One Day fans - who is your Emma Morley?

[MugglesandLuna]

Everyone has been slating the choice of Anne Hathaway as Emma, but who do you picture would be better?

I dont know why, but I always picture the woman that played Claire in Corrie, and Shane west from ER as Dex (and I know he is American, and not posh, but thats who I see in my head).

Kelly MacDonald would be fab. She was great in No Country For Old Men.

Wasn't she just LeBoof? She was also great in Remains of the Day and Trainspotting. She is defo my Em

Ithangyewverymuch

I picture emmy rossum as Emma

Eve Best.

Louise lombard

I have only just read the book and have not seen the film but I have to say I also thought Kate Winslett, but probably because I pictured Emma Morley as being about like Hester in Enigma

Everyone goes on about the accent thing and AH not sounding properly Yorkshire, now I have not seen the film so don't know how bad it is, but it occurs to me that a young Yorkshire woman who spends most of her adult life in London would sound considerably less Yorkshire as time goes by. People's accents do become less pronounced when they move away from where they were born. Hence, it might have been a bit unrealistic if she had been played with a strong Yorkshire accent all the way through

I couldn't picture Dex at all but I could see Alexander Armstrong as Ian