Rescue dog 1) Came from a pound so not a rescue. We were not assessed or homechecked, nor was the dog.
Many teething problems and unwanted behaviour. Slight aggression towards people and other dogs. Wanted to eat the cat for supper.
Never seriously attacked or harmed anything, dog, person or cat. Two behaviouralists later we have a very fuzzy, well adjusted lap dog who loves a cuddle and a game of tug.
It was hardwork but the whole process was very rewarding and I feel immensely proud of him and me for how far we have come. My bond with this dog is much stronger than other dog we have had previously because of the amount of work we have done together. I'd always said until recently that I would never do it again. I will, without a shadow of a doubt. However I would not advise that anyone go to a pound for a dog. Especially if you are inexperienced or have children.
Rescue dog 2) From a Greyhound rescue. Gentle, patient, excellent on the lead. Super recall. Very loving. Needed a bit of toilet training. Would steal any food she could reach.She was everything we were told to expect.
Rescue dog 3) My Dad's whippet. From a rescue. We were told she needed a very experienced owner, due to previous cruel treatment having left her very wary/possisve of her things/space. Had to go to a childless home, although was friendly with children, much more so than with adults, but is very bouncy so not good for small children who might get knocked down.
She was not as bad as was made out to be but was extremely bouncy with children. My children were used as guinea pigs to help train her not to jump. She is now much calmer and a pleasure to be around. She still has a few issues we were working on but nothing we were not told about before agreeing to take her in.
Rescue dog 4) Found straying on the beach. Taken in directly by us. I have not a bad word to say about this dog. He is the calmest, most patient, gentle, loving, trusting dog I have ever had the pleasure of knowing. He lives with my Dad. I intend to steal him one day. Excellent with everyone, especially small children and babies.
Now for the puppies of our family.
Puppy 1) dd1's Whippety thingy. An adorable, tiny little princess and doesn't she just know it
. Very good at toilet training (but had a very experienced hand training her) slightly jumpy and snappy around children (air snap only, not aggressive) due to my children squeaking like muppets whenever they see her and over exciting her. Does respond well to a 'calmly' command but was trained by a very experienced owner to do this. Despite previous, extensive socialisation from a very early age a bad experience has left her fear-aggressive of other dogs. This is in the process of being worked on.
Puppy 2) Superb with people and children. Recall has gone to pot due to his age (common in adolescent dogs) so cannot be walked off lead atm. Suffers extreme seperation anxiety despite training. Likes to eat wood, mainly doors, door frames and expensive dining tables. Also like to eat carrier bags. Toilet training did not go well. He is clean during the day but was not taught to hold it over night owing to lazy owners who would not get up to let him out to toilet during the wee hours when he was a pup. Hence he was taught it's okay to mess on the floor overnight. He is 'put up with' because of his excellent attitude with children and people - this is mainly down to his breed. He is owned by an experienced dog owner and I have also attempted to train away the seperation anxiety, but he is simply an anxious dog who likes to eat wood. He can also be iffy with other dogs despite excellent socialisation (again down to breeding)
In short if you go to a decent rescue you will get almost exactly what you are told you will get, you will have support to help with training and will only be given a dog you could cope with. If it goes wrong there is support on hand to take the dog back at any point in it's life. The dogs temprement will already have been assessed as will it's suitability for life with children.
If you get a pup the adult dog you end up with depends wholly on how experienced you are at training, how much work you are willing to put in, how other people in your family behave with the animal, it's experiences outside your house (which may not always be under your control) and it's individual personality, which will change and adapt when it ages, particularly around adolescence, which is when most pups end up in rescue only through the failings of their initially well meaning owners. In other words a pup's temprement in adulthood is a complete unknown quantity dependant on many things, not all of which you can control.