Good morning all
Little we're also coastal-ish and very surprised by the snow!
MrsHP I'm sorry to hear you also had a difficult time last year.
for you.
BIWI I think you've hit the nail on the head about why I don't think 5:2 is for me. Not only does it make you obsess about calories, those fast days make you feel deprived (yes, they are do-able, but they DO make you feel deprived). Which means that:
a) you are likely to massively overcompensate on your non fast days, and
b) it makes it so much harder to stay on the wagon, and the WOE so much less sustainable in the long term.
How do I know this? I've watched two of my friends in my office do the 5:2 and have heard all about the misery, every step of the way. Yes, it probably does help you lose a bit of weight, but the misery over making sure you don't exceed 500 calories twice a week is not sustainable.
More moderate fasting (skipping breakfast) seems fine to me. But anything more than that smacks too much of disordered eating to me. As BIWI said - we can enjoy this woe because we can eat yummy food. A WOE that says for almost a third of a week you have to be miserable is not for me.