Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Style and beauty

Looking for style advice? Chat all about it here. For the latest discounts on fashion and beauty, sign up for Mumsnet Moneysaver emails.

WATERPROOF bum-covering COATS: I am doing the research so you don't have to...

999 replies

WilfShelf · 19/08/2010 20:57

Can we just have one thread in anticipation of autumn/winter? No, we don't all want a Boden coat because a. they're not properly waterproof and b. EVERY other bugger in the playground has one already. So, I'm after technically sophisticated properly waterproof coats that GO IN AT THE WAIST that are somewhere in between hiker and fashion victim. Inevitably, this means EXPENSIVE usually I'm afraid. Some suggestions below. If you would like to add yours, especially cheaper ones, feel free:

Northface Stella Grace Good good good

Marmot highlander Marmot do some excellent longer waterproof jackets but unfortunately I cannot find lots of stockists in UK

Barbour are doing some nice coats these days [hit view all to see full range]

And even some of their wax jackets are wearable!

Now look here High Fash-hags Creenstone, a dutch company, do some very INTERESTING coats, apparently waterproof and technical... but difficult to find UK stockists or prices: can anyone track 'em down?

That's enough for now. will post more later. Please add suggestions but only ACTUAL waterproof coats please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
WilfShelf · 24/09/2010 18:15

Oh PLEASE please do it. We can all be shareholders in your business...

OP posts:
gibba8 · 24/09/2010 20:55

I totally agree with Mervynne - as a tall size 14 I find it impossible to find a warm coat and waterproof coat that fits in all the right places. I would also spend £££ on the right coat if only I could find one. Love North face and Merrell coats but just not long enough in the arms for me!
Please let me know if anyone finds one!

Mervynne · 24/09/2010 20:57
Grin

It's weird, isn't it, why this not-very-small market hasn't been tapped properly.

If I could get my hands on a good, totally waterproof, breathable not short, proportionally-sized coat with a warm lining - I would PAY for it. And then when I knew it was good, I would buy another one is a different colour and maybe a different style. I'd go on buying them until I died fgs because let's face it, the weather isn't going to miraculously improve in my lifetime.

(I was hopeful for the Grace but it failed because the sizing was crap. I'd have bought a couple for the autumn/spring changeover season if it had been properly sized. I imagine if you are 5'4" and very slim it is great.)

Same with proper, wool underlayers. I need them in my draughty house. I need them outdoors. I am quite tall and not slim, so a really fine jersey knit top that is properly long is a good thing. I'd buy loads. I did find one last year from Icebreaker but mostly their collection wasn't long enough, and the one I did find is ok but the trims are not well-made enough: they rub and itch. It wasn't cheap and I won't buy from them again because they haven't paid attention to what makes the seams comfortable - a really stupid plan when you consider it has to be worn next to the skin.

Maybe the problem is that they assume that everyone lives in warm houses with double glazing, and only goes outside to get to the car/to the next building. My life is nothing like that and I'm not that unusual!

Anyway I decided this year to go for a wool coat. I don't really want one, I want goretex that looks good and fits. I think if the Wakefield isn't breathable then I won't try it, though it looks good.

And then next year I shall launch my own line and sit back on piles of money Grin

3rdnparty · 25/09/2010 09:49

are Barbors sweaty then? am sick of having waterproofs that rustle Grin whilst you walk and are not reaally breathable hate being sweaty so was thinking this was the answer
www.barbour.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=products.view&ProductID=18865&PCategoryID=23&RangeID=2

not really my usual style bit worried people will ask where my dog/horse as in london suburb...

...I need an all year - so not too padded happy to wear layers/liner for warmth -
Wakefield looks bit long and slim (5'6 but busty 16-18 top 14 hip!)

Please help!

gibba8 · 25/09/2010 17:42

I will buy one of your coats Mervyne!

Actually bought a Merrell Isodore coat today-toasty warm and long but only available in black which I would not of chosen if there has been another colour available but just so desperate for a warm coat that fits!

The search still continues.

DonaAna · 26/09/2010 20:32

Brilliant thread. So enjoyed reading it! I'm Scandinavian, and I voted for this Danefae coat. I love it - it so brightens up the day, and I stood in the pouring rain at the playground for an hour wearing it and stayed dry and comfy. Also available in black and brown, and they ship pretty much everywhere.

pigindisguise · 01/10/2010 15:19

Well I just came back from town, where I tried on a Wakefield and a Haven. Both lovely, arms fine on both and I do not have monkey arms. HOWEVER I said to the shop assistant 'they're both waterproof aren't they' and she said 'er no I don't think so, I think they'd be showerproof but that's about it, you'd need to get something like the north face x? (which was incidentally over £100 more expensive). So I said 'so you wouldn't go out in this weather in either of them then?' (it's a miserable wet windy day) and she said 'if I'm being honest, no'

(without re-reading the whole thread) Has anyone tried either of them out in the wet?

odetothewestwing · 01/10/2010 16:30

How strange. Well, I have worn my Wakefield in monsoon conditions several times (today included) and it is FAB, the most waterproof coat I have ever owned - the water simply sits on top and rolls off. So I would say that it's completely waterproof.

Doyouthinktheysaurus · 01/10/2010 16:44

Yes, Wakefield definitely very waterproof. Stayed dry during school run in monsoon conditions today. I have 4 inches of wet jean between boots and my raincoat. May have to consider thigh length bootsGrin

pigindisguise · 01/10/2010 16:49

great news. how about the Haven anyone? I could do with both really but no way can I afford them, so think I need to go with Haven for warmth as long as it's waterproof

carrielou2007 · 01/10/2010 18:08

Defo waterproof, it sort of rolls off, not very breathable but still the best waterproof coat I have ever had.

I also have it's sister the ava bought both from this thread as it was much cheaper than the haven at 65 super super warm Smile.

That sales assistant needs to read the label on the coat that says waterproof/seamed seals or whatever it is called!!

pigindisguise · 01/10/2010 19:07

what, the haven carrielou?

carrielou2007 · 01/10/2010 20:47

The Haven and Wakefield and Ava are all waterproof, not showerproof, waterproof, I have the Wakefield and Ava, if I could have got the Haven for 65 I would have bought it but Ava is also an insulated/super duper warm coat.

glasjam · 01/10/2010 20:59

OK I have visited this thread several times since its inception but it's been a while. Has anyone established whether the Wakefield is still being manufactured by Merrell? Because when I go on their website I can see hide nor hair of it (can see the Haven). I am in Glasgow and desperately in need of a decent waterproof coat and am a bit stumped as to where I can actually go and try one on. What shops are they being sold in? (and sorry if this has been asked before!)

pigindisguise · 01/10/2010 21:22

Cotswold Outdoor have them

trixymalixy · 01/10/2010 22:19

I'm another tall size 14 who finds it hard to buy coats that are long enough in the body and arms. I tried on several Barbour styles, but they all made me look like I'd squeezed into a too small size because the arms were too short and the waist was up round my ribs despite going up a couple of sizes.

bumpypaws · 02/10/2010 08:45

Can't find them on the Cotswold Outdoor website pigindisguise - did you see them in one of their shops? Am still holding out for Shop on the Beach - they emailed me on September 16th to say the Wakefields would be at least 4 weeks, but they were expecting them in.
BTW, DH thinks I'm crazy to be holding out for a coat I haven't even tried on! It had better be good!

pigindisguise · 02/10/2010 09:17

that's strange, yes, they were in the shop (haven and wakefield), and other people have seen them there too.
I keep expecting to see loads of other mumsnetters wearing them but haven't seen a single person in a wakefield or haven yet!

carrielou2007 · 02/10/2010 18:46

I can' remember which link now but if you start at page one, I think it was on 2 or 3 one of the links the wakefields were back in stock when I looked yesterday (thinking about gettin it in black too Blush) think they were 139, not on the beach shop though and their service was fab.

ItsYourTurn · 02/10/2010 20:06

Not sure if this is any help and please ignore if already mentioned! But Go Outdoors have the Haven for £126 here and Taunton Leisure have the Wakefield for £140 here.

glasjam · 02/10/2010 21:22

Thanks all for tips - have a Cotswold Outdoor nearby - had a fruitless search in Glasgow city centre - tried all the main department stores and Mountain Hardware, North Face and Tiso - ironically I saw the Haven in 2 of those shops but no waterproof Wakefield which is ironic given that Glasgow is more inclined to wet than bitter cold. I don't want to order it off any website until I've tried it on. Fingers crossed it's on sale at Cotswolds.

Does anyone know why there is no sign of it on the Merrell website - have they stopped making it?

cazzafromleics · 02/10/2010 21:48

WilfShelf you are a goddess (sp?) and this thread is genius. I know I've found it late but if anyone's reading, did we find out whether the Northface Stella Grace or the gorgeous Merrell Wakefield are actually WARM? I'm too thick/lazy to make sense of technical bits. It all seems to be to good to be true - have been looking for ages.

cazzafromleics · 02/10/2010 21:55

Oops. Just realised I'd only read page 1 of this thread.Blush

glasjam · 02/10/2010 22:29

I tried the Northface Grace on in white and it was very nice but it's a lot more expensi ve at £229 - they didn't have it in black which is good cos I might have been tempted to max out the plastic. Looked a serious coat.

florenceuk · 02/10/2010 22:38

I have an insulated NF Grace in a kind of Khaki check from last year - it is fairly slim fitting (wear a jersey but not a jacket underneath) and reasonably warm (you do need the jersey, it is not as warm as a down jacket). And it is very waterproof and seems reasonably breathable (has Goretex look-alike, Hyvent). It is much nicer looking than the Landsend Squall it replaced (and more waterproof). the Arctic Parka is I think one for those who feel the cold as it is waterproof and filled with down.