Which engagement ring do you prefer?

[PassiveAggressivePanda]

Which do you like best?

Thank you all. The right one is oval, I think the flash made it look more square for some reason!

I've enlarged it as far as it will go on my laptop screen and the blob at the bottom looks more like a claw at me - I am convinced it's rectangular and it looks like a radiant not an emerald cut. We need @PassiveAggressivePanda to come back and confirm the cut of number 2 as it's impossible to be certain from the photo.

x-post - as if by magic!

I still prefer the round one to the oval.

@TofuTuesday correct! The smaller one is natural and the larger one is lab grown.

Smaller one

The right one. It's proportions suits your hand better

The bigger one. The small one is lost on your hand and looks nondescript,

Thought so! I would go with the natural stone every time. I also like the simple classic look of it.

Are they both set in the same metal/metal purity?

Left one is much prettier imo

The most expensive one.

Left one

The one on the right 😍

Left one is meh and looks cheap . Sorry just my opinion !

We looked everywhere for a ring like the one on the left, I specifically wanted one where I could get my hand in and out of pockets. It never catches on anything, and I never need to take it off.
I think it’s elegant and understated.
The second one also looks nice. I just think you’d take it off all the time, and then potentially lose it.

The bigger one

Right one.

Another vote for square one .

I’m so confused why people are calling the oval shape square, even before you posted another pic.

I personally prefer ethically mined diamonds over lab grown because I love the history attached. If you’re not bothered about that then the bigger one does suit your hand. I’m not usually a fan of the big lab grown garish rings but this one is lovely and not too big.