Please or to access all these features

SN children

Here are some suggested organisations that offer expert advice on special needs.

Spastic

125 replies

lou33 · 02/10/2004 16:47

Ok, now it's really really getting to me atm, the amount of times I am hearing this word used as a form of humour, to take the piss out of other people etc. Some of you might remember my tirade against Richard Curtis (thank you everyone who joined in with that) for using it in Love Actually. And recently I wrote to the editor at the Daily Telegraph about an article regarding the paralypmics, and one journalist's viewpoint that it wasn't worth the airspace (no reply from them, but lots of letters printed agreeing with the journo in question, interestingly enough)

Now I've rattled off another email to channel 4 and ofcom, about the tv programme "Make me a perfect wife". Did anyone notice one of the husbands calling his wife a spastic? Icing on the cake, as dh was sitting next to a bunch of people in a pub at the weekend listening to them calling each other spastics, and doing their version of impersonations.

I am so sick and tired of people thinking it is ok to insult and make fun of disabled people. Bet Channel 4 wouldn't dream of lettting racist or religious abuse through , so why are disabled people fair game? I could possibly understand it, if the programme was about the ignorant attitudes of certain parts of society today, but it wasn't at all relevent to the programme itself.

Anyway, if anyone had read this far, and wants to see what I wrote, here it is:

"I am writing regarding the first programme of the above series and to register a complaint.

Can you please tell me why Channel 4, while filming the lives of these people, running it through editing, and checking for final viewing, allowed, or thought it acceptable to include a speech from one of the husbands, in which he calls his wife a spastic? Is it amusing, clever? Were you trying to make him look a fool? Whatever your reasons I am greatly offended.

As a mother of a 3 1/2 year old son, who has cerebral palsy , spastic diplegia, I find it incomprehensible, that in this day and age, there are still people and tv companies, who are willing to use this sort of language as a form of humour. My son struggles every day to do the most basic things. He has only recently learned to sit without lots of support, he cannot stand at all, or walk,he is in a wheelchair, he can only crawl when not using it. He is highly intelligent, and talks all the time about how when he is bigger he is going to walk like his daddy, and play football. He struggles to do things even the very youngest toddlers can do without thinking, yet he is a charming, bright, humourous little soul, who bears no malice to anyone. Would someone from the channel 4 team like to pay a visit to my house, and spend some time with myself and my son, then maybe I could have an explanation as to why including the word spastic in the show was seen as a legitimate source of entertainment?

You may say it is relevent to show what sort of character this man has, but no, it isn't. It has nothing at all to do with the subject of the series, and would have made no difference at all to the way the programme ran, if you had just edited it out.

I am sick and tired of hearing this phrase bandied about, as though people with this type of cerebral palsy, and their families, are unimportant. You wouldn't dare let a racist comment slip through, or a religious attack, for fear of complaints, so how dare you feel it acceptable to make fun of disabled people. My son didn't choose to have cerebral palsy, he should be entitled to have an equal life to those of the non disabled, and that includes not having such ignorant and offensive comments used in everyday life, because of something which is not a lifestyle choice.

I will be contacting Ofcom as well."

Maybe it is our fault for not pulling people up on it when we have the chance. Maybe we should all try and point out that this is unacceptable when we hear these kind of offensive comments. Dh says to his utter shame he said nothing, because there were many in the group, all drunk, and he was quite frankly worried as to how they would react.

Thanks for reading my rant if you have got this far.

Heartily pissed off lou33

OP posts:
sis · 03/10/2004 20:46

I too hope you get sensible replies and your letter will raise awareness of the abuse of medical terminology. It is so sad that people still use words like spastic as an insult in this day.

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:07

UPDATE: Got a reply from Channel 4 just this minute! Am pretty happy with it actually

Should I reply and tell them so? Here it is.

Thank you for your recent e-mail to us, regarding the series Make Me a Perfect Wife. We absolutely take on board your criticisms alerting us to this unfortunate matter and we apologise for the offence it caused you. Our legal and production teams work incredibly hard to adhere to our values as a responsible broadcaster and keep us within the boundaries of what is decent and respectful. I regret that in this instance we let an unacceptable word slip through the net.

The film you mentioned was an observational documentary, as opposed to an entertainment show, and the scene showed an inebriated couple who were discussing their inability to succeed with the social experiment. As you mentioned, there are some cases where we hold a mirror up to a world that does not reflect the beliefs of C4, but shows the world the way it actually is. I do agree that, in this instance, much more care should have been taken to ensure the word was removed. We certainly had combed through the films initially and I believe a request had been made to bleep this in the cutting room. Unfortunately, due to human error, this did not happen and because of the chaotic 'nature' of the scene it was missed. We deeply regret this.

C4 will continue to make programmes that challenge the stereotypes, you have quite rightly raised and I hope you feel that in the main we have a track record in achieving this. Nevertheless, your sentiments on this occasion have been taken on board by us and I sincerely want to apologise to you and your family for any distress caused. We will do our utmost to be more vigilant in the future. I have also forwarded your letter to the production company, Diverse who also want us to convey their apologies.

Thank you for writing.

Yours sincerely,

Deputy Commissioning Editor
Documentaries

Pretty much admitting they made a mistake!

AIR PUNCH!!!!

OP posts:
welshmum · 15/10/2004 15:11

That's brilliant - it's upheld my belief in C4.
Well done you lou for putting them right

chatee · 15/10/2004 15:13

well done lou

spacemonkey · 15/10/2004 15:17

WELL DONE WELL DONE LOU

hester · 15/10/2004 15:18

Well done Lou, that's brilliant. I would definitely let them know you appreciate their response - I'm sure reward works just as well as challenge in these cases, so great that you get to do both.

Twinkie · 15/10/2004 15:18

WIsh I had courage to do what you have Lou - heard someone talk about a little boy with behavioural probelms being on the ming mong list at school but seemed inappropriate to throw a turn about it as was at a party and would have caused upset - keep thinking about it - wish I had now!!

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:21

I really expected some sort of computer generated fob off you know!

OP posts:
moomina · 15/10/2004 15:22

Wow, nice one lou! I must admit when I first read this thread I didn't think you'd get such a good response - thought I would just be 'Thanks for your letter, comments noted, blahblahblah, we're off down the Groucho.' Good for you, mate - it is worth putting this stuff down on paper.

moomina · 15/10/2004 15:23

(or email, of course!)

gothicmama · 15/10/2004 15:24

well done lou

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:24

Ooh twinkie I think I would have had to be physically restrained if I heard that

I am not a nice sight to behold when angry.

OP posts:
Twinkie · 15/10/2004 15:24

Was a mumsnetter!!!

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:26

Maybe I should reply saying

Thank you for your letter and I very much appreciate the apologies regarding my complaint. however , now you have admitted it was through human error that the word went uncut, can we please have the head of the person responsible for leaving it in on a plate please?

Regards....

Bit too much you think?

OP posts:
lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:26

It was a netter?!!!!

OP posts:
Twinkie · 15/10/2004 15:28

I have never seen her posts but I was introduced to her by her MN name!!

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:30

Really I am! There have been lots of netters who have peeped into the sn section, and have said that the board has enlightened them a lot since joining. How hurtful and v sad

OP posts:
kalex · 15/10/2004 15:30

Well done LOU

Twinkie - I am totally shocked

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:31

Despite knowing that I feel a definite spring in my step after getting the email

OP posts:
Eulalia · 15/10/2004 15:34

Totally agree. It was unnecesary unless it was just to show how ignorant and stupid this man was but as I didn't see the programme I can't really say. I guess who was edidting it just didn't think twice which just goes to show how awful it is that someone can say something like that unchecked. Hope you feel better for the letter and it gets some results.

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:36

Eulalia, he didn't need to say spastic to show what an arse he was, it was v obvious already

OP posts:
Eulalia · 15/10/2004 15:37

Oh - just read the reply. Great

Eulalia · 15/10/2004 15:39

OK Lou - I tend to avoid programmes like that anyway.

SoupDragon · 15/10/2004 15:39

What a great response from C4, Lou. Well done for complaining!

And Twinkie, that was terrible!

lou33 · 15/10/2004 15:42

So do I eulalia . It was on when I walked into the room, and after about 2 mins he said his comment, then I saw red mist descending and switched it over.

OP posts: