We have 3 old lads (aged 13+) now, they’ve always gone out with us into the garden, and we made a patch of fresh soil into a litter area so they don’t go & crap all over our neighbours gardens. And it’s cleaned every day - it has to be, or my two giant doods would use it as a fresh bakery counter if we didn’t!
We put cat spikes on all our fences for around £100 (Amazon I think?); before that we’d only let them out if we were with them. It’s not much to pay for neighbourhood peace, with the benefit of stopping your cats roaming into the road or fighting (and picking up illnesses like FIV or FELV which are rife in stray colonies around here, or just reducing fleas).
I love my cats, but I also love the wildlife (we have a wildlife pond, fruit trees, feeders, nesting boxes, woodpile, bug hotels etc.). I don’t understand why owners don’t research more before owning cats, and don’t cat proof their gardens so their cats don’t roam.
Next door, they have 8 cats, all shit with great abandon in my front garden (not the back, our cats can’t get out, other cats can’t come in).
It’s repugnant.