Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Would you accept this money?

57 replies

money26 · Today 14:14

I live alone and am sort of seeing a guy (it’s complicated) for a while, we’ve known each other a long time
he earns more than me and is living with his parent while he saves to buy a house (I already own)
his parent won’t allow visitors so he always comes to mine on average twice a week. He’s said as I cook, he uses my hot water for showers, drinks out the fridge, snacks, food etc he feels like he should pay something towards things and has offered £100pm

I cook usually as I enjoy it but if we get a takeaway he pays and will bring sweets/chocolate for me

I feel £100pm is too much, he says he doesn’t want to be a drain on me

OP posts:
Lotsofthings · Today 17:00

Accept the £100. Upgrade to fancier recipes to cook occasionally if you fancy it. I hope you have at least visited his house and met parent.

Headflip · Today 17:07

I'd probably prefer it if he contributed in a way that lightens my load a bit, rather than just handing over cash, but yes he should be contributing. If you're "sort of" seeing him, I don't think I'd want a formal monthly arrangement. My BF is in a similar position and recognises he benefits from my labour as well as my money, so he will e.g. bring dinner and help with the garden.

£25 pw is not too much if you're feeding him a few times.

HumbleStumble · Today 17:28

Red flag. Get rid.

MurphysColeslaw · Today 17:33

I know it’s not the point if this thread, but does he have an older brother?

WhoWhereWhenWhyHow · Today 17:41

A man with self respect and dignity. How refreshing

Hadalifeonce · Today 17:44

That's only about £12.50 per visit, so not a huge amount in the scheme of things. Equivalent to a bottle of wine or a couple of pints.

OneHazelBird · Today 17:45

Honestly I would be a little bit concerned about this but maybe I’m too cynical.

I’d be concerned that he is trying to buy his way into your home.

Lots of people have to live back with their parents but sometimes this can be a sign of not being able to live alone.

I would accept it (or ask for a smaller amount) but be mindful of his intentions.

How long has he been separated from his ex?

PrincessofWills · Today 17:46

Why not just do the weekly shop together and split the cost . . .

Bunnychubbers · Today 17:46

So he visits twice a week and pays for takeaway? No, I don’t think he needs to contribute anything else. If the situation was reversed how many people would think they should pay a boyfriend they stayed with twice a week? If he was there 4 nights a week or more then yes, at that point it would be reasonable. It’s thoughtful of him to offer, but also quite odd, as is the fact he says his parents forbid visitors. Are you sure he’s not hiding something?

Holliegee · Today 17:52

I think that you e found yourself a really decent bloke, there could be many reasons he can’t have guests at his parents house so by, staying with you each weekend it gives you time together.
if that wasn’t possible you’d perhaps have to stay in a hotel or something, so it’s really comfortable that he can stay at yours.
He doesn’t want to take advantage of your hospitality and wants to pay towards it so it’s the start of a ‘serious’ element to your relationship that you both share the costs.

money26 · Today 17:59

BillieWiper · Today 16:42

I'm afraid the sheer fact he's not permitted to bring visitors even to his own bedroom at his parents house is extremely odd. The fact he would tolerate that as a living arrangement for a grown man.

It's just not normal is it? Most 17 year olds would kick up a stink if they weren't allowed overnight visitors at least sometimes. And most four year olds are allowed friends round during the day?!

Have you seen his house? Is it definitely just his parents he lives with? I'd be thinking he's either married or he's way too enmeshed and infantilised by his parents.

He’s not married, I’ve known him since 2012. It was an unfortunate set of circumstances where he ended up living back at home which I won’t go into as it is too outing. He was never allowed even as a child

OP posts:
money26 · Today 18:00

OneHazelBird · Today 17:45

Honestly I would be a little bit concerned about this but maybe I’m too cynical.

I’d be concerned that he is trying to buy his way into your home.

Lots of people have to live back with their parents but sometimes this can be a sign of not being able to live alone.

I would accept it (or ask for a smaller amount) but be mindful of his intentions.

How long has he been separated from his ex?

His last relationship was around 5 years ago

OP posts:
Sunbringer · Today 18:00

No I wouldn’t, I’d appreciate the offer but tell him to spend it on taking me out :)

money26 · Today 18:02

Chasingsquirrels · Today 15:48

I think £100 probably covers increased costs if you actually worked it all out, or might not even - but then he is getting takeaways as well.

Unless he has significant other expenses in maintaining your relationship (long distance and he does all the travelling) then I'd happily accept the £100pm.

Travelling yes - not long distance but he does live around 45 mins from me so fuel when he drives over

OP posts:
Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 18:03

money26 · Today 14:14

I live alone and am sort of seeing a guy (it’s complicated) for a while, we’ve known each other a long time
he earns more than me and is living with his parent while he saves to buy a house (I already own)
his parent won’t allow visitors so he always comes to mine on average twice a week. He’s said as I cook, he uses my hot water for showers, drinks out the fridge, snacks, food etc he feels like he should pay something towards things and has offered £100pm

I cook usually as I enjoy it but if we get a takeaway he pays and will bring sweets/chocolate for me

I feel £100pm is too much, he says he doesn’t want to be a drain on me

He sounds really kind and considerate - I’d accept but then use the money to maybe buy nice ingredients to cook and a nice bottle of wine maybe.

money26 · Today 18:05

Bunnychubbers · Today 17:46

So he visits twice a week and pays for takeaway? No, I don’t think he needs to contribute anything else. If the situation was reversed how many people would think they should pay a boyfriend they stayed with twice a week? If he was there 4 nights a week or more then yes, at that point it would be reasonable. It’s thoughtful of him to offer, but also quite odd, as is the fact he says his parents forbid visitors. Are you sure he’s not hiding something?

100% positive. I’ve known him as a friend prior to this

OP posts:
OneHazelBird · Today 18:10

money26 · Today 18:02

Travelling yes - not long distance but he does live around 45 mins from me so fuel when he drives over

When I used to travel to my bfs he’d want to pay for everything as he said I’m the one doing the travelling.

Obviously it’s completely up to you how much you take but I wouldn’t want to go to his with his parents there and so I’d think it was pretty even cost-wise.

As a PP said, why not go shopping together and split the cost or split the takeaway etc.

money26 · Today 18:13

Mossyfox · Today 16:27

Are you sure he lives with his parents.

100%

OP posts:
BillieWiper · Today 18:46

money26 · Today 17:59

He’s not married, I’ve known him since 2012. It was an unfortunate set of circumstances where he ended up living back at home which I won’t go into as it is too outing. He was never allowed even as a child

Ok but it's not acceptable to live that way as an adult. How can he expect to conduct grown up relationships when he literally cannot have a partner or friend inside his home ever?

money26 · Today 18:54

BillieWiper · Today 18:46

Ok but it's not acceptable to live that way as an adult. How can he expect to conduct grown up relationships when he literally cannot have a partner or friend inside his home ever?

It’s not my issue to question though, that’s between him and his parent. It is part of the reason why he wants to move out but at present he has to stick by her rules while he’s at home
I can’t get wound up over something I can’t change

OP posts:
BotterMon · Today 18:56

He's the opposite of a cocklodger and sounds rather wonderful. Accept gracefully.

Boreded · Today 18:58

Pumpkindoodles · Today 14:33

I think it’s fine. £25 a week in food and utilities isn’t much. Even less in a 5 week month:
Why don’t you take it and save it if you think it’s too much, don’t tell him and you could treat you both to a little weekend away after a year or treat you both to a few more takeaways or days out or something nice for his house once he’s bought it. Or put it into a savings account to put towards your future together
I don’t think you need to do that, but maybe that will make you feel better about it.

I was actually going to say the same thing. Tell him you’ll take it, but that you’ll be putting it aside for something together, like a holiday etc

Motnight · Today 19:00

DanaScullysLegoHair · Today 16:25

This is a nice idea. The big 'treat' 🙂

Take the money, OP.

Agree!

NameChangeScot · Today 19:06

It's really thoughtful of him.

If you don't actually need the money why don't you save it and use it for a treat for you both when it builds up, a little break away or wedding fund, or whatever you both enjoy.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · Today 19:09

£23 is not a lot.
and you could sometimes make a better meal than a cheap one .