Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

Is this a poor combination of A levels

108 replies

Comefromaway · 06/11/2020 13:20

English Lit
Drama
Film Studies

Child thinks she would like to be a drama teacher in the future. Doesn't like maths & science. Is very hard working but has no confidence in her abilities. GCSE predictions 4/5 in sciences 6/7 in maths & language 7/8 in English & essay subjects. Doing history GCSE but doesn't enjoy it. Gets very anxious about not being good enough.

OP posts:
PresentingPercy · 11/11/2020 23:54

It’s not a given pupils get lower grades in MFL. If they are good at MFL they won’t. They should do MFL in preference to Film Studies if they are good at languages. No one should be discouraged from doing MFL if they are likely to be able to do a MFL at uni. But not everyone is good at MFL any more then they are good at maths.

MrsMiaWallis · 12/11/2020 04:46

@PresentingPercy

It’s not a given pupils get lower grades in MFL. If they are good at MFL they won’t. They should do MFL in preference to Film Studies if they are good at languages. No one should be discouraged from doing MFL if they are likely to be able to do a MFL at uni. But not everyone is good at MFL any more then they are good at maths.
I have nothing against MFL - did French A level myself and enjoyed it. The grade boundaries are very high due to the number of native speakers taking MFL, but I believe they are looking at ways to refine it somehow.
PresentingPercy · 13/11/2020 12:59

I agree the native speaker issue a problem. At degree level too. They simply have to do less work to get a high classification of degree. It’s obviously unfair. DC, as has been said on MFL posts, can go abroad and simply refine their writing skills. Others have to refine speaking, listening and writing skills which is obviously a greater task. Often with no parental help either.

IdblowJonSnow · 13/11/2020 13:03

What's up with film studies? Sounds good to me. I did media studies and loved it, so interesting!
If her confidence is low then might just be best to support her choices?
To some extent a level subjects are irrelevant once you've got a degree. Just check what unis want and what grades they'll want.

JBX2013 · 13/11/2020 14:36

Hi Comefromaway!

I work with schools. The advice from Teachers is:

Eventually, your daughter will be expected to teach English Language/ English Lit (combined at GCSE), English Lit A Level and Drama up to A Level. Depends on the school's staffing and timetabling needs. For pupils, English Language is compulsory up to GCSE, so the demand is there, as is pressure of exam results; but there are also a lot of English graduates about. Drama is optional at GCSE, is more 'fun' and is an extra curricular, but threatened or extinct at too many state schools. Film Studies is less common at the more academic schools. Some professional realties to reflect upon!

Do check with University faculty web pages. Also post-grad Education faculties.

That said, above all, I would support her choice to boost her self confidence.

schmedz · 13/11/2020 18:43

My DD started ALevels with Biology, Psychology and Drama (having achieved '9' grades in both Biology and Drama at GCSE). She soon realised she wasn't keen to pursue Biology so changed to English Lit. Psychology also didn't suit her after a while so she changed to Art (which was her 'worst' GCSE grade at '7' but one of her favourite subjects).

She's at a highly selective Grammar and they weren't as snobby about her final subject choices as some of the Mumsnetters on this thread! As others have said, if the child is motivated and enjoys the subjects, they have the best chance of doing well.

Piggywaspushed · 01/12/2020 10:08

Probably late to the party on this OP but as someone kindly pointed out right at the beginning , this is my subject.

If you still want info , do let me know.

I am not interested in a bunfight over the quality and reputation of Film...people who think it is somehow easy have never seen the spec or an exam. When it was reformed an independent analyst informed Ofqual that the new A Level was 'a film degree and MA in two years'. They responded and took out some content! But it is very wide ranging, opens your mind, is great for historical nd cultural awareness (that cultural capital thing, now so prized) and actually keeps foreign languages going to an extent. I adore the subject. It is (whispers) more rigorous than media, especially if the school chooses the screenplay writing option. It is assessed entirely through writing. I teach English Lit too, which obviously is highly regarded. It has a high drop out rate and is actually narrower in scope and focus (not necessarily demand) than film. that said, they are a great complement.

I would say, I have five students this year who have offers (actual offers and interviews) coming in as we speak for Warwick, Manchester, Oxford and Birmingham for film, English, history of art , creative writing and history. From last year's group, one is now at Warwick studying film,and another at Birmingham studying history. The previous year we sent students to Loughborough (on a scholarship) and Manchester. So none has struggled to gain places at highly regarded institutions.

The options are a bit narrow : but that is rarely said to someone who does physics , maths and another science.

We have a drama teacher who did film A Level and now teaches English and drama. he keeps begging me to teach film because he preferred it!

Piggywaspushed · 01/12/2020 10:10

Meant to add, I can think of several selective schools which offer film, along with many high flying sixth form colleges. A lot of schools are now switching to film from media.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page