Right mumsnetters, what ring?

[ElfOnTheTopShelf]

DH & I were broken into a while ago, and we have just had the insurance money through, including vouchers for jewerly.

Which ring do you think is better?

this one

or

this one

Thanks!

Definitely the sapphire.

I like the emerald

emerald here

I agree with Cyteen - I far prefer the sapphire ring.

Cyteen, thank you so, so much for all your help x

Oh bless you Rinders! I didn't do anything, did I? Except warble on. What a lovely thing to say Hope things are looking up for you all x

the emerald

am leaning towards the emerald; my engagement ring is sapphire so not too sure if it would look too similar

I prefer the emerald- it's more classic in design. Although my engagement ring is white gold and sapphire. But the style of the emerald one is less 'trendy' and likely to date, imo.

The sapphire is simple and very pretty. Definitely that one.

The second one is beautiful

emerald here too

right, am collating votes in the morning

they are both pretty but i like the second one best

Emerald - just. They're both lovely.

first one best

Emerald

Emerald also - love it!

Sapphire gets my vote!

Neither, they are coloured pretty glass.

You can get a beautiful (real) antique one on ebay for that.

I would chose the sapphire of those two.

this is lovely and 'real' sapphire, bet you could get this for under 300

The OP has vouchers for Ernest Jones, by the sound of it though.

Emerald.

this one

Ok, sorry I didn't realise that. The rings you have chosen are just coloured crystal which means the constituent parts are worth about £30. At least the one above is a real emerald/diamond.

Ah, I didn't realize they weren't real stones.