What tossers men are sometimes. Really feel for all of you with horror stories about big babies who refuse to be men. I know because I had one of them myself. This is just my experience but FWIW, treating them mean does do the trick. If they still love you, which my dp does.
It really struck a chord, LG, when you said on your post today that he left the house mournfully saying you really needed 'to think about what you want'. In the past that too was my cue to feel afraid and be all appeasing or else... Trouble is, baby-men just get the message that whatever immature thing/s they have done is OK because nothing happens apart from nagging and tears (some men see this as a simple side effect of life with a woman... bless).
My dp would threaten to leave if I told him the harsh truth too long and too hard and because I was afraid of being left alone with one, then two, little kids it was always me that backed down. But one day, after about the tillienth row about his laziness, selfishness, disrespectfullness etc something just turned over in me and when he said he'd leave then, I just said yes, I think that's a good idea. His face. Wish I'd had a camera. Seeing his reaction just gave me more strength and I went for it. Told him to leave and when he didn't, insisted. He left that evening a broken man and spent the next two weeks coming round every day after work, cooking dinner, taking the kids out all weekend to give me a break, telling me how much he loved me and what a t**t he'd been. He suggested Relate (something I had wanted for years) and at that point I said OK, come back but if you EVER give me cause to feel this way again, that is it.
What we did saved our relationship and I can honestly say that I am now happier than I have ever been. He, though far from perfect , has now grown up and takes his partner and family seriously. Relate was fantastic and I now feel that we will be together for the rest of our lives. It is an unfortunate truth, IMO, that baby-men cannot grow up on their own, they have to be made to.
Big hugs and strength to all of you in the same situation xxx