Which coat do you prefer? (Pics included)

[justanotheryoungmother]

I know they're winter coats but I want to buy one now so I have one for the winter (and while it's discounted). I think they're both lovely but I really can't decide on which one is nicer. Both lovely but different styles

Which one do you prefer?

If it helps, it'd be bought in size 12/14

I much prefer the first one, it's lovely.

Oh the longer wrap one without a doubt

I like the first one but both are nice.

The first one

Including taking size into account will end up buying a 14 due to the baby weight

The first one.

First one, no question about it! Gorgeous

The first one looks like a coat my mother had in the 80s
It's very mumsy

Out of the two I'd go for the second one
But I'm not fussed on either sorry

No1 also looks like a nana dressing gown

The longer one. Gorgeous, elegant, will keep your bum toasty. Oh, how I love a good coat. It's the first thing people see as well. *swoon

I prefer the look of the first and it looks like would be warmer round the collar area as buttons all the way up. They are both lovely though.

P.S: I like pea coats /sailor jackets too (ie the shorter one) but prefer them to be classic navy. They are more weekend-y/casual imo. Great with jeans, wellies, woolly jumper.

Second one. First too much like my grans.

The first one is beautiful!

I like both but would wear them for different occasions. 1 is smart, 2 more smart casual

The first one, very elegant and a beautiful colour.

The first if you're tall, the second if you're not!

I'd buy the second for myself.

I have a black version of the first one and I LOVED it - then I started getting jokey comments off of people at work saying it looked like a dressing gown and now it's ruined it a bit for me and I don't wear it as much!

So if you might be similarly bothered about comments like that (they happen at least once per wear) then that's something to keep in mind!

I'd go for the second one. I always feel like a sack of spuds tied in the middle when wearing a belt tie coat. If you have a bit of a post baby tum like I do, the first coat might highlight it more.

First one

Second one - the peacoat.

First

First one.

I agree peacoats are better in navy (or black or charcoal).

First one

Sorry, neither. First one will end up looking like a dressing gown on anyone who isn't a XXXS, and the second one is lovely but too short. Need me some proper coverage!