Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Help me impress Dh - captain Jack Dr Who question....

56 replies

HonorMatopoeia · 17/06/2007 21:42

Ok, just a quickie so to speak....
Why can't Captain Jack die?
Dh will be evr so impressed if I can tell him!

OP posts:
wurlywurly · 17/06/2007 21:43

because rose saved him and gave him the gift of eternal life.

bonkerz · 17/06/2007 21:45

because when rose inhaled the power from the tardis she bought jack back to life BUT she couldnt control the power so he ended up never being able to die and he will live for ever. had to rewatch dr who today on demand to find out myself!!

Katymac · 17/06/2007 21:45

Because she swallowed the time thingie from the Tardis (Vortex??)

HonorMatopoeia · 17/06/2007 21:45

was that after she did the absorption of the tardis centre thing?

OP posts:
HonorMatopoeia · 17/06/2007 21:46

Aha, yes! Thank you

OP posts:
wurlywurly · 17/06/2007 21:46

how technical are we with our "thingies" pmsl

HonorMatopoeia · 17/06/2007 21:47

Not a true sci fi buff am i??

OP posts:
Katymac · 17/06/2007 21:48

She was consumed by the TARDIS Time Vortex (which is the thing that makes it a time machine) and made Jack live again...permanently

Is that better techy talk?

UnquietDad · 18/06/2007 14:26

So Jack was bounced back to the 19th century and lived through the whole 20th. That means he lived through WW2 twice! Wonder if he was ever tempted to, say, tell people in Coventry to get out before the bombing?

And so in the episode of "Torchwood" where he and Toshiko were trapped in time - he'd have been in 1940 THREE times over!

MrsWho · 18/06/2007 21:41

and apparantly there are Jacks throughout time?
Doctor said to Jack in the radiation chamber?
'its the only man you'll ever be happy with'

SaintGeorge · 18/06/2007 22:07

No, just the one eternal Jack.

He meant that he could meet himself at the end of the universe.

Jack, having arrived with the Tardis, out of time.

And Jack, having lived until the end of the universe.

If that makes any sense at all I deserve a medal.

MrsWho · 18/06/2007 22:29

One contstant Jack but sometimes two at a time because he time travelled!

SaintGeorge · 18/06/2007 22:33

Yes

Aitch · 18/06/2007 22:36

what? but is it not the same Jack, then? [flummoxed]

SaintGeorge · 18/06/2007 22:41

The problem is I understand it perfectly, I just can't explain it very well

SueBaroo · 18/06/2007 22:41

Yes, same Jack but at differet points in his own existence.

Like Back to the Future 2 (the film, not the novelization ) Marty has to be careful in case he bumps into the other version of himself. Same person, different point in their life.

It's all that timey-wimey stuff, you know?

Aitch · 18/06/2007 22:42

but hooooooooow? if he's travelling in time and space then he's the constant.

Aitch · 18/06/2007 22:44

suebaroo. you absolutely CANNOT quote the space/time continuum rules of other productions.

SueBaroo · 18/06/2007 22:47

Exactly.. time isn't a straight line, it's more like a ball of timey-wimey stuff, see.

If Jack is in point A in his life, he then goes off in time and goes something else, then comes back to point A, but in his timeline, it's now point B. But there is still a Jack in point A, because that's now happened, it's in his past.

Like, if I visit my childhood home in 1979, I will meet myself, but it will be a two year old child I meet, not me right now.

SueBaroo · 18/06/2007 22:47

Aitch, I bloody well can, missy, if The Doctor did it, so can I...

Aitch · 18/06/2007 22:52

did the doctor really say 'in back to the future?' i missed that.

SueBaroo · 18/06/2007 22:55

Yup, in The Shakespeare Code, the Doctor explains the elastic nature of time using the 'fading' thing from Back to the Future. I even quoted it in my earlier post.

I do other stuff apart from watch Dr Who, btw. Just thought I'd underline that.

cough

Aitch · 18/06/2007 22:59

ah. i never saw the shakey one. so he actually mentioned the film Back To The Future, did he?

edam · 18/06/2007 23:00

It's also known as the Time Trousers concept. You make a choice and hurtle off down the right leg. But in a parallel universe there's the you who made the other choice and went down the left leg.

(See Red Dwarf, Terry Pratchett and gosh, lots of other entertaining stuff.)

SueBaroo · 18/06/2007 23:01

He did. 'twas most amusing. I love the way it's all self-aware and in-jokey now.