Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Want to win husband back - how do I do it?

72 replies

newlydumped · 29/04/2009 20:47

Dh announced just over a month ago that he didn't love me anymore and was leaving me and the DCs to go live with his parents.

Almost 2 months on I have gone through the hating him stage and the begging him to come home stage and now I am actually content with my life in a new home and a new routine but I miss my DH terribly and so do the DCs.

So my question to you all is how do I win him back and have any of you managed it successfully? I can manage alone but I miss him so much and never wanted to be a sinlge mum - I always had visions of a happy ever after family. This is my second marriage - the first one failing due to domestic violence and several affairs (by him not me!) so is it possible that actually its just me?

Am I meant to be alone? I hope not! Any honest opinion gratefully received......

OP posts:
missingtheaction · 30/04/2009 09:13

How To - solid gold is saying that sobbing etc are NOT the way to go if you want to win someone back. Which I heartily agree with. so we are all in violent agreement on that one.

and i think your personal swipe against sg at the end is uncalled for

HappyWoman · 30/04/2009 09:29

how to - i have done the begging and sobbing in the past and believe me you will feel worse for it.

What helped me was a book called the rules of life - it was simple and had some good things in it.

I decided that i did want my marriage to work and took some of the responsibility for its breakdown. I was determined that if my h was to leave it would be his choice to leave me and not that i had 'driven' him away.

A couple of things i 'changed' was to try and treat my h like a friend rather than take him for granted. I found things to compliment him on and make him feel good - i dont think that is weak - it is what we would do for a friend after all. Just saying something like 'you look nice' or you smell nice' is a good start. look for the positives and you will find them (after all you do love him). it is so easy to find fault and to 'nag' which is not nice.

The other tip i still use is to say sorry first - again it is not weakness the trick is to say 'sorry we argued about xyz,' and try to accept that it is ok to have different opionions too.
This actually makes you feel good - you are not saying you are wrong but making the choice not to fight over it.
When we have an arguement i will make a cup of tea and say 'sorry - lets not fight about it anymore' - however i think he has caught onto this as he is just as keen these days to 'make up' first.

Take some time to really think about what you want - and if it is your marriage then go for it.

howtotellmum · 30/04/2009 09:30

MTA- okay so we agree on soemthing!

My "personal swipe" was more an observation, said because I think SG has a rather unique persepctive on relationships - she seems to be at the opposite end of the spectrum - that's fine- but at times this can appear to indicate a lack of empathy for others whoselives are very different and, dare I say it, more conventional ( not that I am condoning or criticisng either lifestyle choice).

Kally · 30/04/2009 09:58

If you were not being being critical of SG then you really shouldn't have resorted to that last remark. SG, I think, has some of the best perspectives and her particular input on this one is what I would say also.

My marriage broke up after 26 years of slow breakdown, 3 kids, debts up to my eyeballs, in a foreign country with no support from anywhere. I wouldn't have taken my ex back had he promised me all the tea in China... He could never have won me back.

OP would be forever walking on eggshells with this man. He has already traumatised her and broken the security of the family... and walking out as he did doesn't seem galant and Fatherly... Sod off... too stressed and whatever to see his kids?? He's a bigger kid than them.

hopefullandfree · 30/04/2009 10:52

This is my second marriage - the first one failing due to domestic violence and several affairs (by him not me!) so is it possible that actually its just me?

Im concerned you ask yourself this. No, its not you, domestic viloence is never your fault and its not your fault that your husband claims you are " draining " .

Lets assume that you are in fact draining, possibly you do worry too much of what other people think.I can think of a lot worse faults !
That isnt a reason for your husband to run off to his parents.Really he should have addressed this with you and tried to work things out , counselling if necessary.

The fact he has just bailed with these feeble excuses doesnt sound like hes very commited.
Perhaps seek some counselling for yourself to help you cope with this. Dont beg and plead, you dont want someone who doesnt want you, you deserve a lot better than that.

newlydumped · 30/04/2009 11:40

some great input ladies thanks

I have suggested counselling several times but he refuses to pay for relate and won't talk to a free counsellor through church cos thats not his bag so we are at stale mate there.

He and I have fought like mad on and off over the past 18 months but tbh to me this was nothing more than stress and tiredness following a new baby and shitty pregnancy. so in a way I guess I should have seen it coming and not bee so naive.

I accept many of you seem to think he is not worth fighting for but this is the thing - to me he is. He is still the only one I have EVER felt so close to and I miss his company amongst other things.

I do probably need to consider however that he isn'[t good for me - it is damaging to ones self esteem to never get compliments and rarely be hugged. Its not his way. Although when we first met he was all over me like a limpet and has admitted he utterly worshipped the ground I walked on. He says I have changed - I haven't I have just lost a bit of confidnece and sping in my step since havign DS2. I guess once he sees me back to my old self when pg hormones are all levelled out he may reconsider.

BNut then won't it be damaging to the kids to have him back again after a long gap?

OP posts:
Longtalljosie · 30/04/2009 12:35

If he comes back he needs to make it permanent.

There is one option, which will only work in certain circumstances, but it will do you good anyway. Bear with me ladies, because it sounds like I'm going to turn into Longtallfeminismforgotme but...

  1. Get a haircut
  2. Buy new clothes he hasn't seen and wear them when you meet up. Not expensive, just different. He may not know why you look different, but it will register.
  3. Have a friend call you when he's there and don't say who it is unless he asks. If he asks, say though - I'm not advocating completely messing with his head.
  4. Join a club / activity of some description (I know babysitting may be an issue, but try).

All this gives the impression you're doing just fine and moving on. That will revert a lot of the power back to you. At the moment he knows he can have you back any time he wants - which means he's not really thinking about what you and the children mean to him. If he feels you may be carving out your own life, he may have to consider what his life is like.

As I say, it might work or might not. A lot will depend on whether he's being an idiot - or whether he genuinely wants to move on. Even if doesn't work, it will also make you feel better about yourself, so good all round...

solidgoldSneezeLikeApig · 30/04/2009 12:35

ND: it sounds very much as though he doesn't want to come back, and that trying to persuade him to do so will only hurt you. You may love him, but he clearly doesn't love you in the same way, and if he doesn;t by now he never will, so even if you get him to come back by appealing to his sense of duty, you will never be able to relax because you will always be aware that he is there reluctantly. Far better to do without him.

Overmydeadbody · 30/04/2009 12:50

I completely agree with SG.

newlydumped I am sorry you are in this situation but I think there is nothing you can do to try to 'win him back' apart from give him time while getting on with your life.

And just becuase this relationship has broken down doesn't mean you are meant to be alone! there are plenty of men out there...

Kally · 30/04/2009 12:51

But WHY does she have to be manipulative LongTall? What happens when that all becomes old hat and faded? Then she'll have to work out new strategies to keep him amused and happy? No, no, she has to build herself up for herself, not him. He's more or less told her he can't be arsed, and not wanting to see the kids would put a damper on it for me. What have they done wrong? He's being very selfish and shortsighted.

Just tell yourself newlydumped... can you tolerate a lifetime of always accomodating his whims? You've got children to think about and beleive me it won't be easy always being scared he'll run off back to Mummy and Daddy again at the slightest shuffle on your part. I would find that absolutely exhausting.

Overmydeadbody · 30/04/2009 12:56

Would you really want to get back with him knowing he didn't really, in his heart, want to be with you but was doing it for the sake of the children?

TimorousWeeBeastie · 30/04/2009 12:57

This isnt the 1st time you have split - how did you "win him back" last time? Would that work again now?

newlydumped · 30/04/2009 14:21

timourous - no flies on you madam - even with a name change! last time in all honesty I started getting out there again - got a few dates organised through the internet and was on one when he bumped into me!

Just shows this is all great advice from you guys - getting on with life - which longtall I agree does include new hair and clothes etc - I am classic for "letting myself go" after a baby as I am usually utterly knackered and of course hacve to be the best mum on the planet which involves not leavign the childs side for a second and not letting them take ANY risks at all. Did the same with DS1......

SO ok I see where I need to go from here. I have stayed freindly and civil for the kids and also to keep communicatino channels open

I do have to think carefull tho - he may not be good for me - and I need to consider my future with care. He would have much to prove before allowing him back -

OP posts:
TimorousWeeBeastie · 30/04/2009 14:24

I think the whole makeover thing is a great idea, especially for your self-esteem just now!

TimorousWeeBeastie · 30/04/2009 14:25

Take the time that DH has the DC to do something for yourself, no work, just relaxing & being YOU

RumourOfAHurricane · 30/04/2009 14:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn

newlydumped · 30/04/2009 14:33

not bad idea shine - will have to think of something witty now!!!

OP posts:
JiminyCricket · 30/04/2009 14:33

you can't control or win someone back, but you can be grown up and warm to someone - more attractive than needy or trying too hard

thesilverlining · 30/04/2009 14:37

shineon - that better?!

jiminy - yes its rather pathetic i realise that - but have had really low days and guess i need reminding from time to time

TimorousWeeBeastie · 30/04/2009 15:52

some tips, if you really want to go down that route, could be to remind him of why you got together in the place? Wear a perfume you wore back then, maybe ask him out on a date, hold eye contact with him when you chat?

Though as you know, Id rather you moved on to bigger and better things

solidgoldSneezeLikeApig · 30/04/2009 19:08

If you behave as though you couldn't give a toss whether he comes back or not, and as though your life as a single person is great, while always remaining polite to him when you have to be in contact re DC, you will soon start to feel better off without him. Because TBH he doesn;t sound worth making any effort for, he's made none for you.

thesilverlining · 30/04/2009 19:12

solid - good point - actually even just today I am questioning why it is i want him back so much - it could be the IDEA of him iykwim rather than the actual him.....hmm not sure......but definately willing to take advice from here about not giving a toss - its true i think it'll do wonders for my confidence

notbeenaround · 30/04/2009 20:07

have been exactly in your situation and really feel for you, dh and I are back together after he walked out and was gone for about 5mths (no one else involved i should add). I can tell you what definitely does not work at trying to get someone back is begging/pleading/crying/pursuing/getting angry/shouting.

All the advice given is pretty damn good and I would say go with new haircut/colour and some new clothes, let him see you have a life. Once I stopped begging dh to come home and started to accept we were over then thats when things gradually started changing (from his side) we were doing relate but purely to split on good terms (hahahaha!!!!) and that actually turned things round for us. Maybe suggest that to your dh and that may get him thinking about going.

HappyWoman recommends a good book which I've got and I can also recommend "I love you but I'm not in love with you" written by a relate counsellor. All in all I would say take this time to focus on you and your needs and that of your children, if its meant to be it will.

thesilverlining · 30/04/2009 20:27

notbeen - thank you for sharing - its good to know someone has managed to get it back on track!!!

idontlikethisperson · 01/05/2009 09:39

Hi there thesilverlining

I read your thread and am thinking of you.
Let me tell you about my situation, although a little different, it might give you some perspective...so sit tight, it's a long one.

My H and I split over a year ago, out of the blue (I have posted on MN before under a different name). I became shamelessly needy, distraught, determined to win him back. He did come back, and also had a fling with someone else 2 weeks after he left, which he only told me about bit by bit and most of it the day before we were due to go away to make a go of it.

Because I wanted it to work soooooo much I accepted it. I say accepted but I was devastated. I spent months feeling anger, hurt, upset, distrust etc. It didn't make things any better. I now realise I was suffering depression due to all of this.

Last December (a year after he initially left) it happened again. He wanted to break up. (No fling this time though). After a couple of months of him sleeping in the spare room, he moved out. He's been gone for two months now.

I've been having counselling for the last two months. I've learnt a few things about myself. One of them being the reason I wanted him back is not just because I loved him but because I didn't want our family to split up, I didn't want bad things to happen to our family, I wanted to control everything to stop awful things happening. I wanted everything to be alright.

I'm a generally anxious person anyway, always worried about what people think, always stopping myself from doing stuff because of the what ifs, generally being overcautious.

As a result (and you'll see my thread on the mental health board), I have recently suffered a pretty major bout of depression and anxiety with a lovely helping of OCD.

This comes from not taking care of myself. By that I mean I spent so many months thinking what could I do to make it better, why doesn't he love me, what if he meets someone else (awful awful feeling, I know), what is he doing at the moment...... Instead of thinking, I need to take care of myself.

In addition, you can't take all the blame for your relationship breakdown. There's two adults involved. Yes you may have not been perfect but no relationship ever is.

You have to ask yourself what man leaves his kids? I know marriage is tough, but when you've made the commitment, you need to work it out. He nay be stressed and exhausted, but so are you. His line of thinking is selfish - like my H. I know it's hard to accept because you love him, and I love my H too, but he didn't really consider what it would be like to leave you raising the kids on your own, did he? He didn't really think about the kids future, did he? I'm not talking about staying together for the sake of the kids, I talking about achieving something amazing by making your relationship work. He's just not interested at present.

That's not to say he'll never be, but at present his mind is elsewhere and he's being an idiot to give excuses.

So please please please take care of yourself. Its awful and hard at present, I've had the worst couple of months ever, but a lot of that is my own fault, by not allowing myself to grieve, by not allowing myself to ask for help from others, trying to control the situation (i.e. by thinking, what can I do to win him back, how can I make it better?) . Now is not the time to be thinking that, now is the time to be taking care of you. Get some counselling. Get some time off.

You might surprise yourself.

If you do that a maintain a friendship (I dont mean agreeing with everything he says or making yourself feel super nice all the time) with your H, then you don't know what will happen - he may just need this time away.

By the way, another thing I learnt was:
Don't suppress your emotions. If you are angry with him, don't hold back. If you are sad, don't hold back. You are entitled to feel however you want to feel. He can't expect everything to be all happy and smiley (my H does). Life's not like that. Don't hold back just because you are worried what they think or because you're worried you will scare him away. I have suffered greatly mentally because of that. You've gone through a great deal..Dont deny it.

If not, you have your dignity. Please don't lose it like I did. My mental health has suffered immensely and I'm taking tiny pigeon steps, trying to reach the old me. Its painful.

I'm sorry if this is a lecture. I know I never wanted this to happen to me, but it has. There's nothing I can do to change his mind or control the situation. The only thing I can do is look after me and change the way I feel.

Hugs x

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is closed and is no longer accepting replies. Click here to start a new thread.