It's a pleasure 9-5.
I'm nbot quite with you on how you presented your PT tasks but presentation of SAFMEDS is important yes.
I have stolen a model/lead/test intro from Direct Instruction (another fantastic methos of learning that yields stunning results) which works well with SAFMEDS. Read my handouts and it explains it all.
Good question Indogo re child knowing whether letter/word acceptable or not. In this field we work on one thing at a time so I would (with a real beginner) look at maybe
- letter touching bottom line
- letter touching top line
and so on and so on.
With some kids, it's literally starting with marking a paper.
Now, they need immeditate feedback on acceptability of effort in a way which doesn't interrupt the flow of thier writing (as 99.9% of praise/info/criticism does) so what we do is combing TAGteach and PT.
With SAFMEDS, the kid gets feedback about 'learning opportunities' because the 'wrong' SAFMED goes into a differnwt pile to the 'corrects'. That structure is not possible with, say, letter formation, so I TAG acceptable eforts and don;t TAG those that aren't. The silence says it all!
TAGteach
You can TAG with a regular counter (like tey use on trains) and if you work in a given period of time, when it is over, the counter will give you the number of 'corrects' which you subtract from the whole.
Indogo, you have linked to stuff written by the KING of Precision Teaching/Direct Instruction namely the fabulous Michal Maloney (with whom I had my picture taken at last year's ABA conference in Texas. It has pride of place in my office. He is amazing. He produces lots of fabulous books (mostly for pisssed off American home schoolers who have lost faith in the system) under the title 'Teach your children well'
He has a website of that name. It's a bit amateurish but ignore that. This guy is the business.