@Turquoisesol
Thank you tabulharasa that really makes me feel a lot better. I was thinking growl so next step is bite. But maybe it is more of a grumble and I don’t feel too happy noise
You get things like the canine ladder of aggression - and they’re dead handy for working out the subtler tells of stress, but then they go growl, snap, bite... and barking isn’t even usually on them.
Because barking can mean a load of different things - but so can growling.
You get a sort of low grade growl that just means, ooh, I dunno about this, I’m going to make a bit of noise till I decide whether I’m really bothered or not. Which is what that sounds like it was.
But you get dogs that make happy growling noises when they play or are overly exited.
I’ve had a foster who growled at you when he wanted you to do something for him, like unstick a toy from under furniture, lol
I had a dog years ago that would growl when you told him to do something he didn’t really want to do, like go to bed - he’d do it, but would walk away growling, almost muttering under his breath about it not being fair or something, rofl.
And of course they do do it as a last step before moving on to a bite - but it’s definitely not just that.
Some dogs are just chattier than others.