Arg, @YorkshireFelix , I'm so sorry you're still struggling with this. It must feel never-ending, and you must be exhausted. How lovely that your physio said such nice things though - honestly some weeks I hang on Bill's good school reports from daycare 😄
Bill offered a heel this morning, while still on a long line at our morning walk place. This is where he's normally free to go sniff and dig and run around a bit. I got him to sit several times at my side and walk on too. I know it's a tiny achievement but such a big deal for us, he's struggled so much with loose lead walking (and everything else). He managed a record 50 steps (mine not his) of heel walking on lead between rewards on the way home too.
I was thinking about this a bit on the way home from work today as he's at daycare so I had headspace. I think I got really complacent because his recall was so good at six months old, and he was so social and resilient and generally lovely, didn't hump, didn't resource guard, etc etc, and I just wasn't emotionally prepared or sufficiently skilled for adolescence. If his recall had been rubbish, or he'd been a different sort of dog, I might have recognised my weaknesses more, and focused much more on keeping him engaged. Now I'm having to go right back to basics and he's responding so well it's hard to believe (though in fairness to both of us, I do think he's been going through a fear period and was really struggling badly for a few weeks).
I was thinking about @brushingboots saying once (I think - forgive me if I've misremembered) that at six months you decided you had to put pupsy's needs first and that it got easier from then. Was that when you really started training seriously? Because I was also thinking about why adolescence wasn't so awful for you, and why Bill has been so tricky, and I do think it's because it was at about six months that I stopped training seriously - work got really busy and as I say, I got very complacent. So long as his recall was good I could let him roam quite far from me without worrying, so I never focused on building his focus and engagement with me. Then adolescence hit and he was completely out of the habit of focusing on me on walks; he'd become used to making his own choices until I called him away from them.
Anyway, this morning I was much more the centre of his world and it was lovely, and much easier than it's been over the last few weeks. Sausage helped, I'm not going to lie, but working on the very simplest things like responding to his name and sitting have helped so much - in case anyone else is tearing their hair out right now.