Hello, I've been quiet a long time, mainly as we are not making much progress and I didn't want to cast doubts and general gloom, but reading through the recent threads, I thought I'd comment.
We have been doing TH since Easter. We achieve the exercises pretty much every day, except that sometimes DD is out all evening and then we only manage 2 lots a stairs in a day. We have completed EE, and teeth, and been doing stairs and Hemi P and T for a few months. We have seen very little differences, and the differences we have seen, I think could well be done to just general progression with age. DD is a bit more alert (I think this is probably suppliment based as this started within a few weeks). We abandonded diet over summer, with lots of icecreams etc, and saw no differences. We are back on it now, but less rigorously.
We've seen Robin four times now and he is always v positive, and says there are lots of improvements. Prior to TH we did lots of extra reading, spellings, and toe by toe. I did nothing on top of what teh school asked (except TH) since Easter, then re-started this year with picking up spellings, tables again etc. There is really no difference in her reading (despite completing EE and Robin saying she was lots better), and my attempts to teach spellings are still hopeless. Nothing is retained, letters all back to front etc etc. when I track back over her SATS levels, the only thing to make a jump has been toe by toe which we did over a summer holiday.
One thing I have noticed is an improvement in her agility, nothing huge, but still an improvement. Whether all this work is worht it though, I'm not sure. Don't get me wrong, DD has made some progression, her sats are keeping going up slowly, but she is still bottom of teh class, and struggling hard, despite lots of effort on her and our part. Robin was confident when we first met her that her difficulties were minimal and easily sorted.
I have e mailed Robin with all the above. I got a one line reply "children all go at their own rate, don't worry". Maybe he is right, we will give it til Xmas, and I truely hope I am eating my words in a few months, but as people are asking about it, I thought I would share now. I have also been wondering about where the people are who this doesn't work for are....if it was such an all encompassing miralce cure, wouldn't someone have researched it by now? Getting a PhD student to do a bit of reseach for you, to get you started/known, is not expensive.
Re Facebook - I have been in another support gp, which set up a FB group to run along side the group. I'm not on FB and don't want to be - privacy, no time etc - and the group died as most people moved to FB and therefore the "chat" died away on the support network. Most people couldn't keep up with both ends, and write everything twice, so they chose one or the other. Also, I think if you run a private gp, it's harder for new people to join? (As I'm not on FB, please correct if this is wrong) You can't read old threads, and "listen" in until you're ready to join?
Sorry to be all doom and gloom........would be lovely if things were otherwise