Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Teenagers

Parenting teenagers has its ups and downs. Get advice from Mumsnetters here.

DD doesn’t want to drive

92 replies

backinthebox · 19/11/2024 11:58

DD has turned 17, and I assumed it would be high on her list of priorities to learn to drive. We have a small car that she is insured on and could drive whenever she needed it, and have paid for driving lessons for her. She had a few practice sessions with DH, and I don’t know exactly what went on but she will now not drive with DH in the car, and won’t have a go with me either. She tells me her weekly lessons are progressing well, but not so well that she feels she wants to drive our little car anywhere with me in the passenger seat.

We live rurally, and there is no public transport within 2 miles of us. This was not the case when we moved here, but the local council decided that posh village folk did not need buses 🙄 and cancelled all the services some years ago, despite this being a thing we looked for when moving to our current home. We cannot let the children grow up isolated from their friends and social lives, so we have always given them lifts anywhere they need to get to, without question, but DD thinks it is not unreasonable for this to continue and that she can call us to collect her at any time of day or night with very little notice. She is undiagnosed ND, probably ASD, and this leads her to be both very abrupt in her requests for lifts, and also anxious about learning to drive when there are other cars on the road. It’s wearing me out a bit.

How do I persuade her to move forwards with this? The car is there for her, but she doesn’t like changing gear - is it a ridiculous suggestion to just take the car to a dealership and swap it for an automatic, and learn and do the test in that? I would just like to be able to get to the end of the day without having spent 2 hours driving her around when there is the means for her to do that herself if she applied herself to it. The trains were not running last week, and instead of driving her to the train station a few minutes away, I had to drive her to and from school, in my week off, and it took literally hours each day.

OP posts:
pucelleauxblanchesmains · 20/11/2024 15:04

I have ASD and am learning to drive (no way would I have managed aged 17 but then I didn't live rurally either). I would say: she's learning, and if you push her too hard with time limits etc you risk her giving up altogether. Especially if like me she has the tendency to freeze/shut down when stressed - which is obviously something I have had to unlearn while driving and this in itself has taken time.

pucelleauxblanchesmains · 20/11/2024 15:04

I have ASD and am learning to drive (no way would I have managed aged 17 but then I didn't live rurally either). I would say: she's learning, and if you push her too hard with time limits etc you risk her giving up altogether. Especially if like me she has the tendency to freeze/shut down when stressed - which is obviously something I have had to unlearn while driving and this in itself has taken time.

NotUoufjds · 20/11/2024 17:20

Genuine question to people here if your DC genuinely tried so hard but couldn't pass and just found it hard would you stop giving them lifts.

waterrat · 20/11/2024 19:18

If you think she is autistic Op please help her actually get a diagnosis

this is very relevant for her anxiety around driving for example

Would you consider moving? I would prefer an anxious teen didn't feel pressured oto learn to drive.

SD1978 · 20/11/2024 19:31

She doesn't need to learn, because you've capitulated completely on the need to, and she's happy with the status quo of being driven around. She's at a school she can't get to, and you facilitate this to the detriment of your son. Her da dashed her to do a (sim0e) driving tasks, she didn't want to, you agree with her she shouldn't have had to, and now she refuses to drive with either of you, and you continue to provide lifts when and wherever she wants. Sorry, but if there is no consequence, why would she learn. You re concerned there may be some neurodiversity, but it seems you just allow it all her way to compensate this, which if she does get into where she wants for uni will stop abruptly, and no one will care that she needs everything her way. I'd stop driving her to school, and look at getting an automatic license, and also have an expectation of driving x amount. Can you buy a cheap automatic car? They are so much easier and quicker to learn on

SometimesCalmPerson · 20/11/2024 20:03

Doesn’t the fact that she’s telling you she’s too nervous to practice with you despite being unable to drive being inconvenient for her tell you that she has genuine anxiety about it? Some people just do, driving isn’t for everyone. I know a few very competent adults that just can’t drive for whatever reason.

My ds is also autistic (independent and working full time) and as much as I’d like him to be able to drive, if he feels like he can’t do it well then I’d rather he wasn’t on the road tbh.

If her lessons with an instructor are going ok, what’s the big deal anyway?

Octavia64 · 20/11/2024 20:31

@NotUoufjds

My DD is 24.

She's been having driving lessons since she was 17. Failed 3 times so far.

AuDHD. Probably never going to pass.

Yes I give her lifts.

verycloakanddaggers · 20/11/2024 20:37

she is applying to uni atm and has her Cambridge interviews and assessments, and we don’t want to derail those as it’s all she wants to do. She has a very focussed approach to things, and she is focussed on that atm, the driving is just fluff as far as she is concerned, no need to do it as she can just ask for a lift. I think she is reasonably good at spatial awareness and working memory - she scored the 2nd highest GCSEs in the county, and competes at international level in a sport that requires huge amounts of spatial awareness. So these are not excuses.

She's only 17, is working her arse off, is potentially ND, and is taking lessons.

I think give the kid a break. You sound a bit much.

If you can't give a lift on X day, just explain. But she's not doing much wrong as far as I can see.

Arran2024 · 20/11/2024 20:38

My daughter doesn't drive. She is diagnosed asd. I dont think it's a good idea for her. She is so black and white - she can't cope with other drivers making mistakes, changing their minds etc and I am not convinced that she wouldn't have a crash just to prove herself right! Also she is better at one thing at a time and I'm sure she could drive OK along simple roads with no distractions - it's the distractions she wouldn't cope with.

I see it as part of her asd. She has moved out now but for years I drove her around. Now her boyfriend does it.

If your daughter is off to uni the problem might disappear tbh. She may live in towns with public transport in future.

BeatriceAndLottie · 20/11/2024 20:41

NotUoufjds · 20/11/2024 17:20

Genuine question to people here if your DC genuinely tried so hard but couldn't pass and just found it hard would you stop giving them lifts.

No. I’d switch to a better instructor and go for automatic.

NotUoufjds · 20/11/2024 20:45

Octavia64 · 20/11/2024 20:31

@NotUoufjds

My DD is 24.

She's been having driving lessons since she was 17. Failed 3 times so far.

AuDHD. Probably never going to pass.

Yes I give her lifts.

My DS passed automatic at 23. Found it so so hard but managed to pass on the 3rd attempt.

Lovemusic82 · 20/11/2024 20:46

My dd is similar but has a diagnosis of ASD and dyspraxia. She’s away at uni at the moment so doesn’t need a car (she’s living in a city) but when she returns she will need to drive to be able to find work or go out with friends as we live rurally. I’m trying to persuade her to learn in an automatic but it’s hard to get automatic lessons here.

it sounds like your dd is learning at her own pace but doesn’t want you or dh involved in the process which is fair.

Thevelvelletes · 20/11/2024 20:52

I had one lesson from my dad it put me off learning for life.
One of my regrets in life is not learning to drive.
Leave it to the professionals to teach if that's what she prefers.

Pickles001 · 20/11/2024 20:54

for me, id like to drive but its the cost of having a car, and paying for lessons the risks of theft, ect

if ££ was covered then id learn to drive and have a smart car as they are nimble

DuesToTheDirt · 20/11/2024 20:58

Going out with her mum or dad in the passenger seat is very different from having lessons with an instructor, or even getting practice with one of your friends, which is maybe why she said she'd consider that. Parents can be judgemental or scared or bossy, and even why they aren't the child may think they are, or just feel under pressure. If she's resisting going with you two but OK to carry on with lessons I'd do that for now.

saraclara · 20/11/2024 21:06

I learned purely through lessons. There was no way in hell that I'd have practised with my mum (the only driver in the family) in the passenger seat, and as a nervous driver, driving without the dual controls would be a massive extra stress.

It probably took longer, and I actively hated learning to drive, but it's doable. If it goes on too long, talk to get instructor about learning in an automatic.

mugglewump · 13/03/2025 19:58

I imagine she is suffering from anxiety and finding the driving very stressful. Could you buy her an electric bicycle to get around on? If you stop the lifts because she has her own transport, and she doesn't like cycling in all weathers, she might decide to give driving another go.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread