Looking at Google Maps, it's more like a 25-minute walk. Grr...
But Stropps, and all, you are of course right. He will be fine. It's just so confusing and stressful. While Ofsted reports are of course flawed, they're the only things we have to judge the school on. Even visiting doesn't necessarily help, as I don't know what to look for, other than a 'nice feeling' which doesn't mean much.
School choice 1 is the closest, but is the Ofsted Outstanding school all the middle-class parents want, and where people rent houses on the roads nearby to get into. Two Choirs! Most of his nursery friends will be going there, and lots of my friends' children.
School choice 2 was what I was expecting. Brand new building, wonderful head, separate reception building to the rest of the school.
Number 3 was in the opposite direction, but a good school.
The one we got is just an unknown quantity, and takes me right out of my comfort zone. The main building is in Walthamstow Town Centre, and looks a bit, well, rough. All busy roads, lorries, bustle, etc. And 25 minutes away!