Just looking for a waterproof coat at the moment and came across this thread, which was really helpful. I already have a Janelle and a shorter, older Seasalt jacket, but want something shorter than the Janelle and a bit more lightweight to carry if taking off while on holiday.
I've been going round in circles a bit as don't want to be too warm going in and out of warm buildings on holiday (hence not wanting something bulky to carry).
I'm looking at the Didriksons Marta at the moment - which is just a thin waterproof - and wondering about layers under it, instead of a warm coat. Does anyone have a Marta?
Actually the best solution that's always worked for me before (for heat regulation) was a Cotton Traders waterproof - has that country look similar to the Jack Murphy coats. The Cotton traders one was very cheap! Completely waterproof and not thick, but kept you warm as it made you sweat! Which meant it was ideal for most weathers and could wear a bodywarmer under it in freezing temperatures.
So I could take that on holiday but - it's a bit country outdoors looking.
I like the Helle coat a lot but thinking it could be too warm. It's annoying that Didrikson don't have anything in between a thin Mac and their "mid warm" coats. The nearest thing to that in between warmth is something like the Janelle (which definitely isn't warm enough in winter weather and needs layers. But want something shorter and less bulky.
Any tips appreciated!