I really enjoyed different takes on “flattering”, particularly your observation that it tends to mean “makes you look smaller”
ilovecherries. That’s always been my interpretation too.
I like Toast and its ilk because they’re clothes I can put on and forget about. I like feeling comfortable and not looking like everyone else. I detest clothes that show my shape because I’m pretty shapeless these days. And I absolutely love blue, it holds a visceral appeal for me, it raises my spirits and it suits me because I have blue eyes. That’s as close to flattering as I’m prepared to go.
Regardless of what anyone else says, I reckon you don’t love the dress ilovecherries or you’d have ripped the tags off and worn it. I won’t buy anything if I don’t love it these days.