What does everyone think of this jacket?

[Tallzaragirl]

https://www.marksandspencer.com/feather-and-down-puffer-jacket/p/clp60689996?color=SPICE&extid=psps-pla-pmaxgglwwch_-UK--bausmeccounterfactual&gadsource=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD7g6bQtciMr5kSAAP1xTXN2r9fY&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI77WT5p7tiQMVd5JoCR2OYBx0EAQYASABEgIXhfDBwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

I tried it on in-store and it's so comfy, soft and warm.

Not too sure though. What does everyone think?

It’s just sooooo 2007…

I've got something similar from Zara, warm and comfy to throw on when I'm going for a casual look, had lots of complements on it, I prefer it in black 🙂 have a look on vinted, got my Zara one for £14 and was perfect condition.

You have all put me right off it anyway 🤣

Fwiw it does cover my bum. I don't know what shape I am but I'm 5"6 and 9 stone.

I'm not going to buy it 🤣

It’s a nice coat definitely prefer the lighter colour to the black. The black makes it look basic

Look I wouldn’t buy it. I think it’s too short and I didn’t like the colour but if you like it get it!

you say it’s comfortable, you obviously like the style as you picked it up to try it on so bugger what anyone else thinks.

Have you looked at the longer ones in uniqlo?

I like it and have seen it IRL - it looks v cosy and is less orange than the pics.

I am in the market for a new short puffer though as I’ve never got into the maggot coat trend.

Too short - I have a similar length one I got in a Next sale and it's lovely and warm on the top half but my bum is always freezing.

Also not keen on down lined things - I had a jacket with this and if it rained the feathers stuck together in a clump and my shoulders were wet - even with just a shower.

Very masculine. Ok if that's your vibe

It's ok.. But of you like it that's the main thing. It's not awful

MandM have half price puffers

Hell would freeze over before I bought a jacket that had caused suffering to animals.

Plus, it’s also a horrible colour imo

Boring as what it looks like.

However M&S do not use feather or down that is taken from live ducks or geese.

@Ginkypig I know we shouldn't care what others think, but I have been known to really regret purchases.

I don't want to be walking round with people thinking "wtf is she wearing".

What the heck is an AWIN link? Looks like a regular M & S link to me.

I don't like it OP. Don't like the pockets or the collar. M & S plain ones are more stylish.

I need things to cover my thighs as I really get cold there!

embassyofbricksandlogs.com/product/fargo-puffer-jacket-black-olive/

Mine is no longer made but this is the updated version of it. Mine is olive green with teddy coloured fleece in the hood. Side zips and slightly longer at the back than the front. Honestly, it's an absolute beezer of a coat and worth every ridiculous penny I paid for it.

I have a shortish puffa/parker. It sits on my hips. I wear it with flares or wide legs and think it looks better than my longer coat. I am tall and slim.

I dont like the collar, the colour or the length.

Personally I wouldn't wear it - puffer coats of any kind make me feel smothered and claustrophobic and I also dislike the colour. But if you like it, buy it. Even if it's not to everyone's taste, nobody is going to notice it and think 'What a terrible coat'. It's not something that's going to stand out and draw attention.

Won't you get a cold bum? Why have such a warm jacket for your butt and legs to freeze?

I really disagree about it being frumpy- i really like it and it looks like something from urban outfitters that my teen and her friends would love- so I suppose if you are happy to dress like a teen!
I don't suit short jackets but if I did, I would wear this. Maybe without the down.

No teen around here would wear that! The only person I can imagine it on is Doris from Gavin and Stacey.

Hmmm, I'd never wear that colour (too muddy and blah), but it might suit you. Everyone has different colouring. It's a fairly ordinary jacket - I'd want it a bit longer, to at least cover my bottom. Other than that, fine, but not unlike a hundred other puffer jackets you could buy.

But the main thing is, if you like it & it's comfy & warm, and a good price, then go for it!