Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Site stuff

Join our Innovation Panel to try new features early and help make Mumsnet better.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Vanishing posts on the Jess Phillips thread

57 replies

Mner2000 · 21/01/2020 11:00

Numerous posters (here) have noted that their posts were removed from the Jess Phillips thread before and after the event (here) and there being nothing noted on the thread itself that there is no accompanying deletion message on the thread itself.

The Daily Mail clearly has a screen grab of StealthPolarBear on 20/01/2020 13:31.17 that is no longer on the thread - without an accompanying thread deletion message like is normally there.

Is mumsnet against free speech and rigorous debate? Politicians must robustly account for their actions where their policies affect so many. If they cannot do this on a Mumsnet forum, how will they manage in parliament?

Self ID is not single issue - it affects every area of national and regional policy. Maybe if Jess had been able to see a better range of comments, it would help her understand this better and if she had seen the number of comments, it would help her see just how many people are concerned about the real impacts of policy change on such a large level. She says herself that some of the issues raised on the thread were not ones she had come across on the doors but yet we are not allowed to ask them here. This would have been the ideal opportunity to raise awareness of the many, many issues involved.

There must be a better way to arrange these webchats than just deleting people's comments and concerns without trace. What about grouping the questions by topic.

OP posts:
DioneTheDiabolist · 24/01/2020 22:36

You are not a lone voice Peachgreen. Plenty of other Mnetters are put off as well. As are guests. This is not the first time this issue has come up. I'm glad MNHQ did something this time.

LangClegsInSpace · 24/01/2020 23:48

I don't understand why some posters are put off participating in webchats just because there are lots of questions on a particular topic.

What stops you from posting your own questions to make the webchat more balanced? It's not as if your views will even be challenged on a webchat thread. You don't even need to read the other questions, you can just read the OP and then post your question.

peachgreen · 25/01/2020 01:18

Because I have to wade through a sea of transphobic bullshit to find the answer to my question and it's exhausting, even if I try not to read it in detail. If I open a thread - any thread - and see that it's the same old echo chamber I'm just not interested in being part of it.

Yes, yes, I know, there's no transphobia here, report it if you see it, blah blah.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/01/2020 10:26

Yes, yes, I know, there's no transphobia here, report it if you see it, blah blah.

Well, yes.

You don't need to 'wade through' anything to find the answers, though. If you click on 'Webchat AT A GLANCE' you get a list of just the questions the guest has responded to, together with their answers.

Vanishing posts on the Jess Phillips thread
Jux · 25/01/2020 14:27

peachgreen: Because I have to wade through a sea of transphobic bullshit to find the answer to my question and it's exhausting, even if I try not to read it in detail. If I open a thread - any thread - and see that it's the same old echo chamber I'm just not interested in being part of it./2

You can just open the thread, search for your name and you will go straight to the posting box. When the webchat's done, you can do exactly that again and it will take you straight to your answer (if your question's been picked up and answered).

It is good to have all sides of a question/issue discussed/asked, so please do.

WelshMoth · 25/01/2020 14:35

Because I have to wade through a sea of transphobic bullshit to find the answer to my question and it's exhausting, even if I try not to read it in detail. If I open a thread - any thread - and see that it's the same old echo chamber I'm just not interested in being part of it.

It's quite clear that you've not done much wading peachgreen if transphobia is your conclusion. This isn't a single issue, it DOES have huge safeguarding concerns that need addressing and we would like an acknowledgment of this.

Every single poster here would encourage you to report transphobia. Questioning this narrative isn't bigotry, shining a light on it's implications for women and children AND trans people isn't transphobia. If you'd "waded" through the thread (and indeed the FWR board), you'd see that for yourself.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 25/01/2020 15:23

Because I have to wade through a sea of transphobic bullshit to find the answer to my question and it's exhausting

Oh dear. So sorry you have to deal with other people's "exhausting" opinions about protecting women's rights.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page