surviving members as seen through Grace's eyes. As I've said above, Grace's account of events cannot be relied upon and we are given strong indications throughout that she has had some kind of breakdown upon her return to London after the accident and has lingering mental health issues which have remained untreated.
What to believe? What really happened? Well, we only have Grace's word for what happened and by the end of the novel you really have no idea what is going on in her head. She seems to live in a fantasy world of her own making. Is she alone, or are there other people living with her? And what about her accounts of her sister? I have no idea now what to believe there.
I wasn't entirely gripped by this novel. I felt that it moved rather too slowly and the ending was confused (probably a strong indication of Grace's own mental confusion) and rushed. I didn't like the conclusion - it felt to me like the author was really at a loss as to how to end it and decided that would do. It didn't fit.
I felt, perhaps unfairly, that this novel was being compared to those of Sarah Waters.
Next up - Jane Austen : A Life in Small Things by Paula Byrne. Have already started it and enjoying it so far.