Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

A story about (a lack of) entitlement.

75 replies

Magda72 · 19/06/2022 18:19

There's been a lot of aggro (hand wringing & pearl clutching) on here recently re adult dc/bedrooms/finances etc. so after meeting a good friend for a long awaited catch up I'm going to share this.
This friend is separated from her husband 6 years. She has a 24yro, a 21yro, a 16yro & a 12yro. For as long as I've known her she has lived in a tiny 3 bed (3rd bed is basically a box room), 1 bathroom, tiny kitchen/diner, 1 tiny living room house. Her dh was always unemployed (by wish - wanted to pursue his Art) & my friend was always self employed in an area that pays the bills but very little by way of luxuries. My friend cannot afford to buy a bigger house and where we are her mortgage is less than what renting would be.
Since splitting her h has not given her or the dc a penny - not a penny. He basically fecked off to another part of the country with another woman & sees the dc sporadically.
My friends eldest was doing exams when her dad left but ploughed on and did very well. She then took a year out and worked to save hard for uni. She has since obtained a first class degree all the while working while studying in order to pay her way through college (with the assistance of a small education grant). My friend helped her when she could but money was and is very tight. This girl is now working a full time job & putting herself through an MA programme part time.

The second eldest didn't want to go to uni but went straight out to work after school. 3 years later she's a manager of her division - the company's youngest at 21.
My friends youngest two are different sexes and given their ages can no longer share a room. So in their house my friend & her dp have one room, her dd has another & her ds another. At this the house is full to the brim as the house is truly tiny. My friend literally has no room for her older 2 when they visit.

Does anyone moan? No.
She & her older dc make day trips to see each other & the dc if push comes to shove will sleep on a sofa/floor if an overnight is necessary. They have both moved out all their stuff into their own accommodations which they fully fund themselves. These dc also have no rooms at their dads as he lives in a one bed with his gf miles away and they have little interest in spending time with him.
These dc are 2 of the nicest, most thoughtful, sociable & hardworking people I've ever come across. The took my friend out for her birthday recently & treated her to everything - a spa day followed by dinner. They have been treated appalling by their dad but are not bitter or nasty or needy.
My friends two youngest are also great kids and her 16 year old is now working all summer having completed their exams.
It's grafting like this that makes me see red on here with all the expectation that dc need two homes, two bedrooms & to be housed & financed by both parents well into adulthood.
There's so much bullshit on here as to what good parenting is - the Mumsnet version of it seems to be some middle class crap about proving your love by providing every material comfort going & that if you don't (especially as a separated/divorced parent) you are failing your dc, they will be scarred for life & you should jump through hoops to right this.
I know many teens and young adults and NONE of them (including my own) are as hardworking, independent or grateful as my friend's dc. Her family is proof that love is not money & bedrooms & holidays & mollycoddling into adulthood - it's graft & pulling together & mutual respect & gratitude & a hell or a lot of people on here could learn a thing or two about this from my friend.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
justforthisnow · 19/06/2022 23:30

Magda72 · 19/06/2022 23:05

So some of you are damning my friend for 'letting' her exh bugger off (can't see how she'd have stopped him) & more of you are damning her for now being with a man who DOES honour his financial obligations to his dc.
Right so - misogyny still alive and well on here - everything is my friends fault & she's irreparably damaged her dc despite ALL evidence to the contrary.
This perfectly demonstrates that no matter what a woman does to provide for her family and set an example of strength she's always less than and hasn't done enough.

Nope, your friend has not let anyone bugger off, her ex chose that, but she has made it easy for him to financially escape his obligations to his own kids.
Then chose a man who does pay his "financial obligations" but doesnt make her life easier.
No winners here except the men.

StaplesCorner · 19/06/2022 23:45

So OP, are you saying that young people who have to live at home, or choose to do so, have a sense of entitlement? That they are really special if they manage to get a good degree or career - that those who don't are just ... well ... "entitled"? And you seem quite smug that you've thought of posting about that? Just checking ... Hmm

Totheweekend · 20/06/2022 07:14

Why did your friend keep having children, in effect giving them an proven-to-be-useless dad?
Everyone’s circumstances are different and she clearly did the best with what she had.
I’m more than happy that my DSD feels entitled to a room at our home (she’s here 50% now) when she is a young adult. I don’t want her feeling boxed into the first work/career decision she makes just because she feels pressure to pay for a roof over her head. I think most parents would want that for their child(ren) if they could manage it and don’t see it as a luxury-extra-optional-post-18-parenting add-on.

Hoppinggreen · 20/06/2022 07:20

Well I am going to quit my job, throw DH out, never get a penny from him and move to a much smaller house straight away so that my kids turn out as well as your friends.
How can they possibly end up decent human beings with a room each?
It’s a nice story though

ShirleyJackson · 20/06/2022 07:21

Is this paragon really your friend? Or is she ‘your friend’ meaning ‘you’?

You seem to know an awful lot about ‘her’ and are very defensive of ‘her’ too…

soundofsilver · 20/06/2022 07:22

Magda72 · 19/06/2022 23:05

So some of you are damning my friend for 'letting' her exh bugger off (can't see how she'd have stopped him) & more of you are damning her for now being with a man who DOES honour his financial obligations to his dc.
Right so - misogyny still alive and well on here - everything is my friends fault & she's irreparably damaged her dc despite ALL evidence to the contrary.
This perfectly demonstrates that no matter what a woman does to provide for her family and set an example of strength she's always less than and hasn't done enough.

Errrr, no. You missed my point. You were basically saying her kids aren't entitled because she's done such a great job (which I agree with). My point is her ex IS entitled and has some sweet FA raising his kids.

soundofsilver · 20/06/2022 07:22

*done

soundofsilver · 20/06/2022 07:24

....so it isn't a story about a 'lack of entitlement'. It's a story about male entitlement.

KnitOnePearlOneDropOne · 20/06/2022 07:24

So the partners DC never come to stay then?

Youseethethingis1 · 20/06/2022 07:28

Not enough eye rolls for these responses. Some people are absolutely determined to take what you have said precisely the wrong way @Magda72 much like most of the rest of this shambles of a board.
What I took from the story was
A) friends ex is useless with little or no morals or redeeming features
B) friend, like many women before her, left to without a leg to stand on WRT getting money out of him
C) friend instead focused energy on bringing up her children, giving them stability, building their characters
D) older kids now making a success of their young adult lives and sufficiently secure in their family and themselves to not begrudge their mother looking after their younger siblings
E) the old saying about how you can't control other people, you can only control yourself is absolutely true
F) none of this excuses fuckwit father
No idea what these other people have been reading.

howtomoveforwards · 20/06/2022 07:36

Of of course children don’t need 2 bedrooms, or 2 of anything at all. But what they do need - and you seem to forget this - is a sense of being cared for, of being a priority, of being important in both their parents lives. There is absolutely no doubt that a teenager making way with bedrooms for a younger sibling can understand the logic of why that might need to happen but I am not sure that in all cases, it sits easy with them or doesn’t sting a bit. Same as you can be excited to meet your new sibling in one household but cry in the other because it’s unsettling and you worry about your position in the family.

And also completely miss the point that parenting isn’t about what you can provide materially but how you can prepare your child mentally to be independent of you and happy and confident in life

that’s really easy to say, isn’t it, if it’s not you with a decade of lone parenting ahead of you, no idea how you’re going to afford to put the oven on, put petrol in the car, buy some much needed new school shoes or anything else that is reasonably required to just get by. It’s pretty shit being the kid who didn’t get a holiday, who always has second hand clothes or doesn’t have an iPad. In my experience, what prepares children for adulthood above everything else, is hardship. And a determination to avoid it for themselves. It’s a pretty shit life lesson, drummed in from childhood. I am not sure we should aspire to it.

motogirl · 20/06/2022 07:41

Adult dc with jobs who do not live at home do not need bedrooms but those at university do, many issues are regarding that. We have 4 DD's between us, 2 live with us, one bunks in with her sister or sleeps in my study when she visits the other sleeps with her sister. We haven't got elastic walls! But if my other dd needed to live with us we would have to move

Holly60 · 20/06/2022 08:55

Magda72 · 19/06/2022 22:58

Just because these young people have had the tenacity to survive without it, doesn't mean it isn't a good thing to preserve your children's safe space even when they have moved out or reached adulthood.
And what if you can't? Like you financially actually can't? @Holly60 you are demonstrating exactly what I'm talking about. My elder siblings also had to effectively move out when they went to college/work as we lived in a 3 bed and there was 6 of us dc. My parents were wonderful people who educated us all & strove to give us a great start in our adults lives but they couldn't give us what they didn't have!
My friends kids DO have a parental safety net - a safety net of love & care - they don't necessarily need to maintain 'their' bedrooms into adulthood to feel loved & cherished.
I know this family well and they are extremely close & have a great relationship with their mum.

I'm not disputing any of this. In fact I think we are agreeing. You are suggesting that these kids have thrived DESPITE not having a space in the parental home. I agree it very much sounds like they have. But I stand by my belief that it would still be better for them if they DID have a space. A lovely bedroom to come back to whenever they want it. It doesn't make a young adult automatically entitled if their parents are able to provide this for them.

Magda72 · 20/06/2022 08:59

*Is this paragon really your friend? Or is she ‘your friend’ meaning ‘you’?

You seem to know an awful lot about ‘her’ and are very defensive of ‘her’ too…*
Oh sweet Jesus - no I am not her! I'd say anyone who has read my many poses would know that (eyeroll) & I'm defensive of her because she's my friend & because the majority of you have wilfully misconstrued the point I was making.

OP posts:
Magda72 · 20/06/2022 09:05

@Youseethethingis1 - thank you - you've gotten my point exactly!
You're right - this board is a total shambles. Any post that isn't full of self flagellating & sacrifice seems to trigger a LOT of people who then deliberately choose to miss the actual point of the post.

OP posts:
sandgrown · 20/06/2022 09:07

Hats off to your friend. I was in a similar situation and my children have also turned out very well . They know if they needed to come home there would always be a bed for them and we remain incredibly close. Our house needed lots of work and I was embarrassed if they invited friends over but recently one of their friends said how much she loved coming to our home as it had such a relaxed feeling. It made my day .

Magda72 · 20/06/2022 09:12

....so it isn't a story about a 'lack of entitlement'. It's a story about male entitlement.
@soundofsilver you are arguing into a vacuum! Of course there's male entitlement in this situation! There's male entitlement in virtually EVERY domestic situation whether the family is intact, blended or headed by a lone parent! But once again & louder for the people at the back that is NOT what this post is about!

OP posts:
Magda72 · 20/06/2022 09:13

@sandgrown - lovely post & hats off to you & your dc because it is not easy.

OP posts:
heavyistheheed · 20/06/2022 09:16

Your friend has done well with the hand she was dealt and her children sound fantastic but really if I was your friends parent I would be upset with my daughters life choices, mainly due to the fact she continued having children with such a loser who has never worked a day in his life.

Thereisnolight · 20/06/2022 09:20

The DC sound great! Good for them!

It strikes me that they know they are loved and that makes up for what I’m sure is a more difficult life than you paint.

This I think is very different from a family where the new boyfriend/girlfriend moves in with their DC and the older DC get kicked out to make way. “They’re old enough now, they don’t need a room”. They mightn’t need the actual room (though probably they actually do) but the worst part is having a parent who makes the home unliveable due to them putting themselves and their sex life before their child. See it here all the time!

MsTSwift · 20/06/2022 09:22

Isn’t that just human nature though? If you are forced to succeed because there is no safety net sink or swim that’s a strong driver. Remember reading a study that an inordinate proportion of those who were extremely successful had lost a parent before they were 10.

soundofsilver · 20/06/2022 09:34

Magda72 · 20/06/2022 09:12

....so it isn't a story about a 'lack of entitlement'. It's a story about male entitlement.
@soundofsilver you are arguing into a vacuum! Of course there's male entitlement in this situation! There's male entitlement in virtually EVERY domestic situation whether the family is intact, blended or headed by a lone parent! But once again & louder for the people at the back that is NOT what this post is about!

Wow. Ok then. Jeez.

pitchforksandflamethrowers · 20/06/2022 12:48

Honestly the comments on here explains a lot of the entitled adults on this board with side order of misogyny.

Christ people really want to get the wrong end of the stick don't they.

All children deserve care, love ect but your story shows that if you spoon feed any child any child into adulthood your setting them up to fail and the reverse is true. This isn't good for children but people seem absolutely dammed for sure that SC need people to consistently apologise for the parents break up up until adulthood and beyond.

sandgrown · 20/06/2022 14:28

@Magda72 thank you x

MsTSwift · 20/06/2022 14:46

I do think it’s a fair comment that running around after kids and pandering to them often results in spoilt entitled young people. I sometimes cringe at how much my friends skivvy about for their teens.

Though seems abit extreme to suggest adopting a poverty stricken lifestyle to avoid that! Some people do just have really nice kids.