A pencil eyeliner that stays put?

[Tabooandlemonade]

Is it too much to ask??

Just looked in the mirror after a long lunch/meeting and again my eyeliner (applied only to upper lids) has transferred off my lids to under my eyes. Why. How?

Or is it my eyes? This one is black Green People, I’ve tried Rimmel, Estée Lauder too and the same. My liquid liner stays out but I don’t really wear it in the day.

Any recommendations for one that stays in place?

[Tabooandlemonade]

Thanks all, ordered the Avon one as it’s on offer!

[lindyloo57]

I think its different ones suit different people, I've tried the double wear one, rimmel, Avon and many others, none of them last long on me, I had a bit more luck with a wet& wild one but it only lasted a little longer than the others,

[KatharinaRosalie]

Maybelline Tattoo Liner, and I've tried many.