Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Vanishing posts on the Jess Phillips thread

1 reply

Mner2000 · 21/01/2020 11:00

Numerous posters (here) have noted that their posts were removed from the Jess Phillips thread before and after the event (here) and there being nothing noted on the thread itself that there is no accompanying deletion message on the thread itself.

The Daily Mail clearly has a screen grab of StealthPolarBear on 20/01/2020 13:31.17 that is no longer on the thread - without an accompanying thread deletion message like is normally there.

Is mumsnet against free speech and rigorous debate? Politicians must robustly account for their actions where their policies affect so many. If they cannot do this on a Mumsnet forum, how will they manage in parliament?

Self ID is not single issue - it affects every area of national and regional policy. Maybe if Jess had been able to see a better range of comments, it would help her understand this better and if she had seen the number of comments, it would help her see just how many people are concerned about the real impacts of policy change on such a large level. She says herself that some of the issues raised on the thread were not ones she had come across on the doors but yet we are not allowed to ask them here. This would have been the ideal opportunity to raise awareness of the many, many issues involved.

There must be a better way to arrange these webchats than just deleting people's comments and concerns without trace. What about grouping the questions by topic.

RowanMumsnet · 23/01/2020 16:13

Hello

Sorry it's taken us a while to respond.

We've been holding webchats on MN for over ten years now and they've become a really valuable way of allowing MNers to interact directly with powerful people and voice their concerns. But along with that we think we have a couple of responsibilities: to all Mumsnet users, giving an equal opportunity for every MNer to post about the issue that really matters to her (it is usually a 'her') even if she's the only one facing it; and to the politicians, who are our guests and who aren't obligated to give us their time and face what several political journalists have cited as being some of the fiercest questioning a politician can face in public.

We thought long and hard about deleting those posts and particularly about using the button that disappears them without trace but the truth is that all the polite requests, evident deletions and emails to users that we had tried previously had just not worked, and the situation was beginning to feel implacably hostile.

For us it came down to two factors: that we knew other MNers were being put off from posting on webchats entirely, and that we were finding politicians more and more reluctant to engage. The evidence that our current approach has in our own terms been successful lies in the really broad range of strong, thoughtful questions on the thread (as some users in FWR have acknowledged) and in the increased willingness of some other politicians to line up webchats.

We take the point that there are lots of sub-headings to this issue and setting a false and slightly arbitrary limit on posts about this feels fairly suboptimal from our point of view but it's the best mechanism we've come up with so far to allow the issue to be addressed and answered by guests without other users being put off from taking part and guests feeling they're on a complete hiding to nothing.

Watch this thread for updates

Tap "Watch" to get all the latest updates

End of posts

There are no more MNHQ posts on this thread