Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

DP proposing MIL lives with us, I couldn't stand it

52 replies

FattipuffsandThinnifers · 03/11/2008 18:25

Not sure if this is the right place to put this, but here goes. MIL is long-term depressed, and though is only in her early 70s is in a care home as she couldn't cope in her own house. There is a terrible family history - DP's twin brother was killed in a car accident when they were 12, his dad died 9 years ago, then his sister died of cancer 7 years ago. DP is now the only remaining child, and they have no other close relatives, MIL is an only child and FIL's relatives all live abroad.

His mum had always been prone to depression throughout her life, but understandably, these events triggered severe depression/mild psychosis, and he made the decision to put her in a home 3 years ago. She is stable, but very withdrawn and has no interest in life (not even her grandson really).

But, her depression aside, she is a very difficult person. She was really controlling of DP when growing up, and he has had a very difficult relationship with her throughout his life - mixture of guilt and resentment. This was the case before the bereavement, btw. The guilt has no doubt increased since though.

She is ultra-religious (he was brought up so but rebelled when a teenager), her life revolves around the church, and she has always disapproved of me for being non-Christian. There are many things which to me smack of hypocrisy though - I don't equate being religious with being 'good', I think being good makes you good.

She is just really really hard to be with. I am not a partiuclarly impatient person but I find even a few hours with her trying.

Our absolute dream house is on the market - slightly beyond our realistic budget. DP has just announced that he would go for it if his mum was to live with us.

He feels lots of guilt about her situation - understandably so, and I think it would ease his conscience if she were to live with us. I can understand and sympathise with this.

But this has really freaked me out - think my instinctive reaction is horror

Not only would it be a nightmare for me personally (for reasons above) I also could not cope personally with being a carer. It is just not in me. Let alone caring for someone with depression - I would feel totally unqualified to deal with this.

It would also have such huge implications for the rest of our lives. I am currently a SAHM but at some point am assuming I'll go back to work (when DS is at nursery probably). I also want another DC but DP is not sure. If we had taken on such a big financial, and emotional commitment I am sure he would be even more reluctant to have another.

I just don't know what to do - I feel terrible, really selfish and uncompassionate, but this is just not what I want for any of us, and tbh I would just hate every minute of it. Am I a horrible person? What should I do? I would much rather not have the house if it is on these terms. And part of me feels DP is emotionally manipulating me by saying this.

Sorry this is soooo long, if you have got this far, thank you for listening.

OP posts:
tryingherbest · 04/11/2008 22:11

My paternal gran came to live with us and it was a disaster.

She was a lovely lady but the relationship between her and my mum just broke down.

My dad got her to sell her flat with the idea we'd buy a bigger property. Gran, quite rightly, insisted the the bigger property have her name on it. Well, she sold, came to live with us and the bigger property never materialised.

Not only that - within a year she needed a proper nursing home.

Parents since divorced.

I do believe you should where possilbe look after aging parents but it can really unbalance a marriage. Two women in one house just doesn't seem to work.

2rebecca · 11/11/2008 00:01

If she's always been miserable and withdrawn alot of this will be personality not illness. If she's now withdrawn alot is there some dementia there as well? It doesn't sound as though she will be any happier if she lives with you, as it sounds as though she has little capacity for happiness. It does however sound as though you will be more miserable.
Your husband then has 2 miserable women in his life rather than one. It's a no brainer really. To be honest if I become withdrawn and miserable in my old age the last thing I'd want my son to do is bring me to live with him so I can drag him and his family down with me, same if I get dementia.
It's a shame so many people feel guilty when their severely ill relatives are in care homes.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page