A mascara that doesn't end up smudged under your eyes - does it actually exist?

[AbbyGal]

Because I've never found one and I must have bought practically everyone on the market.

Help please!

Third-ing the no 7 tubing mascara. Bought off a recommendation on here and v impressed

I get no smudging using Max Factor Masterpiece Max.

Another vote for Boots No 7 waterproof! It’s amazing! I have very long eyelashes which means that mascara smudges very easily on me. I’ve never had any smudges with this one. Definitely recommend!

No 7 waterproof and lights camera lashes by tarte

Bobbi brown No Smudge mascara

Tubing mascara!! Idk how people wear anything else but that! There’s also a vegan/cruelty free version of it but rather exxy

This, it's a tubing mascara and is great. Does flake a bit though

Another vote for the no 7 tubing mascara. I spent years of my life with mascara always giving me panda eyes and then I bought that one on the off-chance a few years ago. Never looked back since!

Tubing mascara. I use N07 Stay Perfect and it doesn't budge. All mascara would smudge on me until I discovered tubing mascaras. Game changer.

I had this problem for years (greasy eyelids) until someone told me I needed waterproof mascara. Game changer. Even the cheapest of the cheap - if it's w/p it doesn't move

I had this problem for years. I tried every waterproof mascara on the market.
I was talking about it at a benefit counter and the consultant told me I need pressed powder under my eyes. They sold me a powder foundation that I use a brush with. I can now buy any mascara

Just to add I still use my normal foundation

Clinique power lash , it’s really good , will only come off with warm water

i use the No7 tubing mascara Stay Perfect and a little mineral powder foundation (Lily Lolo) around the eyes. Doesn't budge.

I have super-greasy eyelids and found nothing stayed put until the powder revelation. Game changer!