Ha, @neverenoughchelseaboots I swear by these ones from Camper (excuse long link, I haven't the patience to figure out hyperlinking): www.camper.com/en_GB/women/shoes/iman/camper-iman-K400299-001
They've been around for a few years, I buy a pair in black every time they're in the sale (I have three pairs at various stages of life).
They are the only boots I've put on that were immediately comfortable, and only today (on the school run, in my puffa jacket and cashmere snood) did I think "my feet are really comfy and warm right now".
The photos online make them look shorter than they are, they're a standard above-ankle height.
Occasionally I mess with Joules Chelea boots - as one of the only other brands that doesn't have that annoying shapeless baggy bit over the bridge of the foot. But always come back to the Campers.
Do you have favourites I've missed?