Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Could you live with your MIL?

59 replies

arabella2 · 28/04/2003 21:26

I ask because my MIL is almost 70, and despite having 6 children, lives alone. This is a recent development because until now she lived with her second son, though he hasn't officially moved out however, he spends a lot of the week at his girlfriend's and so she might go a lot of the week without seeing him. She lives in the same town as 3 of her children: the aforementioned son, and 2 of her daughters. One of these daughters comes to see her once a week but the other seems to ignore her existence unless there is a family gathering (roughly every 4 to 5 weeks). Of her 3 other kids - her youngest daughter lives abroad and has asked her if she wants to live with her but she doesn't (though she gets on with her very well, and this daughter visits several times a year, for several weeks, with both her kids and her dp), presumably because of moving so far away. Her other two sons (of which one is my dh) live in other towns in the UK.
It seems ridiculous that she should be spending so much time alone when I (for example) am at home all the time with one of her grandchildren. I feel that it would be my duty to ask her if she wants to come and live with us - she is my dh's mother etc... She is not extremely mobile (though not disabled) and she is also in need of company. I have also been wondering today whether somebody phones her every day, because if son number 2 doesn't go home for several days, how would anyone know if anything had happened to her eg: she had had a stroke or something like that.
Okay, you might ask, just ask her to come and live with you... Herein lies the problem, I would have to make a very big adjustment. I like lots of things about her and am okay with her for about 3 or 4 days in a row. If tired however, she can be extremely bossy and I think sometimes rude. I know it is normal to behave differently when in a bad mood, but it is not as if I can talk to her as if she were my family. I would lose a lot of freedom if she were to live here because she would be perforce more involved in ds's care and I don't think I could handle this. Already if she stays with us for longer than about 4 days I start to feel edgy because I get the feeling that she is the head of the family and I am one of the employees (occasionally, if she is bossy with me...). I like being in charge in my own home and do not want to be questioned about things. She does have a much softer side, but my position would undeniably change if she were to move in. She is Indian and the Indian family structure is such that the older mother does in fact have a lot of power.
I wouldn't really want to live with my own mother either, the only difference being that I could be more open with her or have fights with her without her going off in high dudgeon.
Is it selfish not to want to ask? I think it is... Ds would certainly be very happy to have another person around and he likes her and I think would certainly learn to rely on her. Does anybody live with either their parents or their in-laws? I would be interested to hear people's opinions.

OP posts:
Libby65 · 30/04/2003 12:13

Arabella2 if you REALLY have to consider it, perhaps a granny flat would be the best idea - something separate from your own home and where she could still have some independence. Otherwise I think you may find it very difficult living under the same roof.

CAM · 30/04/2003 21:59

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

kama · 29/01/2005 16:28

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

grumpyfrumpy · 29/01/2005 16:32

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sozie · 29/01/2005 16:34

Can't stomach the woman for a weekend let alone a life time. For the sake of my marriage and my sanity and freedon (as I would end up in prison) best not think about this one.

sparklymieow · 29/01/2005 16:34

NNNOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!! WAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!

trefusis · 29/01/2005 16:48

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

amynnixmum · 29/01/2005 16:51

No definately not. Not sure I'd have my parents either. I love them both and we're really close but living in the same house would put a lot of stress on our relationship. Better to live apart and actually enjoy each other's company IMO.

Merlot · 29/01/2005 16:52

Absolutely not.

nerdgirl · 29/01/2005 17:05

I always assumed that my mother would come and live with me someday too until one day she announced that under no circumstances would she do it!!

Now we get on really well - always have - so I was more than a little confused.

Apparently a very close friend of hers had her mother living with her for 20 years and even though they were both lovely people, my mother reckons that her friends life was severely limited because of her mother. My mother would just feel too guilty to do that to my family.

I pointed out that she was my mother and I would not only want to look after her (as she did for me growing up) but would feel obliged to do it. Her answer was "we repay our debt to the previous generation to the next generation" and the way I could be a good daughter was to be a good mother and much as my two DS's adore their Granny their lives would be better if she wasn't living with us.

My mother is still young (63) and active and I'm prepared to put up a fight to get her to live with us if and when the time comes but I thought she had an interesting perspective on the whole thing.

My mother would say the decision came down to this - would your DS really be better off living in a home with both you and your MIL every day?

tamum · 29/01/2005 17:18

I just read all this and thought oh hooray doormat's back posting again, and then realised that the thread is nearly two years old!

munnzieb · 29/01/2005 17:50

been there, done it wouldn't do it again.

blueteddy · 29/01/2005 17:59

NO!

Joolstoo · 29/01/2005 18:15

well she's dead now - but absolutely not.

When we were first married we lived with her for a week - on our first morning she knocked on the bedroom door and walked right in! We moved sharpish!

Amanda3266 · 29/01/2005 18:46

Yes I think I could. My MIL is lovely -don't want to annoy any of you who don't have such nice MIL's but mine is fantastic.

hercules · 29/01/2005 18:50

My mil is srilankan and similar ideas of mother being top. No way. Our marriage would not survive.

emmatmg · 29/01/2005 18:54

I honestly cannot think of anyone, in this entire world, that I would be worse than living with my MIL.

I rather live with a pack a rabid dogs!

I have serious trouble just having her in my house so to actually live with her..........My God! I would rather stick pins in my eyes.

I'll probably have nightmares for a month after just having the thought in my head.

milge · 29/01/2005 19:05

Did a week with her whilst our house was without power and water. More than enough. Not to be repeated unless we are in extremis..

Caligula · 29/01/2005 19:17

I couldn't live with my own mother, let alone ex MIL.

vict17 · 29/01/2005 19:20

No way!! (Kama seems to be resurrecting a lot of old threads today!)

MunchedTooManyMarsLady · 29/01/2005 19:20

Not even if the world was a huge radiation zone and I would die slowly and painfully if I did not enter her house!

yoyo · 29/01/2005 19:22

I definitely could live with MIL but DH could not live with his!!

Yorkiegirl · 29/01/2005 19:24

Message withdrawn

Kayleigh · 29/01/2005 19:28

Not for all the money in the world.

kama · 29/01/2005 19:44

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn