Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Silly reason to break up with someone?

84 replies

throwaway3749574 · 02/08/2026 05:23

Boyfriend/DP of about 3 years, my first proper relationship post divorce, and his post becoming a widower suddenly. We’re both mid forties.

I know that I can bring the relationship to an end for any reason, but I’m worried if I do I’ll regret it and that this is more of a “me” issue.

in my DP/boyfriend I have someone who is respectful, feminist, sensitive (mostly - or at least wants to be), listens to me, supportive, we have a good level of sex and it’s satisfying (if a little samey). It’s a warm loving relationship with a good underlying friendship. He has no controlling tendencies. We’re financially suited, live near each other and are on the same page re. not wanting to blend families and kids coming first (teens).
basically, I know in reality I’m lucky to have met him in my 40s and he is a good prospect compared to many available men on OLD in their 40s and 50s!

a recurring issue is that I feel he doesn’t compliment me enough. I’m rolling my eyes at myself as I write that as it sounds really egotistical. But he doesn’t make me feel like he wants me or fancies me, other than “in the moment” when we have sex which is usually quite scheduled due to the realities of when we have an empty house between us.

he says nice things…. But it always feels a bit “gay best friend” or what he’d say to his sister.

im away on a cruise and I sent him a pic of me and my kids on formal night, in a posh dress, made a real effort. He said “oooh so glitzy glam!”

am I ridiculous that I’d love it if he told me I looked amazing in my dress? Or something else that made me feel like he fancies me?

we’ve consciously wanted to have a relationship where we talk to each other about how we’re feeling and air grievances or niggles as neither of us had that in our marriages.

but it’s hard! How many times do you raise the same thing if it doesn’t change? I’ve told him how much I like it when he’s physically affectionate at “non sex times” but it’s not really improved. We have lovely warm cuddles on the sofa but I sometimes come away from his at the weekend realising we didn’t kiss properly all weekend. I’d love him to stroke my bum or get down to some proper heavy petting on the sofa but it’s very rare unless we’re doing it all.

what do I do?
it’s a recurring niggle and gut feeling something is missing. But I can foresee ending it and regretting it as in many ways he is a great partner especially heading into older years.

OP posts:
hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:08

cloudtreecarpet · 02/08/2026 15:48

"Dating is like voting" then you say something about catching buses? 😂

Sorry that you’re unaware of this very well know metaphor

Silly reason to break up with someone?
HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:19

dating is like voting - you just have to catch the bus that takes you closest to the destination you want to go to.

makes bugger all sense

SilenceLaySteadily · 02/08/2026 16:24

Breakup and get yourself on OLD. There'll be hundreds of porn-brained, insecure, selfish manchildren who'll tell you how sexy you are in your formal dress.

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:38

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:19

dating is like voting - you just have to catch the bus that takes you closest to the destination you want to go to.

makes bugger all sense

.

Silly reason to break up with someone?
hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:39

Also, op, don’t forget that there are a lot of unhappily married posters on MN who resent people going on to find happiness after having the courage to divorce which they themselves don’t have.

They’ll happily pop up to rain on your post divorce parade.

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:39

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:38

.

And this proves what? No source. Just a random photo 😆

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:43

My DP isn’t kind, loyal, devoted to me. We are a team and help each other out myriad ways that make the whole single parent experience so much easier to handle.

did you mean that your DP is kind, loyal and devoted @hebelievesinabeauty

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:44

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:39

Also, op, don’t forget that there are a lot of unhappily married posters on MN who resent people going on to find happiness after having the courage to divorce which they themselves don’t have.

They’ll happily pop up to rain on your post divorce parade.

Who has on this thread?

No one

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:48

bowtieandheels · 02/08/2026 10:12

I could have written this post myself, the only difference is that my partner doesn’t have kids. We don’t live together and have been in a relationship for 12 years now. He’s the most wonderful man in pretty much all ways, apart from his inability to compliment and not sound like my grandma!
This became quite a big deal to me early in the relationship, I wanted to be lusted after and feel like he desired me. I don’t think that’s an unreasonable thing to want, particularly in our 40s when we might be starting to feel a bit invisible in the wider world. In the end after many discussions I’ve had to accept that this just isn’t his way, he also doesn’t ever make me feel like he’s eyeing up other women, he never comments on anyone else looking good (or otherwise) and just doesn’t seem to see people in that way. In most other ways he’s the best person I’ve ever met, so that’s the compromise I’ve accepted. Oh and also he never ever has any problem getting it up and we have great sex, so I take that as a clear sign he’s attracted to me.

100 percent this.

I like that my DP doesn’t objectify me or other women. He sees me as en entire person not just someone sexual (although we do have great sex).

I would never consider this a relationship dealbreaker.

UpDownAllAround1 · 02/08/2026 16:49

you have answered your own question. How
about considering initiating the petting and stroking?

SwedishEdith · 02/08/2026 16:50

Do actually fancy him? You haven't said. If you do, why aren't you initiating the kissing etc? I also think a pp was right that an overtly sexual comment about the photo with your kids in seems inappropriate so would be one reason he kept it bland. But those "you look gorgeous/amazing" etc comments take 2 seconds so don't represent anything deep really.

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 16:51

SwedishEdith · 02/08/2026 16:50

Do actually fancy him? You haven't said. If you do, why aren't you initiating the kissing etc? I also think a pp was right that an overtly sexual comment about the photo with your kids in seems inappropriate so would be one reason he kept it bland. But those "you look gorgeous/amazing" etc comments take 2 seconds so don't represent anything deep really.

Exactly my point

He doesn’t seem to fancy the Op

but the Op doesn’t seem to fancy him either!

Gamerlady · 02/08/2026 16:54

Men are not mind readers you need to tell him what you want. You sound high maintenance wanting compliments all the time , he sounds a really nice guy , you're the one making issues over nothing really.

cloudtreecarpet · 02/08/2026 17:01

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:08

Sorry that you’re unaware of this very well know metaphor

Nope never heard of it but think it needed a bit more explanation anyway when applied to this scenario. 🤷‍♀️

cloudtreecarpet · 02/08/2026 17:03

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 16:39

Also, op, don’t forget that there are a lot of unhappily married posters on MN who resent people going on to find happiness after having the courage to divorce which they themselves don’t have.

They’ll happily pop up to rain on your post divorce parade.

Have you actually read the thread?
I don't think people have done this in the slightest, in fact most people have told the OP she is lucky to have found a decent bloke and to think carefully before ending it over this issue.

Maybe you posted on the wrong thread?

Bonden · 02/08/2026 17:06

Did your husband behave in that way? I wonder if that is something you’re hoping to have replicated, and also that that level of feedback on how attractive you are to him is maybe about your own aging and how you’re coming to terms with that.

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 17:46

cloudtreecarpet · 02/08/2026 17:03

Have you actually read the thread?
I don't think people have done this in the slightest, in fact most people have told the OP she is lucky to have found a decent bloke and to think carefully before ending it over this issue.

Maybe you posted on the wrong thread?

Not one has. No idea what @hebelievesinabeauty is going on about here… not this thread that’s for sure!

LarkspurBlues · 02/08/2026 18:58

I get it OP. I dated someone like this after my marriage and he seemed sometimes a bit lukewarm or impersonal. A cheerleader but not linking to me especially. Not totally motivated by attraction unless in certain compartmentalised zones. He turned out to have weird commitment issues, though he had a 2-yr breakdown after we parted. I described him to a friend as ‘emotionally starving me’. I never look back fondly.

HwalkingL · 02/08/2026 19:23

LarkspurBlues · 02/08/2026 18:58

I get it OP. I dated someone like this after my marriage and he seemed sometimes a bit lukewarm or impersonal. A cheerleader but not linking to me especially. Not totally motivated by attraction unless in certain compartmentalised zones. He turned out to have weird commitment issues, though he had a 2-yr breakdown after we parted. I described him to a friend as ‘emotionally starving me’. I never look back fondly.

He just sounds like he wasn’t very interested
why did you stay with someone for 2 years who seemed so disinterested?

MaggiesShadow · 02/08/2026 19:28

In the scheme of what you've described it does seem a bit silly and has me wondering if you're looking for a reason.

Equally, it's fine to say that you're not getting what you need from the relationship and move on. Some people's energy just doesn't quite match.

Do you actually wonder about his sexuality? I wonder because you mentioned gay best friend vibes and lack of physical intimacy outside of sex.

suburberphobe · 02/08/2026 19:50

He's sexually hung up as in loads to unpick here.

I couldn't have sex with a guy whose son is living there, even if far away. (House must be huge).
He will know it's happening.

If you don't have a connection both mentally or sexually, why bother? Sorry OP.

suburberphobe · 02/08/2026 19:52

Forgot to say, you deserve so much better.
Love yourself.

Newsenmum · 02/08/2026 19:55

Nobody is perfect and there are always going to be things that annoy you. Do you actually love him?
And you need to keep telling him. Do you think it’s deeper than words though. Are you actually worried he doesnt feel lust towards you?

Supporting2026 · 02/08/2026 19:59

Respectively this feels more like a self esteem issue at your end not a reason to break up your relationship. It's one thing to wish he was communicative in this area - but if it gets to you so much that you'd terminate an otherwise extremely good relationship you seem to want to be in then it feels like a personal issue I'd try and work out and address first in yourself.

hebelievesinabeauty · 02/08/2026 20:30

cloudtreecarpet · 02/08/2026 17:01

Nope never heard of it but think it needed a bit more explanation anyway when applied to this scenario. 🤷‍♀️

You then got the explanation. Not sure what more you want if I’m honest. Scroll on if you can’t follow