Zombie, does he sleep well in the pram for naps? Dc3 has his naps in the pram now. He always fell asleep on the school run, but wouldn't nap in the cot, so I pop his lullaby cd on in the kitchen (it used to be the washing machine
), put him in the pram and push him back and forth. He's usually off within 5-10 mins. I'm Just wondering if something like this might be worth a go? I know its not the main issue, but if you can get him having a couple of decent naps so he's rested, it might help bedtime.
And work with the nap 2 hrs after first waking pattern, then next nap 3 hrs after last waking, then bedtime 4 hrs later. (These are approximate, it still depends on sleepy signs and how long naps were etc).
I hope you don't mind me saying, but you sound a bit confused with it all? Also like you need a break. Consistency really is key, and if the gentler methods are more in tune with you, then maybe just accept it will take time, but in a few months it will be much better.
I'm loathe to suggest you read a whole book, whilst so sleep deprived, but something like no cry sleep solution might suit you better? Or have you read bits of the mammoth sleep thread on here 'what worked for us' or something similar? People have posted their tales of success.
Give yourself a break and a pat on the back, this is really hard. If your instinct is to cuddle ds and that's what he's used to, sleep training will be tough using a method that's not natural to you.
I will try post a link to the other thread later (bedtime for my 3 now and DH away) xx