Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

*UPDATE* on the DP 'finding himself' trip to India. We had 'the talk', did not go well...

476 replies

stellamel · 03/08/2009 11:09

Original thread www.mumsnet.com/Talk?topicid=relationships&threadid=799173-DP-is-going-on-39-finding-himself-39-trip -to

....went worse than imagined

It started off all nice and calm, well on my part anyway. I asked if I could chat about a few worries I had regarding the trip, which he grudgingly agreed too, he didn't see what needed to be discussed, as I'd already agreed to the trip. Anyway I pushed on regardless. I asked him straight out what his reason was for going, was it this make or break deal, this finding himself trip, but he said that was what I wanted it to be, it wasn't anything like that for him, he said he was doing the trip because 'he fancied it' , it was something he'd always wanted to do. When I pointed out that I didn't think he could justify an extended trip, to a danger zone, at a large expense just because he fancied it, he just replied 'why not?'.

Anyway it all went down hill really from there really, to condense a very long and exhausting evening into a readable post, he basically said it wasn't to be a one off, he intends to do more of these extended trips to exciting locations. He also refused my compromise of a couple of weeks a year to himself to go off climbing or running etc somewhere (a damn fair compromise I thought). He also refused to turn next year's India trip into a family affair, I tried to suggest we go as a family treking somewhere (we are big hiker types) instead of him doing India. He said no, if we could come on bikes, or possibly canoe down the Andes (what with a 6mth old and a 4 yr old!) then maybe, otherwise there was no point. When I pointed out that I didn't know anyone who thought this was a good idea amongst my friends and both our families (men as well as women), he said he couldn't care less and that everyone of his mates at work thought it was a brilliant plan, and they wished they could do it. He then said the most negative thing ever 'All men are held back by their families'!

He basically accused me of being selfish, of not understanding because I have no desire to travel, which I said was extremely unfair, I do and would, but I have to put my children first, and I am not even a earth mother type - I just know that my kids have to come first and foremost now, and that doesn't mean I have to sacrifice myself in the process, just that I have to work around the fact that I am a mother with responsibilities. I conceded that family life can be mundane and tedious, and I too feel the need to escape at times, but that can be done without fecking off for weeks and weeks to the other side of the world at great expense.

He is blatantly unaware that his going away heaps massive pressure onto me too, that I need to stay behind and hold the fort as it were while he just swans off.

He told me that this is how he is, that he is a free spirit etc and he'll never be any different.

I pointed out that it sounded like he was trying to escape being a parent and a partner, he replied by saying hypothetically speaking what would that mean if it were true. I told him it would make me feel very insecure and question his commitment to me, and was it worth carrying on. He got angry with that, and said he wanted to be in a relationship and be a Dad.

Ho hum, things deteriorated after that, much of the same going round in circles, with him not understanding any of my fears and worries. I gave up in the end and went to bed.

We are still ok, the trip is still going ahead, with my blessing (he's going regardless, I may as well be included in the build-up, so I can get a grasp of the risks involved and the precautions taken). I have a lot of thinking to do. I have discussed the above with a mutual friend and his mum, and feel that he his possibly never going to compromise and it's down to me know to decide what the future holds. His mum did say, he once came to her quite upset after another failed relationship, he told her he felt he would never be able to have a long term committed relationship because he couldn't find anyone who wanted the same as him. His mum told him that most women will happily coast along for 3 years, but after that they want some show of commitment. He just didn't get it.

So there you go, not positive, but at least I now have a better insight into how he works, and hopefully I can make a choice that is the best for everyone.

OP posts:
lucykate · 03/08/2009 14:03

i've just spoken to dh about this, thought his opinion, as a fellow arty type with 2 motorbikes in the garage, would be interesting. he laughed, then said 'no way, seriously!'

he said, that the trip sounds like a great idea (but then blokes would say that), although, there are proper, official bike trekking holidays, a la 'city slickers' that you can go on, he doesn't have to go ad hoc.

but his timing stinks! why now?, why not 10 years ago when he had the freedom to be a rolling stone?

ReallyReally · 03/08/2009 14:05

you want him "to interact with me and DC when he is home"

oh dear

if he was a lovely hands on dad when he was around then fair enough, but it doesn't sound as if he is.

you can't change him, like hunker said. He has drawn up a plan for his life, based on your first post, that assumes your complete support without ever mentioning that there was going to be more than one trip.

Quite aside from the practicalities of his career choice (I know a few photographers too, very good ones, and none of them make a living full time) and his trips and their financial or insurance implications:

HE HAS NOT TRIED TO SEE YOUR POINT OF VIEW AT ALL

I would be annoyed if dh did this to me in a row about who took the bins out, not a discussion about your future

He is walking all over you. Any compromise to be made in this relationship is your compromise.

I couldn't live with a man who had so little respect for me, sorry.

My worry is that if his great and unrealistic life plan to be a free spirit and a top international photographer doesn't come off, he will blame you and the family for his failure to get it together

I wouldn't like to be around for his 50th birthday

themoon · 03/08/2009 14:09

This is a bloke who is going to get worse instead of better... Imagine him at 50 or 60...

SpankyCnut · 03/08/2009 14:09

There's a great quote, I think by Toni Morrison. When people tell you who they are, listen to them.

He's telling you loud and clear that he's selfish, thoughtless and financially irresponsible to the point of recklessness.

Now think about how you want to proceed with that information.

flashharriet · 03/08/2009 14:09

Have waded through both of these threads and am as as everybody else.

One thought occurred to me - do you think he would still go if his mother became seriously ill?

VinegarTits · 03/08/2009 14:11

The more i hear about this man the more i despise him, i have no words, he leaves me speachless, i would be running for the hills if i were you, he will never put you or your dc first in his priorites, unbealivably selfish and arrogant to think he should be allowed to treat you this way, using the excuse of being a 'free spirit'. free loader more like, seriously get rid of him.

lucykate · 03/08/2009 14:12

stellamel, are you ok?, i feel like we're beating you round the head with post after post, albeit all in support of you, but it's a lot to take in.

Tortington · 03/08/2009 14:17

i am afraid aftre reading both threads i have ran out of patience with you both.

he is by far the most actively selfish STI encrusted cock i have ever read about on here.

You have THE main job - so he can fuck about being a photographer!! jesus H christ.

he wont stop doing it

you cant go away becuase your dad had brain damage - and he knows it.

i would tell him to fuck right off and stop LEECHING OFF MY MONEY AND EMOTIONS

and the reason i have lost my patience with you in this saga - well its becuase you won't tell him to fuck off.

AitchTwoOh · 03/08/2009 14:18

yes, it's all getting a bit angry now i think. poor old stella, her world's upside down.

VivClicquot · 03/08/2009 14:18

Stellamel - when you had 'the talk', did you discuss the impact that his absence would have on your eldest child, who will no doubt still be coming to terms with the impact of having a baby brother or sister?

You've said on a couple of occasions that he's a great dad. But a great dad would not bugger off to the other side of the world, just at the time when his child might need him the most.

StealthPolarBear · 03/08/2009 14:19

yes I agree lucykate - stellamel seems to be someone who is caught in the middle, trying to keep everyone happy, us included

notwavingjustironing · 03/08/2009 14:20

I'm very impressed with the number of ways we have all managed to say exactly the same thing

If this had been posted in AIBU it would have gone down in history as the thread with the least dissent!

Alibabaandthe40nappies · 03/08/2009 14:21

Stella - everything you have said you want is in the context of him though. You are your own person, not his sidekick. And if one of the things your want is for him to interact with you and the DC when he's at home, then he isn't a great Dad.

My DH gets up with DS in the middle of the night, cuddles him, soothes him, changes him, gives him his bath every night. He rushes home from wherever he is to spend every possible minute with DS and me. That is a great Dad.

I think I may have to leave this thread because I'm getting more and more wound up and depressed. He has done such a number on you that you can't even see how much of a self-indulgent waste of space he is.

pseudoname · 03/08/2009 14:23

Keep abreast of his plans to organise his trip. But under no circumstance do you expend any more of your energies planning it for him. Place your energies into keeping your home happy for yourself and your 4yo.

You may find with this new position that he won't go anywhere as I don't believe he can plan it for himself. This turn of event could be a good or a bad thing depending on how you look at it.
--------------

"he told her he felt he would never be able to have a long term committed relationship because he couldn't find anyone who wanted the same as him."

Of course not! being in a relationship = compromise. Tough shit but unless he starts to practice some, he has made a self-prophesy and I think on some level, he know it.

lisianthus · 03/08/2009 14:27

Just one point, as I think everything else has already been said and stella seems to be having a rough enough time as it is.

Is your house owned by you and DP as joint tenants or tenants in common? If as joint tenants, it would automatically go to you if something happened to DP, so if the house is your main asset (neg. equity notwithstanding) this gives you a bit of comfort even if DP doesn't have a will. However, this does not help you out on the inheritance tax issue other posters have raised already.

And if the house is held as tenants in common, you will still have issues if DP doesn't have a will and something happens to him.

Good luck stella - this is an awful situation to be in and I really hope that it works out for you.

Lobyd · 03/08/2009 14:28

This thread makes me so sad. Angry too, but mainly sad.

I hope you work it out for the best but think about what the word 'partner' means - you're supposed to be in a partnership, sharing the good and the bad - seems he doesn't know how to do this and you deserve someone who will be there for you and your children.

All the best with whatever you decide.

FabBakerGirlIsBack · 03/08/2009 14:36

YOU are looking to see f you can find a way to make it work?

I will tell you how. He fucks off on a trip where he might not come back at all never mind in one piece while you stay at home with 2 kids wondering where that man who lives in the house is.

posieparkerinChina · 03/08/2009 14:48

Stella, copy this thread and keep it somewhere so every trip you can reread everything that's been said. IMHO I think you'll stay with him in he hope he'll change with more dcs and resposibility and my feeling is that the more commitment expected from him the less he'll want to give.

I think he's an idiot but who is the bigger fool, the fool or the one that stays with the fool?

Good luck, happy hunting for a new man.

stellamel · 03/08/2009 14:52

I'm alright, I know lots of you are frustrated by my soft arse approach, but I've got to do it this way. I must be 100% sure when I reach a decision.

I posted this update, because I promised everyone on the first thread that I would tackle him about it and let you all know because you spent a lot of time giving me good advice, sharing experiences. Also I didn't want anyone to think I was for one minute making it up or a troll

OP posts:
ErikaMaye · 03/08/2009 14:54

Stella you poor thing, I can't imagine how stressful, difficult and painful this must be for you

I read your other thread, too, and I'm really sorry that your discussion didn't work out positively, I was really hopeing he'd see your point of view.

Is there any way you can try again, switching the positions around? Ask him to consider what it would be like for him if you disappeared to the other side of the world for six weeks, leaving him to deal with your DD. The fact that you're 19 weeks pregnant as well should surely count for the fact that you need him around right now. I'm rather shocked at his disregard for your feelings in this.

I'll echo, also what has been said about finances - PLEASE ensure that if he is determind to go, that he has the funds for it. DON'T take out any money to support this "holiday".

I'm not going to say anything nasty about your partner, but please also consider how unbending he is being about his decision. Its obvious from what you've said that if he had asked you to reconsider doing anything because he wasn't comfortable with it you wouldn't hesitate to find a compromise.

Also, speaking as a daughter who's father went away to "find himself" when I was young... It destroyed me. It damn well nearly destroyed our family, financially and emotionally. Children are very perseptive, and though I was only seven, I knew something was wrong. The house didn't feel right - Mum was on edge all the time, waiting to hear he was okay (This was before mobiles, and he was in Africa), trying to hold it together for me and my very young brother. I really hope that if he won't reconsider for you, he will for the well being of your daughter.

Best of luck with everything. Stay strong. x

flashharriet · 03/08/2009 14:55

Oh stella . I'm really sorry that you're being put in this position.

But I would think about my question re his Mum becoming ill. Whether he has children or not, responsibilities towards aging relatives are an inescapable part of getting older. How do you think he would react to that happening?

StealthPolarBear · 03/08/2009 14:56

" I know lots of you are frustrated by my soft arse approach, but I've got to do it this way. I must be 100% sure when I reach a decision."
Thank you for your updates. If it gets to the stage where you thread(s) are actually making your life more stressful then come on and say so. You've asked for advice, you've been given it, I don't think you owe MN anything. Apologies if I'm getting this wrong, but if I was in your position the reading the repeated posts telling me to get rid of him and what an arse he is would be making me stressed (and I made enough of those posts myself )

expatinscotland · 03/08/2009 15:02

'Also, speaking as a daughter who's father went away to "find himself" when I was young... It destroyed me. It damn well nearly destroyed our family, financially and emotionally. Children are very perseptive, and though I was only seven, I knew something was wrong. The house didn't feel right - Mum was on edge all the time, waiting to hear he was okay (This was before mobiles, and he was in Africa), trying to hold it together for me and my very young brother. I really hope that if he won't reconsider for you, he will for the well being of your daughter.'

crumpet · 03/08/2009 15:06

One point possibly worth making is that if this is no longer a one off 40th birthday milestone event which has to be done by June , then there is no real urgency to go until the money has been saved up, so that at least the debt can be avoided.

LuluMaman · 03/08/2009 15:11

I've read both threads, did not post on the other as you had loads of brilliant advice

my two pence worth is this

divorce him

he won't compromise, he refuses to acknowledge yours and the children's needs

he feels families hold men back

once he has had 'permission' to go once, he will hvae carte blance to do whatever he wants

don't stick around waiting for him to change and be the man he ought to be