Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Broken. Drama starring Anna Friel as a single mum in poverty. BBC1

269 replies

HelenaDove · 15/05/2017 20:08

Starting on the 23rd May. Written by Jimmy McGovern (Cracker Hillsborough. The Street) it also stars Sean Bean as a Catholic priest.

Trailer.

OP posts:
cowgirlsareforever · 20/06/2017 22:14

I didn't like her but I desperately didn't want her to kill herself.

Toddlerteaplease · 20/06/2017 22:16

The bit with the kids didn't bother me. But the scenes with that really cute dog were tear jerker s. Agree with other posters about her. She's also put a huge burden of guilt on Fr Micheal.

Optimist1 · 20/06/2017 22:17

Well said, TheSecond. She's been the least sympathetic of all the victims of broken society that we've been presented with so far in this programme.

Roomba · 20/06/2017 22:36

I'm really enjoying (if that's the right word, it probably isn't!) this. The only thing that annoyed me was in Ep1 Anna Friel just being turned away at the Jobcentre, being told she'd get nothing for 13 weeks.

A) She would be eligible for JSA Hardship Payments as she had children - it's a lower rate than JSA (which is too low anyway) but would be payable while she was sanctioned, and also while she was waiting for her claim to be assessed.

B) The woman she saw wouldn't make any decision on her claim, just take all the details down. She did explain that, but she then made it sound as though it was a foregone conclusion and just let her leave, not even bothering to explain about Hardship Payments or alternate things she may be entitled to. I didn't find that realistic IME.

Someone asked up thread about people having to wait that long for benefits - if you are 'Vulnerable' ie are disabled, have kids, are a carer etc you can apply for Hardship Payments. Also, you are eligible if you've been sanctioned - I assume someone actually calculated the exact amount required so you don't starve to death but not enough to pay your bills and they give you that amount instead of the JSA.

IME, half the time, employers never bother to fill in the form sent to them to obtain reasons the employee was fired - so they'd be awarded the JSA anyway. But that was a while back and the shop owner looked like the type to fill the form in with graphic detail of why she fired AF!

I found tonight's episode hard to watch, when she was trying to teach her kids how to look after themselves. And when Sean Bean thinks he's averted disaster and then getting that voicemail.

Roomba · 20/06/2017 22:39

I should have also said that Hardship Payments are available if you're sanctioned under Universal Credit rules too.

TheHiphopopotamus · 20/06/2017 22:54

I'm really enjoying it too after thinking I wouldn't. Sean Bean is brilliant as always.

I know someone who was in the exact circumstances as Roz though, so this talk of the book being thrown at her and getting sent down for eleventy thousand years made me lol. The person I knew got 18 months in a low security prison and was out in under a year. But I guess for Roz it was more the shame of everyone knowing what she'd done more than anything.

SkeletonSkins · 20/06/2017 23:04

I had to turn off in the end, I found it too upsetting. How she could watch her children walk away, and to put poor Sean bean in that position too.

speedywell · 21/06/2017 01:24

:(

She had just utterly convinced herself hadn't she, nothing would change her mind and let her believe that she could cope with the shame. She was just so consumed and convinced by it that nothing else mattered.

I have had experience of someone close to me feeling determindly suicidal from time to time and in Roz I can recognise similar entrenched beliefs that just will not fully go away no matter what anyone says.

Made me feel so utterly powerless and fearful so I can really relate to Sean Bean's character.

Hugs to all who have cried in real life and for the stories on Broken.

pottered · 21/06/2017 05:32

It's good, although I think it could've been a little less predictable - didn't like the honest copper's wife banging on about the mortgage, it felt like that scene was misogynistic to me. Shame is a big deal to some people, the type of person who likes lovely designer clothes I could believe couldn't live with the shame.

The friel story line - how did she think she was going to get away with it? I was also surprised about turning down the food bank.

Alittlepotofrosie · 21/06/2017 12:45

I find this really hard to watch but very very good. I thought at the end he'd pick up the phone and talk her out of it. Those poor children Sad

MrsBotox · 21/06/2017 13:02

I found it impossible to sympathise with Roz. She got herself into that fix and carried on stealing from her friend. Dumped her poor dog on someone with no clue how to care for him and left her kids with no mother and a lifetime of guilt. Selfish, self-absorbed and utterly lacking in empathy.

cowgirlsareforever · 21/06/2017 13:09

She became addicted to gambling. I felt sorry for her because of that. Those machines ruined her life and made her not want to go on living any more.

mumofthemonsters808 · 21/06/2017 13:14

I'm really enjoying this series, its excellent.

bumblebee61 · 21/06/2017 13:19

Best thing on TV for years!

The80sweregreat · 21/06/2017 17:23

it is very gripping. i love this drama - not an easy watch though.

Cagliostro · 21/06/2017 17:25

Just watched first episode. So depressing

JustDanceAddict · 21/06/2017 17:59

Didn't like Roz either, prob cos I have been a victim of fraud - the person who committed fraud is thankfully now in prison along with he husband. Not what she did to me, but for major company fraud. I had a very close shave and so lucky dh and I were on the ball.

TheOnlyLivingBoyInNewCross · 21/06/2017 19:04

This episode was the hardest watch for me because she made me so angry. I accept that I have no idea what it is like to be suicidal but I could not believe that she would put her kids through that just because she couldn't bear to be exposed as a thief. I felt no sympathy for her at all because I could not identify with that level of self-absorption, that kind of belief that how she feels is more important that how those kids are going to feel for the rest of their lives. It made me really angry to watch.

lifeisazebracrossing · 21/06/2017 22:05

Just watched episode 4 and it was so upsetting!

Cagliostro · 22/06/2017 14:50

I watched episode 2 just now. Not sobbed over a TV show like that for a long time :( Vernon :( :(

hesterton · 22/06/2017 14:55

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

pottered · 22/06/2017 16:56

agree - another aspect of broken - broken family, broken as a person - is it the gambling we don't have a lot of sympathy for, or is it the fact that she's willing to leave her children over the shame of being a gambler? I imagine that someone that's about to kill themselves does detach, she couldn't do it otherwise.

LouiseBrooks · 22/06/2017 20:16

I just watched it, found it heartbreaking. No she wasn't the most sympathetic character but I thought it was awful.

It's a great programme though.

guffaux · 22/06/2017 22:08

i've been more affected by the roz episode so far- really tearful and feeling far from God-

felt angry and upset about her choosing suicide and leaving her children and dog, but also am crying over her preparations, showing her love for them in practical ways, and not realising that she means more to them all than what she was providing them for the time after her death

just felt really upset for them all, including her, as she couldn't see her real worth to them

ewanthedreamsheep · 22/06/2017 22:18

Am I the only one to be impressed by how much she managed to get done on her final day? washing, ironing, bath, supermarket, dog walk, visit mother, facial, council meeting.....