Blackout blind 100% failure as quietly anticipated. DS up at 4:10 yesterday morning, then 4:20 this morning.
Now DH and I are having a disagreement about this. My response is to go in when he wakes up and, on a weekday morning, feed him for the hour he seems to require then I can usually get him back in his cot for another 1.5 hours which allows me to get ready for work or, on a weekend, take him into the spare room, feed for an hour, and we both get another two hours by co-sleeping. Nice, manageable, fine by me and DS gets all the night-time sleep he needs within the appropriate hours.
DH thinks he needs to learn to sleep later, so when he goes in at 4:10, he'll keep lying him back down. If DS goes back to sleep, it'll last 5, maybe 10 minutes, then he'll bob up and start wailing again. By this time, it'll be 4:40ish and DH will ask me to feed him, saying that 'I've at least given him the chance to put himself back to sleep.'
Isn't this just telling DS that if he holds out long enough he'll get what he wants or does DH have a point??
My position is that sleep training is only for the benefit of the parents. Once it reaches a manageable stage, which it is for me at the moment using my method, it's fine as long as DS's sleep isn't being affected. Using DH's method, he gets completely wired from screaming, only sleeps fitfully if I can get him back to sleep at all, then he'll pass out for an hour and a half around 7 or 8am on DH's lap which then ballses up his nap time.
DH thinks I'm a complete hippy for saying that DS will learn to sleep later in his own time and that sleep training is for DS's benefit, not ours, because he 'needs to be taught how to sleep' and starts pulling out the old 'rod for your own back' clap trap.
Have I been on MN too long and does DH have a point or is my path of least resistance the way to go? Or is there a middle ground?
(Sorry for lengthy rant but it was DH's method this morning so I've been up since 4:20 listening to my baby screaming then dealing with the sleepless fallout. Unlike DH who went back to sleep until half seven once I calmed DS down in the spare room
)