A pencil eyeliner that stays put?

[Tabooandlemonade]

Is it too much to ask??

Just looked in the mirror after a long lunch/meeting and again my eyeliner (applied only to upper lids) has transferred off my lids to under my eyes. Why. How?

Or is it my eyes? This one is black Green People, I’ve tried Rimmel, Estée Lauder too and the same. My liquid liner stays out but I don’t really wear it in the day.

Any recommendations for one that stays in place?

Stays *put

I use Clinique Quickliner for Eyes Intense. I love it. It only seems to come off when I want it to come off. I’ve even gone to bed without removing on a few occasions (slaps wrists) and it still looks good in the morning.

Thank you @LadyDanburysCane will try it! I’d prefer to have to work to get it off than have it slide about my face on its own terms

I've only used it once, but the Beauty Pie gel liner stayed put all of yesterday for me! Nice colours too.

Avon is the best one Ive used so far 👌

Stila stay all day. Although my eyes are now so hooded ive given up with eyeliner

As above....Avon glimmer stick for me in blackest black but other colours are available! Not a massive Avon fan but swear by these

@keeponkeepinon

Sorry but I've just finished a clinique quickliner, it ran our really quickly and slid down just as much as pencil on me. I'm trying a max factor felt tip type one next. Used to rate the bourjois one but you can't get it anymore

Was it an “intense”? I find the intense much better than the standard. I use my black one two or three days a week and it lasts a few months. Other shades I use less frequently and they seem to go on forever.

Avon push up pencils; they stay on all day....better than anything else I’ve tried.

Urban decay primer makes anything stick, but I also use the urban decay eyeliners, the 24/7 ones.

If you have oily lids there may not be a product that works. Had a bit of success with this one
www.kikocosmetics.com/en-gb/make-up/eyes/eye-pencils/Intense-Colour-Long-Lasting-Eyeliner/p-KM00303020

So many to try, thank you.
Am guessing you can buy Avon direct now? I don’t have to find A Lady?

100% Estée Lauder double wear pencil it literally does not budge till you take it off! I couldn't recommend it more

@sharronsmiths

Avon is the best one Ive used so far 👌

Same here. I’ve had eyeliner at every price point and Glimmersticks are the best I’ve ever used. Loads of colours too.

Estee Lauder Double Wear. Was the Estee one you used the Double wear one? I'd be surprised if that was off by lunch time

Yeah the double wear one with the built in smudger, I have a black one and after all day at work it's still on when I get home

@Tabooandlemonade yes to the Avon online. I no longer have an Avon lady either, so just buy direct.

Caviar stick

Definitely Quickliner Intense! Lasts ages so well worth the price.

@Tabooandlemonade

I got a three pack of the blackest Avon Glimmersticks from Amazon! Other colours are available - I got a brown colour too - cosmic brown!

The Avon ones are reduced to £4 on the website at the moment.

Bobbi brown

Victoria beckham kajal liner. Its amazing.

Also just bought an Avon one
I had resorted to liquid liner but feel it is harsh and tricky to apply.
Looking forward to trying the Avon one