Active discussions

Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Talk
Telly addicts

Related: Film discussion forum.

Original poster

Peter Capaldi leaving Doctor Who

112 replies

TyneTeas · 30/01/2017 22:22

www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-38805151

OP posts:
Bluntness100 · 31/01/2017 11:43

I'd agree the writing was much poorer, but I do think there is an element of there is a requirement on the actor being able to bring it to life and make it watchable.

We were addicted before, but watched two or three episodes with capaldi and gave up, sad to say, so I imagine ratings are way down, which is a mix of the wrong lead and poor writing. It's a shame as he is a brilliant actor.

I'd agree with the poster who said they changed this to appeal to a certain demographic and when they put an older doctor in it messed with that.

In addition, I've got to be honest, as there was always some unspoken romance between the doctor and his assistant in the new doc who, I found lthe whole older man younger woman a bit creepy. Although they made sure to not make it romantic, it just looked wrong in my view as a pairing. The visible age difference was simply too much.

All in I don't think capaldi was to blame, I think they just got a number of elements wrong and it was pretty much always going to alienate their core demographic.

Davros · 31/01/2017 11:56

They've forgotten it's a kids' programme, albeit with some scares and unusual concepts

HelenDenver · 31/01/2017 12:06

It was always a family programme with the Beeb, never specifically a kids' programme

Aworldofmyown · 31/01/2017 13:09

I've just posted this on another thread!

"I would love Zawe Ashton, would never happen though.

I like PC and think he's a good actor, just not a good doctor who."

WhereYouLeftIt · 31/01/2017 14:55

Well they've been laying the trail for a while now to allow the doctor to regenerate as a woman. I want Helena Bonham Carter!

SemiPermanent · 31/01/2017 15:11

Shock Helena Bonham Carter would be awesome!!

bialystockandbloom · 31/01/2017 15:20

I hope that the show gets back to being about the Doctor and not the bloody assistants

THIS!

Tim Roth would be great! Agree a slightly older Doctor seems more appropriate, even though David Tennant (obviously) was young and best one ever. Think it's like policemen or GPs though, as I get older I can't take anyone seriously who's younger than me.

Best thing (since Clara left) is that Moffatt is finally going too. Hurrah. Mark Gatiss should be the lead writer.

bialystockandbloom · 31/01/2017 15:24

miro re Steven Moffat I do agree though, those episodes you listed were some of the best ever. He was a great writer in those series, he overcomplicated things when he was in charge. And the production has been terrible for the last two series, so dark and noisy and the dialogue just stupidly fast and mumbly.

TizzyDongue · 31/01/2017 15:36

Imagine the mass hysteria and tantrums if the doctor was female! She'd be the worse Doctor and the least popular before it even aired.

Lunar1 · 31/01/2017 17:48

Another vote for Tim Roth!

Andylion · 31/01/2017 19:11

I've liked all the Doctors since I began to watch DW, starting with Eccleston. I agree with pp that the writing had been a problem for PC's stint.

Also, yes, to more Malcolm Tucker.

Nibblets · 31/01/2017 19:37

According to The Guardian, the new Doctor MUST be a woman. I didn't read the entire article - www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/2017/jan/31/doctor-who-new-time-lord-woman-peter-capaldi because
my mind was filled with images including having to confront challenges such as the state of the lavatory on the Tardis - 12 previous occupants, all single males aged between 903 and several 1,000 years old. At least there would be infinite cupboard space. Whoever gets the job would be well advised to spend the first episode travelling back through time to get supplies of Jeyes Fluid and a stiff brush. The Izal medicated paper would create merry hell in the nearest black hole. Personal ask: Could she pop back to 1966 and find Jamie, the Doctor's companion who subsequently got transported to the planet M-ER-Dale?

MsAdorabelleDearheartVonLipwig · 31/01/2017 21:04

Thanks TizzyDongue, it's not just me then. Grin

Lunar1 · 31/01/2017 21:42

A female dr would work if it was Catherine Tate. I really wanted to hate her when she was cast with tennant, and sobbed when she lost her memories.

JustDanceAddict · 31/01/2017 22:17

Yay! I stopped watching it this series and have watched all the new incarnations. Tenant still the best but Matt Smith grew on me.

WhereYouLeftIt · 31/01/2017 22:28

The Tennant-Tate series was my favourite.

CalmItKermitt · 31/01/2017 22:42

I bloody LOVED Donna!

Riversleep · 31/01/2017 22:43

I never really warmed to him tbh. It still seems like he hasn't found his character traits yet he's on his 3rd series. I think they decided to make him a grumpy old man, which backfired, then tried to make him have a midlife crisis. I was just a bit bored with it, as were my DC, who used to love it, to the point that I was driven to distraction by the endless Doctor Who DVDs! It will be I teresti g to have a clean slate of new Do for and new writer.

Riversleep · 31/01/2017 22:47

nibblets Smith and Capaldi were married to River Song, so not single. I think Tennant was married to several people! I agree about the rest. A out time they shook up the white male demographic. I'd like Sacha Dhawan or Richard Ayoade.

Nibblets · 01/02/2017 07:57

Oops! Apologies for not keeping up; I must admit I stopped watching when Sylvester McCoy took the role; since then I've watched if the family's tuned in.

HelenaGWells · 01/02/2017 11:10

Tennant - Tate was my favourite as well. I was expecting to hate Donna as I'm not a fan of the actress she was brilliant in this season. I loved the dynamic between the two as well.

I hope this means The Thick of It can be made again. They couldn't really ask for a better time to write it.

This may be why he's left we won't know for a while though.

I suspect one reason is because Moffat is leaving as well and changing writers and Doctors at the same time makes sense. He has also done 3 series which is the same as the others bar Eccleston who only did one. Tennant and Smith both did 3 each.

Although I'm all for having great women in sci-fi I think the doctor SHOULDN'T be a woman, nor should they be a different race. The doctor is supposed to be one person regenerating it makes sense that they regenerate from a white male into a white male. If they regenerated more randomly it should have been done long before now. It's just too ridiculous to say oh look we had 14 white males and now BAM black woman. The doctor also has wives spread throughout time and history as we've seen. It just doesn't make sense to change the white male dynamic.

What they need to focus on is making the assistants stronger and sassier and having them really take a strong role in their own right beside the Doctor. Give us another kick ass Donna rather than another simpering lovestruck Rose.

HelenaGWells · 01/02/2017 11:14

re Steven Moffat I do agree though, those episodes you listed were some of the best ever. He was a great writer in those series, he overcomplicated things when he was in charge. And the production has been terrible for the last two series, so dark and noisy and the dialogue just stupidly fast and mumbly.

yes to this. Some of the early episodes he wrote are some of my absolute favourites but he just seemed to loose it in the head writer role for some reason. I'm not sure if there was a change in director/producers as well as I've noticed the production shift also.

TinselTwins · 01/02/2017 11:28

yeah I would if I were him, he never got to make the role his own, he was just Clara's side-kick!

TheDrsDocMartens · 01/02/2017 11:36

Don't want a female doctor. Not sure who I do want yet.

Loving the idea of Dominic Cooper as Bond.

TheDrsDocMartens · 01/02/2017 11:40

Google suggests Matthew Baynton, like that idea.